> On Mon, 20 Feb 2006 18:34:40 -0500, "Roman Turovsky" > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >> > Dear Arthur, >> > as far as I know this manuscript is also in the Bibliotheque national >> > in >> > Paris. >> > It seems to have no number - don't ask me what that means, I have it >> > probably from the Weiss edition: F-Pn Ms. o. Sig (IX) >> > >> > It is a late manuscript, though it seems to have some early fantasias >> > by >> > Weiss (if the a Roma is correct). >> Beier is of the opinion that the Weiss part of that ms. actually contains >> the music by Weiss the father. >> RT >> > > The title of the manuscript tells another story. > And if the ms was in fact possessed by Luise Gottsched, that knew Weiss > quite well, then that doesn't speak for Beier either. > I think, these pieces are more in the style of SLWeiss than the pieces of > V18671. If one wants ascribe pieces to father > Weiss, then it would be more adequate to ascribe this pieces to him. As I recall the pieces in question are the Fantasias.
> The pieces are ascribed to Silvius Weiss in other sources (Breitkopf > incipits, Harrach). Don'd the Breitkopf incipits ascribe some Lauffensteiner material to SLV? RT To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
