> From: Noel J. Bergman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
> 
> > Applying RFC 2141 is fine from my point of view.  As such I need to
> > update the examples I provided earlier to reflect marlin and phoenix
> > as subdomains of the avalon domain.
> 
> Is that what you want to do?  There is no sub-domain notion 
> within RFC 2141.
> 
> The format of a URN is "urn:" <NID> ":" <NSS>.  NID is 
> Namespace IDentifier,
> and NSS is Namspace Specific String.  One example might be:
> 
>    urn:avalon:home.work
> 
> where "urn:" is required, avalon is the NID and home.work is 
> the NSS.  In
> all of your examples, the NID was apache, and everything else 
> was the NSS.
> 
> > update merlin specific keys to be RFC 2141 based on
> > a *apache:avalon:merlin* domain
> 
> If "domain" is supposed to be NID, that would not be valid.  The ':'
> character is not valid within an NID, and is valid within the 
> NSS.  So your
> string would be interpreted as having an NID of apache, with 
> avalon:merlin:
> being part of the NSS, which is probably not what you're going to want
> internally when you process the NSS.  Alternatively, you could use
> apache-avalon-merlin as an NID.

I think it is much simpler to do this:

urn:avalon:home.work
urn:merlin:something.special
urn:phoenix:something.specific

ALthough it is even simpler to drop the "urn:" portion as well ;P

I favor simplicity of the string we need to type or bind.

--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to