na minha opiniao iax sem duvidas. Vulgarmente falando alem da questao de porta (somente uma porta udp para trabalhar) tem, se nao me engano, uma forma (trunk) que ameniza uso de trafego..
Isso fala aqui: retirado voip-info: The IAX revision 2 protocol is used by the Asterisk VOIP PBX and FreeSwitch Softswitch as an alternative to SIP, H.323, etc. when connecting to other devices that support IAX (a limited list at the moment, but growing very rapidly). However meanwhile other software like Yate SofaSwitch and OPAL have added IAX2 support. •IAX2 is not the result of a standards group, rather a collaborative, community based effort (Note: IAX2 is now: RFC 5456) •IAX2 uses a single UDP port 4569, and thus works well in NAT environments (the obsolete IAX1 protocol used port 5036). IAX2 uses ONLY one udp port for both control and data traffic. As outlined in point 4 of the IAX versus SIP topic with IAX you will always have audio if the control connection can be established. •IAX2 supports PKI-style authentication and trunking. •The Asterisk IAX2 driver has a jitter buffer. (The SIP driver doesn't in 1.2.x, but one has been added in 1.4.x. The IAX2 jitterbuffer is more mature however.) Trunking When trunking with IAX2, only the used bandwidth is allocated at all times. Other TDMoIP protocols used for trunking always allocate a certain amount of bandwidth to keep all channels open. IAX trunking allows multiple voice streams to share a single "trunk" to another server, reducing overhead created by IP packets. IAX always sends DTMF outline (RFC2833), eliminating the confusion often found with SIP. It should be noted that trunking requires both sides to know each other (i.e. they need to be valid peers). If one side has trunk=yes and the other does not cannot validate the peer, you will get one-way audio. The easiest way to make this work is to use a register line to register to the systems you want to trunk with. -- Obg, Ulisses Féres. Abratel Telecom ufe...@abratel.com.br 32-3722-4004 ramal 928 Em 6 de setembro de 2011 20:30, Thiago Gomes <thiagome...@gmail.com>escreveu: > Pessoal, > > Estou analisando um cenário entre Asterisk, qual seria o melhor para > interligar > os mesmos ? IAX2 ou SIP Trunk, > > Qual é a vantagem ou desvantagem dos dois.. E vcs basicamente usam qual e > pq ?? > > -- > Thiago Gomes >
_______________________________________________ KHOMP: qualidade em placas de E1, GSM, FXS e FXO para Asterisk. - Hardware com alta disponibilidade de recursos e qualidade KHOMP - Suporte técnico local qualificado e gratuito Conheça a linha completa de produtos KHOMP em www.khomp.com.br _______________________________________________ DIGIVOICE: Lider no mercado de placas para Asterisk Único fabricante com Centro de Treinamento especializado. LANÇAMENTO: Channel Bank TDMoE, até 64 canais FXS / FXO. www.digivoice.com.br ou (11)3016-5200. ________ LANÇAMENTO SHOPVOIP! Gateway Xibelis Lyric VoIP com 2,4 e 6 canais GSM. Arquitetura Escalável, Balanceamento de Carga, Portabilidade Numérica. Confira em http://www.yx.cl/landing/brasil/lyric_voip_asterisk.org Mais informações: www.shopvoip.com.br ou 0800-6021244 ______________________________________________ Para remover seu email desta lista, basta enviar um email em branco para asteriskbrasil-unsubscr...@listas.asteriskbrasil.org
