GrayHat wrote: >> I don't see how including a module that is explicitly intended to >> consume maximum resources (for whatever duration) is a net >> benefit. >> > > ok, you made your point <g> but let me put things straight; first of > all I *never* wrote that implementing "hashcash" should be a "we > MUST do it"; then, I wrote that such an idea won't probably be > suitable for the single-threaded series while it may fit into the > multi-threaded one, and, to conclude, I was just discussing an > idea to find out pros/cons and nothing more; if it isn't worth or > valid, well, I've no problem with that, but at least we discussed > about it and such discussions in other cases may result in some > improvements to ASSP, so imVHo they're worth > > And... about "resources", if you think that ASSP is consuming too > much resources, try giving a spin to spamassassin (ensure to set > it up to do the "same" ASSP checks) then judge by yourself > If I gave the opinion that ASSP is resource intensive, that was not my intention - quite the opposite. My point was that others have voiced concerns about resource usage and a desire to run a ASSP on minimal hardware - therefore hashcash would not be a good choice. It has been pointed out, quite correctly, that ASSP is in fact quite efficient and I would rather not see that image tainted. Adding the odd DNS check or content check is one thing - deliberately consuming resources is another.
I grant you that many people are resistant to change, and somebody's got to test out the new ideas. But show me any mail target of size (I pick AOL only from convenience, not as an endorsement - fill in the ISP or significant company of your choice) that has adopted hashcash that ASSP users would see a net benefit from before we consider implementing it. Even a sourceforge or other mailing list would be a point - but I've yet to see anybody other than we few, we crazy (I mean proud, creative, innovative thinking) admins, who would be willing to even consider it. -- Daniel ------------------------------------------------------------------------- This SF.Net email is sponsored by the Moblin Your Move Developer's challenge Build the coolest Linux based applications with Moblin SDK & win great prizes Grand prize is a trip for two to an Open Source event anywhere in the world http://moblin-contest.org/redirect.php?banner_id=100&url=/ _______________________________________________ Assp-test mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/assp-test
