Hi Serge, interesting. However, the URL you gave does not work. Also no bacula(-fd) in the official macOS appstore.
I found in the mailing list archive that it is possible to grant full disk access rights to bacula-fd, and since I did that I got far less access errors (the test backup has not yet completed), in fact so far only 3: Could not stat "/Users/user1/Library/Containers/com.apple.mail/Data/DataVaults": ERR=Operation not permitted Could not stat "/Users/user2/Library/Application Support/Firefox/Profiles/cb63fvn5.default/storage/permanent/chrome/idb/3870112724rsegmnoittet-es.sqlite-wal": ERR=No such file or directory Could not stat "/Users/user2/Library/Containers/com.apple.mail/Data/DataVaults": ERR=Operation not permitted Not sure why that is, as bacula-fd should have full access rights now. Does someone know what’s going on there and how to fix it? All the best, JC > On 23. Mar 2022, at 13:37, UGE Serge (FR2010) <u...@unistra.fr> wrote: > > Hello Justin, > > I installed facula-fd on 3 macs, and I got at each time the same error than > you: > "Could not open directory "/Users/moses/Pictures/Photos > Library.photoslibrary": ERR=Operation not permitted" > > It should not work like this. After many tests, the only way I found to make > it run with no errors is: > > - Download form https://macappstore.org/bacula-fd/ > <https://macappstore.org/bacula-fd/> > - Install bacula-fd > - Run it to see if you have the error. > - If yes, remove completly bacula-fd > - Re-install it. > > .... and then it works. I do not know why but it does the job (backup + > restore). > > I hope this can help you. > > Serge UGE > > De: "Justin Case" <jus7inc...@gmail.com> > À: "bacula-users" <bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net> > Envoyé: Mardi 22 Mars 2022 13:52:03 > Objet: [Bacula-users] Q: Correct FD setup for macOS 10.15 > > Dear all, > > I just made a test installation of bacula-fd on macOS 10.15 using homebrew > (so I did not need to compile anything). > I configured the bacula-fd.conf and set up a fileset for “/Users” to backup > all user data. I enabled the option HfsPlusSupport, but the machine actually > does use APFS, is that a problem? > I also set up corresponding pools and scheduled jobs for the storage tiers. > > Now running the job for storage tier 1 I can see that the FD (running as > root) on the macOS machine cannot access a lot of directories. > > Some examples: > > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Pictures/Photos Library.photoslibrary": ERR=Operation not > permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Desktop": ERR=Operation not permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/CallHistoryTransactions": > ERR=Operation not permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/com.apple.sharedfilelist": > ERR=Operation not permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/com.apple.TCC": ERR=Operation not > permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/FileProvider": ERR=Operation not > permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/AddressBook": ERR=Operation not > permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Application Support/CallHistoryDB": ERR=Operation not > permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/Autosave Information": ERR=Operation not permitted > 22-Mar 13:28 macmachine-fd JobId 116: Could not open directory > "/Users/moses/Library/IdentityServices": ERR=Operation not permitted > etc. > Does someone have a proper setup for the macOS FD and the filesets that runs > fine and also restore will work as expected? > > This is my current bacula-fd.conf on macOS: > > Director { > Name = bacula-dir > Password = “snip" > } > > Director { > Name = bacula-mon > Password = “snip" > Monitor = yes > } > > FileDaemon { # this is me > Name = macmachine-fd > FDport = 9102 # where we listen for the director > WorkingDirectory = /usr/local/var/lib/bacula > Pid Directory = /usr/local/var/run > Maximum Concurrent Jobs = 20 > Plugin Directory = /usr/local/Cellar/bacula-fd/11.0.6/lib > } > > Messages { > Name = Standard > director = bacula-dir = all, !skipped, !restored, !saved > > > > Here are the relevant directives from bacula-dir.conf: > > Client { > Name = "macmachine-fd" > Address = "mac.lan.net <http://mac.lan.net/>" > FdPort = 9102 > Password = “snip" > Catalog = "MyCatalog" > FileRetention = 5184000 > JobRetention = 15552000 > AutoPrune = yes > } > > Job { > Name = "mac-users-tier1" > Type = "Backup" > Level = "Full" > Messages = "Standard" > Storage = "unraid-tier1-storage" > Pool = "mac-users-full" > FullBackupPool = "mac-users-full" > IncrementalBackupPool = "mac-users-incr" > Client = “macmachine-fd" > Fileset = “m-uacsers" > Schedule = "First-Fri-Full" > JobDefs = "DefaultJob" > Enabled = yes > AllowIncompleteJobs = no > AllowDuplicateJobs = no > } > > Similarly for Tier 2 > > Schedule { > Name = "First-Fri-Full" > Description = "First Friday of the month - Full" > Run = Level="Full" 1st fri at 22:00 > Run = Level="Incremental" sun,mon,tue,wed,thu,sat at 22:00 > Run = Level="Incremental" Accurate=yes 2nd,3rd,4th,5th fri at 22:00 > } > > Fileset { > Name = "mac-users" > Description = "All user home directories" > EnableVss = no > Include { > File = "/Users" > Options { > HfsPlusSupport = "Yes" > } > } > } > > Pool { > Name = "mac-users-full" > PoolType = "Backup" > LabelFormat = "mac-users-full-vol-" > ActionOnPurge = "Truncate" > MaximumVolumes = 100 > MaximumVolumeJobs = 1 > MaximumVolumeBytes = 50000000000 > VolumeRetention = 6048000 > AutoPrune = no > Catalog = "MyCatalog" > } > Pool { > Name = "mac-users-incr" > PoolType = "Backup" > LabelFormat = "mac-users-incr-vol-" > ActionOnPurge = "Truncate" > MaximumVolumes = 20 > MaximumVolumeJobs = 6 > MaximumVolumeBytes = 50000000000 > VolumeRetention = 6048000 > AutoPrune = no > Catalog = "MyCatalog" > } > > All the best, > JC > > > > > _______________________________________________ > Bacula-users mailing list > Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users
_______________________________________________ Bacula-users mailing list Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users
