On 2021-12-20 02:26, kiasoc5--- via aur-general wrote:
Please ignore my deletion request for linux-slim [1]. I thought the package would be too niche but there are some users of it per the package comments.Perhaps now is a good time to clarify what the wiki means by an "extremely specialized" package? [1] https://lists.archlinux.org/pipermail/aur-requests/2021-December/063787.html Thanks kiasoc5
I feel it's as specific as it needs to be: "extremely specialized" is mostly self-explanatory but gives TUs flexibility to judge on a per-package basis.
In the case of the linux-slim request, the packager even admits to it being specifically for their hardware only:
It performs really well because it has zero compatibility with anything but my pc,
I think this does fit the definition of "extremely specialized". The name "linux-slim" is quite broad a name, too. It has a 0 popularity score and only one vote from two years ago.
However, as you mentioned, this package is helping at least one other person. And there are far worse packages clogging up the AUR.
I'll close the request. Thanks for bringing it up.
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
