Ram:

It was not to question or devalue Gen. Singh's intents. But HOW on earth does the soldier on the beat or his officer differentiate between the "local population" and the "insurgents"?

How would YOU differentiate if you were in Gen. Singh's boots?

Obviously the instructions mean little, considering the situation. If the insurgents were to wear uniforms of an identifiable kind, it might be different.

And if there was a way to differentiate, why has the army sought, and will not let go of AFSPA? Even in the most benevolent of a perspective, one cannot ignore the fact that the soldiers are only human, scared of their own lives, while the enemy and the friends, the natives, look all ALIKE.


The Manorama case of Manipur is one of only thousands of such cases. The army has been given a free hand to dispense summary justice for half a century over the Nagas and for a quarter in Assam.



How does that speak of Indian democracy Ram?

I read recently that the Indian Army is now resigned to the unique character
of Indian democracy, where it will continue to be required to play the role of the police and the courts, for civil law-enforcement and summary justice, instead of being the protectors of the nation from outside enemies. So they are making plans to train the armed forces for its newly legitimized role.


What do you think of that Ram?

If I were to be in Gen. Singh's boots, heaven forbid, I would tell the civil government to get off its fossilized duff and reform police and justice systems , make them effective and dependable, and negotiate with the insurgents, give a little and gain a little, and make peace.

c-da














At 7:12 AM -0800 2/11/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,

The poor General JJ Singh. He is damned if he does and
damned if he doesn't.

All he said was to "adopt a "humane approach" towards
local population" and deal "severely" with the
insurgents.

And the reasons he may have adopted this maybe because
of the fallout of the Manorama case and other times
when the army may have gone overboard dealing with
innocent locals.

Obviously, the army has to deal differently with
insurgents as opposed to the local population.

If you were 'incharge', how would you deal with
insurgents?

--Ram



--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 Dear Editor:

 I noticed the laudatory references to the new Army
 Chief and hope for
 his setting a more humane and progressive course for
 the forces' ways.

 In reference to the news item below, headlined "Deal
 humanely with locals",
 Gen. Singh's sets his noble course.

 My only question, however, remains on the issue of
 how an army
 'jawan' or even an officer, from somewhere in North
 India or South
 India or even NE India, differentiates an
 "insurgent" from a member
 of the "local population"? It creates the impression
 that the
 insurgents in Nagaland or the entire NE, are animals
 of a different
 stripe from the "local population".

 Is it really so?

 If it is not, and I am certain General Singh is
 eminently aware of
 the condition; then one is left wondering if there
 is much value to
 his
 declaration of humane intents. The
 interchangeability of labels, between
 the "local population" and the "insurgents", leave
 ALL of them
 legitimate targets for dealing with "severely", like
 it has always
 been. One cannot escape the fact here that it is an
 attempt to peddle
 old wine in a new bottle.

 It is depressing to see the ever widening gap
 between Indian leaders'
 ( both political and military) long pronounced
 declarations that
 political problems require political solutions; and
 their continued
 actions. Playing with smoke and mirrors of benign
 language goes only
 so far. Too bad Indian democracy has not yet figured
 out the
 difference between an effective  civil law
 enforcement apparatus and
> a judiciary that could be depended upon to dispense
 timely justice in
 matters of internal conflicts, and the use of the
 armed forces,
 however humane, employed to dispense summary justice
 on their fellow
 citizens, every time.

 Chandan Mahanta
 A North Easterner

 Writing from:

 St. Louis, USA
















Deal humanely with locals: Singh

 PTI[ FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 11, 2005 03:35:59 PM ]

 Sign into earnIndiatimes points

 KOHIMA: Army chief General JJ Singh has asked jawans
 to deal
 "severely" with the insurgents and at the same time
 adopt a "humane
 approach" towards local population.

   Singh was interacting with jawans at Rangapahar in
 Nagaland on
 Thursday during his maiden visit to the north-east
 after taking over
 as the Chief Of Army Staff.

   During his visit here, he was briefed on the
 current situation in
 the region by Corps Commander Lt Gen Daljeet Singh,
 a defence release
 said.

   The General had old links with the region as he
 was first posted in
 Nagaland as the second lieutenant after being
 commissioned into the
 Maratha Light Infantry in 1964.

   He had also served in Arunachal Pradesh and
 Sikkim, the release added.
 _______________________________________________
 Assam mailing list
 [email protected]
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

 Mailing list FAQ:
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
 To unsubscribe or change options:
 http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to