I think that this (serious) bug could be forwarded to -devel list ... as it seems no to be a configuration mistake ?
On Mon, 2007-07-30 at 16:56 +0300, Doytchin Spiridonov wrote: > Hello, > > unfortunately spooling didn't helped here, so may you just had a > chance not getting errors in your case? A rule is that if it hapens > once that means it could happen more. And here is what we've got in > one of our tests: > > --- > enabled spooling (Maximum Job Spool Size > = 500m) performed the same and AGAIN the first job I tested to restore > ~44K files are missing: > > Files Expected: 348,120 > Files Restored: 304,654 > > Another restore jobs is similar: > Files Expected: 190,741 > Files Restored: 154,016 > > The case is slightly different as this time there is NO other errors > generated (like file with wrong size or the "Record header file index > not equal"). > --- > > As it shows spooling doesn't solve the problem of concurrent jobs. > > Regards. > > > Monday, July 30, 2007, 11:03:56 AM: > > MWa> Hello, > > MWa> In my case spooling brought a remarkable improvement. Where as I had > MWa> hundreds of errors on one restore I hardly see them now again with > MWa> spooling in place. > > MWa> Doytchin, > MWa> I also saw the same behavior like you did. With the concurrent jobs = 1, > MWa> there were no errors. In this case no matter with or without spooling. > > MWa> Unfortunately setting the concurrent jobs = 1 is not an option in our > MWa> environment. So my current setting is spooling = on and concurrent jobs > MWa> = 5. > > MWa> With this settings, it looks like that the Linux systems (OpenSuse and > MWa> red hat) are ok but Solaris still has problems. > > MWa> For example below is a restore I did on Friday. Of course I don't mind > MWa> about the door files. But the difference between expected and restored > MWa> files is ways to much. And even worse, I have no idea what happened to > MWa> the missing files. I don't know if this has to do something with the > MWa> restore errors we saw. This could also be something different. > > MWa> During the weekend I moved bacula to a new and separate server. It runs > MWa> on OpenSuse 10.2 with the latest patches in place now. The few restore > MWa> jobs I've done so far with this went ok. > > MWa> All in all I still don't feel very comfortable with this, it needs more > MWa> tests to be done. I will continue with testing and keep you updated. > > MWa> Wolfgang > > > MWa> 27-Jul 11:07 porsche-dir: Start Restore Job > MWa> RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 27-Jul 11:07 porsche-sd: Ready to read > MWa> from volume "full-27-7-2007.20" on device "FileStorageFull" > MWa> (/export/bacula-dump). > MWa> 27-Jul 11:07 porsche-sd: Forward spacing Volume "full-27-7-2007.20" to > MWa> file:block 0:3999802558. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:08 porsche-sd: End of file 1 on device "FileStorageFull" > MWa> (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.20" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:08 porsche-sd: End of Volume at file 1 on device > MWa> "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.20" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:08 porsche-sd: Ready to read from volume "full-27-7-2007.21" > MWa> on device "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump). > MWa> 27-Jul 11:08 porsche-sd: Forward spacing Volume "full-27-7-2007.21" to > MWa> file:block 0:200. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:33 prinz-fd: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: > MWa> create_file.c:245 Cannot make node /export/xxx/dev/.zone_reg_door: > MWa> ERR=Invalid argument 27-Jul 11:33 prinz-fd: > MWa> RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: create_file.c:245 Cannot make > MWa> node /export/xxx/dev/.devfsadm_synch_door: ERR=Invalid argument 27-Jul > MWa> 11:33 prinz-fd: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: > MWa> create_file.c:245 Cannot make node > MWa> /export/xxx/etc/sysevent/devfsadm_event_channel/reg_door: ERR=Invalid > MWa> argument 27-Jul 11:33 prinz-fd: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: > MWa> create_file.c:245 Cannot make node > MWa> /export/xxx/etc/sysevent/devfsadm_event_channel/1: ERR=Invalid argument > MWa> 27-Jul 11:33 prinz-fd: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: > MWa> create_file.c:245 Cannot make node > MWa> /export/xxx/etc/sysevent/syseventconfd_event_channel/reg_door: > MWa> ERR=Invalid argument 27-Jul 11:33 prinz-fd: > MWa> RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: create_file.c:245 Cannot make > MWa> node /export/xxx/etc/sysevent/sysevent_door: ERR=Invalid argument 27-Jul > MWa> 11:33 prinz-fd: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: > MWa> create_file.c:245 Cannot make node > MWa> /export/xxx/etc/sysevent/piclevent_door: ERR=Invalid argument 27-Jul > MWa> 11:15 porsche-sd: End of file 1 on device "FileStorageFull" > MWa> (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.21" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:15 porsche-sd: End of Volume at file 1 on device > MWa> "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.21" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:15 porsche-sd: Ready to read from volume "full-27-7-2007.22" > MWa> on device "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump). > MWa> 27-Jul 11:15 porsche-sd: Forward spacing Volume "full-27-7-2007.22" to > MWa> file:block 0:200. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:21 porsche-sd: End of file 1 on device "FileStorageFull" > MWa> (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.22" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:21 porsche-sd: End of Volume at file 1 on device > MWa> "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.22" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:21 porsche-sd: Ready to read from volume "full-27-7-2007.23" > MWa> on device "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump). > MWa> 27-Jul 11:21 porsche-sd: Forward spacing Volume "full-27-7-2007.23" to > MWa> file:block 0:200. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-sd: End of file 1 on device "FileStorageFull" > MWa> (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.23" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-sd: End of Volume at file 1 on device > MWa> "FileStorageFull" (/export/bacula-dump), Volume "full-27-7-2007.23" > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-sd: End of all volumes. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 Error: Bacula > MWa> 2.0.3 (06Mar07): 27-Jul-2007 11:28:34 > MWa> JobId: 40 > MWa> Job: RestoreFiles.2007-07-27_11.07.03 > MWa> Client: prinz-fd > MWa> Start time: 27-Jul-2007 11:07:05 > MWa> End time: 27-Jul-2007 11:28:34 > MWa> Files Expected: 303,761 > MWa> Files Restored: 301,923 > MWa> Bytes Restored: 27,412,500,483 > MWa> Rate: 21266.5 KB/s > MWa> FD Errors: 7 > MWa> FD termination status: Error > MWa> SD termination status: OK > MWa> Termination: *** Restore Error *** > > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: Begin pruning Jobs. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: No Jobs found to prune. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: Begin pruning Files. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: No Files found to prune. > MWa> 27-Jul 11:28 porsche-dir: End auto prune. > > > MWa> > > MWa> -----Original Message----- > MWa> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > MWa> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of > MWa> Doytchin Spiridonov > MWa> Sent: Saturday, July 28, 2007 02:02 > MWa> To: bacula-users > MWa> Subject: Re: [Bacula-users] Restore errors > > MWa> Hello, > > MWa> just to note that several days after a full backup and incremental > MWa> bacpus, restores are OK, which again proves that the problem was caused > MWa> by running concurrent jobs. > > MWa> Wolfgang do you have the same results? > > MWa> Regards > > > MWa> Wednesday, July 25, 2007, 8:12:25 PM: > > DS>> Hello, > > DS>> 2nd day w/o concurrent jobs: we have 1xFULL and 1xINCREMENTAL for > DS>> all clients. > > DS>> Restore OK of all jobs. > > DS>> Seems this (concurrent jobs) is the problem. > > DS>> Regards. > > > DS>> Tuesday, July 24, 2007, 9:57:35 PM: > > DS>>> I don't have any other ideas to check with to provide more cases. > DS>>> It's developers turn now... > > > > MWa> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > MWa> - > MWa> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. > MWa> Still grepping through log files to find problems? Stop. > MWa> Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser. > MWa> Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >> http://get.splunk.com/ > MWa> _______________________________________________ > MWa> Bacula-users mailing list > MWa> Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net > MWa> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. > Still grepping through log files to find problems? Stop. > Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser. > Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >> http://get.splunk.com/ > _______________________________________________ > Bacula-users mailing list > Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users ------------------------------------------------------------------------- This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. Still grepping through log files to find problems? Stop. Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser. Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >> http://get.splunk.com/ _______________________________________________ Bacula-users mailing list Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users
