It's generally a good idea to always specify elementFormDefault="qualified". What that means is by default, all local elements (elements defined within another structure -- e.g., within a complexType) are qualified (part of the targetNamespace). To override the default, you must specify form="unqualified" on the individual element definition.
As an alternative, you could specify elementFormDefault="unqualified" and then override the default on individual element definitions by saying form="qualified". Given that your service requires a mixture of qualified and unqualified local elements, you have no choice but to override the default setting in the local element declarations. To clarify Phillip's comment about the xmlns="": The xmlns= declaration in (a namespace declaration without a prefix value) establishes the default namespace for that instance document. For example, xmlns="urn:example:foo" establishes a default namespace of "urn:example:foo". Any element within the scope of this declaration that doesn't explicitly specify a prefix is automatically qualified by this namespace. If you specify xmlns="", you are setting the default namespace to no namespace. You typically do this if you have previously set the default namespace, and then you need to reset it to no namespace. Let's say for example you have the following schema: <schema targetNamespace="urn:example:foo" elementFormDefault="unqualified" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema";> <element name="foo"> <complexType> <sequence> <element name="bar" type="string"/> </sequence> </complexType> </element> </schema> This indicates that the "foo" element is in the "urn:example:foo" namespace, and the "bar" element is in no namespace. Valid instance documents of this schema include the following: <ns:foo xmlns:ns="urn:example:foo"> <bar>foobar</bar> </ns:foo> (there is no default namespace, so unqualified elements default to no namespace) <foo xmlns="urn:example:foo"> <bar xmlns="">foobar</bar> </foo> (the xmlns="" declaration overrides the previous default namespace) <foo xmlns="urn:example:foo"> <none:bar xmlns:none="">foobar</none:bar> </ns:foo> (the "none" prefix is defined as no namespace) As a general rule, if you have an instance document with elements from multiple namespaces, I recommend not using a default namespace. Qualify all elements with a prefix. It just makes the document easier to interpret. Anne On 10/22/07, Frank J. Øynes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I now know that I know close to nothing, but I made it work: > > step 1: > By setting elementFormDefault to "qualified", > and attributeFormDefault to "unqualified" I got rid of both the unwanted > xmlns="". > > step 2: > By putting form="unqualified" in the element where I *needed* xmlns=""; > <s:element name="StoredProcess" form="unqualified"> > I managed to create an exact replica of the correct soap request. > > From the little I still think I do know, I agree with Philipp, but as long > as the > service provider only accepts *exactly* this soap template all I can do is > try to comply. > > Thanks for all your help, your ideas and references together with Google > brought me a big step ahead, even if it is not done the correct way.... > --Frank > > 2007/10/21, Philipp Leitner <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > Seems strange to me. If I remember my XML basics course correctly then > > 'xmlns=""' is the same as having no namespace declaration at all > > (supposing that you do not have a default namespace). If that is correct > > then both SOAP requests that you mentioned are absolutely identical. > > > > Personally I would recommend to 'not' use the -sp options and give it a > > try with the default ns settings ... > > > > /philipp > > > > Frank J. Øynes wrote: > > > This is probably a noob question, but I am having problem setting up my > > > wsdl file so that the SOAP request sent by my client is accepted by the > > > service. > > > > > > There are two places where the xmlns="" is put, first at the "Command" > > > element, and later at the "Properties"' > > > > > > The service requires xmlns="" in the "StoredProcess" element, i.e. the > > > first child of where in now ends up, and does not accept that it is in > > > the "Properties" element. > > > > > > Can someone please hint me what I am doing wrong here? How can I make > > > the xmlns="" disappear from <Command> and <Properties>, > > > and make it appear in <StoredProcess> ? > > > > > > (btw, I am using wsdl2java with the -sp option to suppress all ns > > > prefixes, and also state "unqualified" for both elements and attributes) > > > > > > ---- LISTING OF ACCEPTABLE SOAP REQUEST ----- > > > <?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8'?> > > > <soapenv:Envelope > > > > xmlns:soapenv="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/ "> > > > <soapenv:Body> > > > <Execute > xmlns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis"> > > > <Command> > > > <StoredProcess xmlns="" name="Online Scoring"> > > > <Stream name="instream"> > > > <Table> > > > <PM_SOK> > > > > <Naeringsinteresser_a>22</Naeringsinteresser_a> > > > > <Anm_Antall_a>43</Anm_Antall_a> > > > > > > <D_Inntekt_Skatt_t0_t2_R>44</D_Inntekt_Skatt_t0_t2_R> > > > > <D_Formue_t0_t2_R>45</D_Formue_t0_t2_R> > > > > > > <Overtrekk_belop_mean_6>46</Overtrekk_belop_mean_6> > > > > <Purring_1_gang_Nye_YY>47</Purring_1_gang_Nye_YY> > > > > <Dager_Eldste_Konto_a>48</Dager_Eldste_Konto_a> > > > > <Omsetning_KR_Mean_3>49</Omsetning_KR_Mean_3> > > > </PM_SOK> > > > </Table> > > > </Stream> > > > </StoredProcess> > > > </Command> > > > <Properties> > > > <PropertyList> > > > > <DataSourceInfo>Provider=SASSPS</DataSourceInfo> > > > <Content>Data</Content> > > > </PropertyList> > > > </Properties> > > > </Execute> > > > </soapenv:Body> > > > </soapenv:Envelope> > > > > > > ----- AND THIS IS REJECTED DUE TO THE SMALL DIFFERENCES MENTIONED > ------ > > > <?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8'?> > > > <soapenv:Envelope > > > > xmlns:soapenv="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/";> > > > <soapenv:Body> > > > <Execute > xmlns="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis"> > > > <Command xmlns=""> > > > <StoredProcess name="Online Scoring"> > > > <Stream name="instream"> > > > <Table> > > > <PM_SOK> > > > > <Naeringsinteresser_a>22</Naeringsinteresser_a> > > > > <Anm_Antall_a>43</Anm_Antall_a> > > > > > > <D_Inntekt_Skatt_t0_t2_R>44</D_Inntekt_Skatt_t0_t2_R> > > > > <D_Formue_t0_t2_R>45</D_Formue_t0_t2_R> > > > > > > <Overtrekk_belop_mean_6>46</Overtrekk_belop_mean_6> > > > > <Purring_1_gang_Nye_YY>47</Purring_1_gang_Nye_YY> > > > > <Dager_Eldste_Konto_a>48</Dager_Eldste_Konto_a> > > > > <Omsetning_KR_Mean_3>49</Omsetning_KR_Mean_3> > > > </PM_SOK> > > > </Table> > > > </Stream> > > > </StoredProcess> > > > </Command> > > > <Properties xmlns=""> > > > <PropertyList> > > > > <DataSourceInfo>Provider=SASSPS</DataSourceInfo> > > > <Content>Data</Content> > > > </PropertyList> > > > </Properties> > > > </Execute> > > > </soapenv:Body> > > > </soapenv:Envelope> > > > > > > > > > ----- Complete WSDL: ----- > > > > > > <?xml version=" 1.0" encoding="utf-8"?> > > > <q1:definitions > xmlns:s="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"; xmlns:http=" > > > http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/http/"; > > > xmlns:mime="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/mime/"; > xmlns:tm=" > > > http://microsoft.com/wsdl/mime/textMatching/"; > > > xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/soap/ " > xmlns:soapenc=" > > > http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/encoding/"; > > > xmlns:s0="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis" > > > xmlns:q1=" http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/wsdl/"; > > > > targetNamespace="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis"> > > > <q1:types> > > > <s:schema > > > > targetNamespace="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis" > > > elementFormDefault="unqualified" > attributeFormDefault="unqualified"> > > > <s:element name="Discover"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element name="RequestType" type="s:string" > > > nillable="true"/> > > > <s:element name="Restrictions" nillable="true"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:any/> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > <s:element name="Properties" nillable="true"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:any/> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > <s:element name="DiscoverResponse"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element name="return" minOccurs="0"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:any/> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > <s:element name="Execute"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element name="Command" nillable="true"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element > name="StoredProcess"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > <s:element name="Stream"> > > > > <s:complexType> > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > <s:element > > > name="Table"> > > > > > > <s:complexType> > > > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > > > <s:element name="PM_SOK"> > > > > > > <s:complexType> > > > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > > > <s:element name="Naeringsinteresser_a" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="Anm_Antall_a" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="D_Inntekt_Skatt_t0_t2_R" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="D_Formue_t0_t2_R" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="Overtrekk_belop_mean_6" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="Purring_1_gang_Nye_YY" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="Dager_Eldste_Konto_a" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > <s:element name="Omsetning_KR_Mean_3" type="s:string"/> > > > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > > > </s:complexType> > > > > > > </s:element> > > > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > > > </s:complexType> > > > > </s:element> > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > <s:attribute > > > name="name" use="required"> > > > > <s:simpleType> > > > > > > <s:restriction base="s:string"> > > > > > > <s:enumeration value="instream"/> > > > > > > </s:restriction> > > > > </s:simpleType> > > > > </s:attribute> > > > > </s:complexType> > > > > </s:element> > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > <s:attribute name="name" > > > use="required"> > > > > <s:simpleType> > > > > <s:restriction > > > base="s:string"> > > > > <s:enumeration > > > value="Online Scoring"/> > > > > </s:restriction> > > > > </s:simpleType> > > > > </s:attribute> > > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > <s:element name="Properties" nillable="true"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element > name="PropertyList"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > <s:element > > > name="DataSourceInfo"> > > > > <s:simpleType> > > > > <s:restriction > > > base="s:string"> > > > > > > <s:enumeration value="Provider=SASSPS"/> > > > > </s:restriction> > > > > </s:simpleType> > > > > </s:element> > > > > <s:element name="Content"> > > > > <s:simpleType> > > > > <s:restriction > > > base="s:string"> > > > > > > <s:enumeration value="Data"/> > > > > </s:restriction> > > > > </s:simpleType> > > > > </s:element> > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > <s:element name="ExecuteResponse"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element name="return" minOccurs="0"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > <s:sequence> > > > <s:element > name="TABLE"> > > > <s:complexType> > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_RESULT"> > > > > <s:complexType> > > > > <s:sequence> > > > > <s:element > > > name="PD_FLT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="RISK_CLASS_CHR" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="TIMESTAMP_DT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORECARD_ID" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="LINDORFF_ZONE" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_NAERING_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_ANT_ANT_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_INNTEKT_SKATT_ENDRING_FLT" > type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_FORMUE_ENDRING_FLT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_OVERTREKK_AMT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_PURRINGER_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_DAGER_ELDSTE_KONTO_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > <s:element > > > name="SCORE_OMSETNING_KR_INT" type="s:string"/> > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > </s:complexType> > > > > </s:element> > > > > </s:sequence> > > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:sequence> > > > </s:complexType> > > > </s:element> > > > </s:schema> > > > </q1:types> > > > <q1:message name="DiscoverSoapIn"> > > > <q1:part name="parameters" element="s0:Discover"/> > > > </q1:message> > > > <q1:message name="DiscoverSoapOut"> > > > <q1:part name="parameters" element="s0:DiscoverResponse"/> > > > </q1:message> > > > <q1:message name="ExecuteSoapIn"> > > > <q1:part name="parameters" element="s0:Execute"/> > > > </q1:message> > > > <q1:message name="ExecuteSoapOut"> > > > <q1:part name="parameters" element="s0:ExecuteResponse"/> > > > </q1:message> > > > <q1:portType name="MsXmlAnalysisSoap"> > > > <q1:operation name="Discover"> > > > <q1:input message="s0:DiscoverSoapIn"/> > > > <q1:output message="s0:DiscoverSoapOut"/> > > > </q1:operation> > > > <q1:operation name="Execute"> > > > <q1:input message="s0:ExecuteSoapIn"/> > > > <q1:output message="s0:ExecuteSoapOut"/> > > > </q1:operation> > > > </q1:portType> > > > <q1:portType name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpGet"/> > > > <q1:portType name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpPost"/> > > > <q1:binding name="MsXmlAnalysisSoap" type="s0:MsXmlAnalysisSoap"> > > > <soap:binding style="document" > > > transport="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http > > > < http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http>"/> > > > <q1:operation name="Discover"> > > > <soap:operation > > > > soapAction="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis:Discover" > > > style="document"/> > > > <q1:input> > > > <soap:body use="literal"/> > > > </q1:input> > > > <q1:output> > > > <soap:body use="literal"/> > > > </q1:output> > > > </q1:operation> > > > <q1:operation name="Execute"> > > > <soap:operation > > > > soapAction="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:xml-analysis:Execute" > > > style="document"/> > > > <q1:input> > > > <soap:body use="literal"/> > > > </q1:input> > > > <q1:output> > > > <soap:body use="literal"/> > > > </q1:output> > > > </q1:operation> > > > </q1:binding> > > > <q1:binding name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpGet" > type="s0:MsXmlAnalysisHttpGet"> > > > <http:binding verb="GET"/> > > > </q1:binding> > > > <q1:binding name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpPost" > > > type="s0:MsXmlAnalysisHttpPost"> > > > <http:binding verb="POST"/> > > > </q1:binding> > > > <q1:service name="MsXmlAnalysis"> > > > <q1:port name="MsXmlAnalysisSoap" > binding="s0:MsXmlAnalysisSoap"> > > > <soap:address location="http://xxxx"/> > > > </q1:port> > > > <q1:port name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpGet" > > > binding="s0:MsXmlAnalysisHttpGet"> > > > <http:address location="http://xxxx"/> > > > </q1:port> > > > <q1:port name="MsXmlAnalysisHttpPost" > > > binding="s0:MsXmlAnalysisHttpPost"> > > > <http:address location="xxxx"/> > > > </q1:port> > > > </q1:service> > > > </q1:definitions> > > > > > > : > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
