Hey Tom, could you please post the libxml2 version you use?
that helps to find the problem. Christian On Wed, 2004-03-10 at 10:26, Tom Schindl wrote: > Hi, > > well that's not really AxKit related but I know that there are many > XML-Gurus following this list. > > Take a look at the following DTD's: > > DTD-1: > ---------------------8<--------------------- > <!ELEMENT foo ( bar, beso:bar )> > <!ATTLIST foo > xmlns:beso CDATA #REQUIRED > > > > <!ELEMENT bar EMPTY> > <!ATTLIST bar > beso:testbar CDATA #IMPLIED > testbar CDATA #IMPLIED> > > <!ELEMENT beso:bar EMPTY> > ---------------------8<--------------------- > > DTD-2: > ---------------------8<--------------------- > <!ELEMENT foo ( bar, beso:bar )> > <!ATTLIST foo > xmlns:beso CDATA #REQUIRED > > > > <!ELEMENT bar EMPTY> > <!ATTLIST bar > beso:testbar CDATA #IMPLIED > testbar CDATA #REQUIRED> > > <!ELEMENT beso:bar EMPTY> > ---------------------8<--------------------- > > DTD-3: > ---------------------8<--------------------- > <!ELEMENT foo ( bar, beso:bar )> > <!ATTLIST foo > xmlns:beso CDATA #REQUIRED > > > > <!ELEMENT bar EMPTY> > <!ATTLIST bar > beso:testbar CDATA #IMPLIED > testbar CDATA #REQUIRED> > ---------------------8<--------------------- > > > XML: > ---------------------8<--------------------- > <?xml version="1.0" ?> > <!DOCTYPE foo SYSTEM "./test.dtd" > > <foo xmlns:beso="http://www.bestsolution.at/testns";> > <bar beso:testbar="bli" testbar="blo" /> > <beso:bar beso:testbar="bli" testbar="blo" /> > </foo> > ---------------------8<--------------------- > > Using xmllint(xmllint --valid --noout test.xml) I expected the following > results: > > DTD1: invalid => no attribute (beso:testbar,testbar) in beso:bar > DTD2: invalid => no attribute (beso:testbar,testbar) in beso:bar > DTD3: invalid => no element beso:bar in foo > > But got: > > DTD1: valid (is there some inheritance???if yes, see DTD2) > DTD2: valid (if attributes are inherited why does #REQUIRED is > transformed to #IMPLIED) > DTD3: valid > > What am I missing, is libxml's DTD-Validation broken or does it follow > the XML-specs? > > thx > > Tom --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
