Obviously you'll just create a flame war with this...

I am FAR from alone, both on and off this group, from the only person 
asserting that default namespace handling wasn't well thought-out... If you 
generate XML, put prefixes on your tags. Trust me, you are doing the whole 
world a big favor.

On Friday 28 March 2003 10:04 am, Daniel Veillard wrote:
> On Fri, Mar 28, 2003 at 09:46:05AM -0500, Tod Harter wrote:
> > Part of the problem here is that the SPEC is 'broken'. How do you select
> > with XPath an element that is in a default namespace? There is no prefix
> > you can place in the XPath statement!!! Your stuck!
>
>  Perfectly wrong !
>  Either:
>   1/ you map the default namespace name of your target nodes to
>      a namespace with a prefix in the context of the XPath expression
>      i.e. map foo to the default namespace name and use
>         /foo:name
>      this is the prefered solution and every correct use of XPath should
>      allow you to do such a namespace mapping
>   2/ or if you can't define such a namespace mapping you build your
>      XPath expression with the local-name() and namespace-uri() defined
>      in the XPath spec:
>        http://www.w3.org/TR/xpath#function-local-name
>         /*[local-name() = 'name' and namespace-uri() = 'default namespace
> name']
>
>  Again before asserting that a spec or code associated to it is broken,
> it's better to read the associated spec and make sure your understand it !
>
> > I had this problem with parsing
> > some XHTML the other day where everything was in the default namespace.
> > In XSLT you're template can specifiy the same namespace as the default
> > and then IIRC you get a match, but what if you had to deal with multiple
> > namespaces? The entire concept of default namespaces makes me grind my
> > teeth. Its like autovivification of variables and hash keys in perl.
> > Anyone designing XML processing systems DO NOT USE DEFAULT NAMESPACES,
> > ever ever ever!
>
>   Sorry, this is crap. Simply define the xmlns:xhtml="XHTML namespace"
> at the top of your XSLT stylesheet and use xhtml:html etc. in your
> template match and embedded XPath expressions. People have done that
> for years without trouble, you're just showing ignorance here. Sorry
> that doesn't give you the right to shout on the topic ...
>
> Daniel

-- 
Tod Harter
Giant Electronic Brain

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to