Let me explain why I asked the question:
*** It is not that I have any lack of faith in the people of Assam. As individuals, they are just like us. But I see a huge problem with the way they run or are required to run, the affairs of choosing candidates for democratic elections, how it is funded, how the elected people get to become MANAGERS of massive operations, issues they have little knowledge of or experience with.
The IAS, ACS types, the administrators, are reduced to, by and large, go-fers for the real power wielders--the ministers and other elected reps.
The STATE being the biggest employer, wield enormous influence on the lives of society, preventing even the most upstanding and able individuals from asserting themselves, should there be conflicts of interests.In the absence of a system of justice that could be depended on to intervene in a timely manner, to provide support for those who attempt to change things for better, but might be resisted by vested interests, no few would dare to resist. One has to make a living, and support a family.
So on and so forth. I can go on and on.
Under the circumstances, it is highly unlikely to see(C)taking place. Even(A), could reasonably be expected to continue to erode, like we have witnessed in our lifetime, turning into (B).
To reasonably expect to see even a slow turnaround for the better we will have to look for a trend. Where is that trend to be seen? Where has there been ANY attempt to improve or change the institutions that have been the problems?
I hear our NRA brethren admonishing Assam youth to go into business. Do you know what the interest rates are like for capital? I hear it is over 10%, for the BEST customers with a good track record.
And do you know what it takes to get a loan? It is unbelievably complicated for someone who is NOT a part of the cartels and for those who don't have those 'connections'.
Again, so on and so forth.
Finally,people should be able to expect meaningful reforms within the system operating. But if that were possible, we would have seen trends.
However such could be effected in a system where Assam has freedoms to devise such, within the Indian Union. Autonomy of the RIGHT kind could make that possible.
Of course sovereignty would allow unlimited freedom to radically re-orient Assam governance, incorporating the world's best ideas, applicable to Assam's circumstances.
*** You mentioned that most NRAs might be frightened away from the last option. In other words, even if the best system is put together in an 'independent' Assam, people still would not want it--mainly perhaps they will be
uncertain of its viability. Did I read you right?
Do you think it is because people might think that in such a circumstance ULFA would dictate things, without bringing on board the best that Assam can offer? Or would it be because people are so attached to India, that no matter what, they would not want such a breach? Or would it be because they would be seriously worried about an independent Assam's viability?
c-da
At 10:47 AM -0800 2/8/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,
Or to rephrase it more directly: That NRAS really have no faith in Assam Govts, be it the current one, be it the past ones, or be it some future one, based on the current model. I know I am asking you to comment on something that MIGHT reflect negatively on your own beliefs. And as an incentive ...
First of all, I am not all worried about how any comment I make on this subject is reflected. I am just going to express my thoughts. It may not be the correct assessment, but I will give it my best shot. I fully undertand my limitations -:).
I am not at all beholden to the Assam Govt. or the Center. If there is truth to be told, it should be.
Now, do NRAs have faith in the governance in Assam? I don't about others, but my feeling is though, there is a lot to be desired, and a lot does need to be done, NRAs do have faith with certain reservations. I would venture, that NRAs might think that they could at least attempt to work with current system.
There is the bureaucracy, the misuse of money, etc, etc. No, I do wish things could be better, and I do wish things at Delhi could be better.
But that is the system we have at the moment. For the future, there are basically a only few options (a) things could remain the same (b) things could get worse (c) things could get better
We all wish/want (C) above. If thats impossible (for whatever reason) then obviously (a). We definitely don't want (b).
Now, I think the fundamental difference people may have is HOW to reach this improved model?
So, inspite of all the problems we have with the State Govt. or Center, I feel that over time there could be improvements. While the process is frustrating, and people do not see marked improvements sooner, one can actually place some faith in a democratic system, which has at least the basic infrastructure in place.
But they might have such faith in a future REFORMED one?
Absolutely, but the question is will they have the same faith if this future govt. is outside of Indian governance. You might see some fast dwindling of 'faith' there. But if you are talking about vastly improving the present Assam Govt. - most should agree with you.
Does that help answer your question, C'da?
-Ram
--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> on the threadsRam:
>I was confused a little, because from some of your >posts, I got the impression that the issues we are >trying to understand (vis-a-vis Assam) MIGHT be >construed as being condescending.
*** It was not my intent to somehow portray Rajen as some kind of a self-impressed megalomaniac. Nothing could be further from the truth. I know his intentions are and have always been most honorable. I can say that with sincerity because I know him personally, just like I know you and so many others here in the net where we disagree and engage in heated debates.
We all tend to lose our cools occasionally, indulge in hyperbole, and so forth. I know I indulge far too often on sarcasm for one thing, knowing full well it is not an admirable trait.
Having said that, I will not be candid if I did not say that our debates often cannot rise to a desired level of objectivity, because we get bogged down with our biases, leading us to play 'no-comprendo', or resorting to specious arguments, or avoiding responding to issues and at times obvious evasiveness and so forth. As a result, all the intelligence here go to waste, because we fail to close the loops> to tell themof a discussion.
I have one suggestion to netters for consideration in that context:
*** If we intend to let the chips fall where they may with our discussions and analyses, and thus contribute something meaningful towards HELPING the people of Assam to make intelligent decisions about what is right for them, then we might be able to overcome our self-imposed obstacles.
One thing that I have found very helpful is a realization that I do not have to be right about anything. It helps if I am, but I am free to be wrong, free to make errors. That makes it easy for me to accept it when someone presents a better argument, or corrects my erroneous perceptions. Surely WE ALL are much more than what we portray ourselves as in Assam Net. It is such a small part of our beings.
Simply put, our sense humility should be an asset, not a burden, to our discourses.
My own lack of interest or enthusiasm about TELLING people of Assam anything is based on that. Surely I have my preferences. But I have no interest in telling Assam or ULFA or AASU or the Chief Minister on a given day,or India -- that I have the answers to their problems. I can help analyze SOME of them. But it is not my role> sometimeswhat is right for them.
That is not the same as unwillingness to take a stand on issues where we ought to be able to see in blacks and whites. We owe it ourselves to see them and acknowledge them.
That is why I have no qualms about our condemning Dhemaji, or custodial deaths, or blatant violations of the rule of law.
Now let me ask you something again:
What do you think? Is it likely that
>NRAs might be energized > > enough to consider returning to Assam, at least >> temporarily, or intermittently, >> to help reconstruction, should there be genuine, >> visible and believable > > governmental reforms and /or when so asked.
Or to rephrase it more directly:
That NRAS really have no faith in Assam Govts, be it the current one, be it the past ones, or be it some future one, based on the current model. But they might have such faith in a future REFORMED one?
I know I am asking you to comment on something that MIGHT reflect negatively on your own beliefs. And as an incentive for you to comment forthrightly, you can ask me any leading question that might reflect negatively on my own leanings, and I promise to answer forthrightly.
You cannot get a better blank check than that can you?
Is it a deal :-).
c-da
At 7:48 PM -0800 2/7/05, ram Sarangapani wrote: >Hi C'da, > >Wow! that was a marathon session you and Barua had! >-:) > >Though, it may have frayed tempers a bit, it did bring >out the fact that we netters are passionate about >whats going on back home. > >> No, you are not confused Ram. You are just trying to > > pin me down and demonstrate to the world that I am >>full of it . > >No, far from it (you may find this hard to believe), >there was no such intention - and least of the demo to >the world etc, etc. Thats not my style. > >I was confused a little, because from some of your >posts, I got the impression that the issues we are >trying to understand (vis-a-vis Assam) MIGHT be >construed as being condescending. > >I do understand YOUR point that at times some NRAs do >tend to do that - tell the "natives" how its done. But >C'da, there are times, when many of us 'sincerely' >want to do something. > >Yes, many a time, our approaches are just outright >wrong or over the top, but then, we also have >outspoken people in this net (or outside) who will >tell you frankly where and why we are going astray. I >think thats a good thing. > >>I don't go about waylaying unsuspecting >assam->netters, and play gotcha when they make a slip. > >Ditto here. I never thought you did (maybe>in playful banter), but never as put-downs. > >>I never said a word until you guys badgered me to >>open my mouth. I was happy to play I saw or heard >>nothing. Now you cry foul. > >No such intention - but sorry if that was the
=== message truncated ===
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Take Yahoo! Mail with you! Get it on your mobile phone. http://mobile.yahoo.com/maildemo
_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
