Re: TCK Summary with new TCK

26 Jul 2002 19:31:53 -0000

Can you send a jtr file which demonstrates the isXXX failure and for your issues on setGetPopertyTest1

thanks

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The new TCK resolved a number of issues.

We are still having problems related to the getVarBoolean methods.

(See attached file: TCKIssues.html)

Rich Scheuerle
IBM WebSphere & Axis Web Services Development
512-838-5115 (IBM TL 678-5115)

TCKIssues  
Summary with the new TCK.
Green indicates Tests that are now fixed.
Red indicates failures that we expected would be fixed by the new tck.
 
 
Test  TCK issue Status
jaxrpc/api/javax_xml_rpc/Service/Client.java#
GetPortsPosTest2 		 4. getPorts should throw ServiceException wsdl
Note: Axis was changed to pass this test		 TCK bug #4709354 assigned
* Test is now excluded
jaxrpc/api/javax_xml_rpc/Call/Client.java#
SetGetPropertyTest1_from_standalone		 8.  Stub/Call get/setProperty issue TCK bug #4708407 assigned
Does Axis need to be changed ?
Note that Axis passes but w/ Stub issue
jaxrpc/api/javax_xml_rpc/Stub/Client.java#
setPropertyTest5_from_standalone		 8.  Stub/Call get/setProperty issue TCK bug #4708407 assigned
Does Axis need to be changed ?
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/attachmentstest/Client.java#
AttachmentsTest_from_standalone		 AXIS needs work Russell is working on this one.
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/inheritedinterfacetest/Client.java#
inheritedinterfaceTest_from_standalone		 12. Client.class is stale This is still a problem in the new TCK.
The test passes if the Client.java is recompiled.
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/marshalltest/Client.java#
MarshallStandardJavaClassesTest_from_standalone		 5.  Roundtrip issues TCK bug #4708425 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/marshalltest/Client.java#
MarshallJavaBeanTest_from_standalone		 11.  Calendar compare issue TCK bug #4714327 assigned
* Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/marshalltest/Client.java#
MarshallValueTypeTest_from_standalone		 11.  Calendar compare issue TCK bug #4714327 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/marshalltest/Client.java#
MarshallJavaArrayTest_from_standalone		 5.  Roundtrip issues TCK bug #4708425 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/j2w/marshalltest/Client.java#
MarshallJavaMultiArrayTest_from_standalone		 5.  Roundtrip issues TCK bug #4708425 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/document/literal/marshaltest/Client.java#
MarshallSimpleTypesTest_from_standalone		 6.  wrapped doc/lit no TCK bug number yet
* Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/document/literal/marshaltest/Client.java#
MarshallArraysOfSimpleTypesTest_from_standalone		 6.  wrapped doc/lit no TCK bug number yet
11. Calendar issue		 * Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/document/literal/simpletest/Client.java#
SimpleTest_from_standalone		 6.  wrapped doc/lit no TCK bug number yet * Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/document/literal/stockquote/Client.java#
invokeStockQuoteService_from_standalone		 6.  wrapped doc/lit no TCK bug number yet * Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallAllSimpleXMLDataTypeTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue
(Some of the marshal tests also have issues 2 and 11, but they are hidden by 7)		 TCK bug #4708351 assigned
(TCK bug #4708425 assigned, TCK bug #4714327 assigned)
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallAllStructsTest_from_standalone		 2.  getVarBoolean instead of isVarBoolean TCK bug #4708425 assigned
Why wasn't this issue fixed by the new TCK ?
Do we need to raise this issue again ?
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallSequenceStructsTest_from_standalone		 2.  getVarBoolean instead of isVarBoolean TCK bug #4708425 assigned
Why wasn't this issue fixed by the new TCK ?
Do we need to raise this issue again ?
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallWSDLRestrictedArrayTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708365 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallSOAPRestrictedArrayTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708365 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallExceptionsTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708365 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallEnumerationsTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708365 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/marsalltest/Client.java#
MarshallAllSimpleXMLDataTypesTest_from_standalone		 7.  Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708365 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/parametermodetest/Client.java#
InSimpleTypesTest_from_standalone		 11. Calendar issue TCK bug #4714327 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/parametermodetest/Client.java#
OutSimpleTypesTest_from_standalone		 11. Calendar issue TCK bug #4714327 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/parametermodetest/Client.java#
InOutSimpleTypesTest_from_standalone		 11. Calendar issue TCK bug #4714327 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/parametermodetest/Client.java#
InStructTest_from_standalone		 2.  getVarBoolean instead of isVarBoolean TCK bug #4708425 assigned
Why wasn't this fixed in the TCK ?
Do we need to raise this issue again ?
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/xmlnamemappingtest/Client.java#
JavaKeywordsTest_from_standalone		 7. Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708351 assigned
*Fixed
jaxrpc/ee/w2j/rpc/encoded/xmlnamemappingtest/Client.java#
JavaNamingConventionsTest_from_standalone		 7. Full bean constructor issue TCK bug #4708351 assigned
*Fixed

 

Issue Explanations

Issue: 2 Boolean value

The TCK expects getVarBooloon instead of isVarBoolean for a bean property that is a boolean value.

Issue: 4 getPorts() problem

TCK expects a call to getPorts() to return a null iterator if there is no wsdl.  The specification clearly indicates that an exception should be thrown.  Axis was changed to comply with the TCK.  The Axis change should be backed out once the TCK is fixed.

Issue: 5. Roundtrip Issues

Problems with roundtripping Calendar/Date.

Issue: 6 Wrapped Doc/Lit

The TCK and Axis do not agree on the way to interpret wrapped doc/lit.
 

Issue: 7 Full Bean Constructor

The TCK relies on full constructors in the beans, which is not compliant with the specification.
 

Issue: 8 Stub/Call Get/Set Property Issue

The TCK expects an exception when it sets/gets an unknown property.  AXIS does not throw an exception.
 

Issue: 11 Calendar Issue

The compareCalendars method in the TCK should compare the canonical form of the calendars.
 

Issue: 12 Client.class is stale

The Client.class file for the inherited interface test does not match the Client.java.  Recompiling Client.java fixes the problem.
  

-- 
Lance Andersen                       email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sun Microsystems Inc.                phone: (781) 442-2037
1 Network Drive, UBUR02-301          fax  : (781) 442-1610
Burlington, MA 01803

Reply via email to