Sir you can also add to your valuable observations the concept of survival mechanism of darwin, wherein humans like animals develop treason,false propaganda,violence, arrogance etc: as their survival mechanisms.Naxals are no different.
On Mon, Oct 12, 2009 at 5:41 PM, Amitabh Thakur <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Friends, > > Today the threat of Naxalism (known by so many names) has been accepted as > being among the biggest threats to our country. The situation is almost > alike an all-out war where both the State and the extra-constitutional > forces seem to be interlocked in a deadly fight. And when any State, with > all its might, decides over something, more often than not, it succeeds in > achieving its goal and purpose. > Yet, the fact remains that the lure of the Left is among such phenomenon > that is bound to remain all the time, at all places. The idea of waging a > righteous war against the system, the imagery of being the protectors of the > poor and the hapless and the concept of being the voice of the voiceless are > some such thoughts that always have a sufficiently large number of takers. > There could always be a question as regards the extent to which such ideas > exist in an individual as also regarding the genuineness and commitment of > those who claim to be the forbearers of such ideas but there can be no > denying that Left and Ultra-left are such basic ideas which have their > existence rooted in the very genesis of Human thought. > Here is an attempt to show it through a brief academic analysis- > 1. Left, Right and Center are three broad categories in which Human Thought > processes can be divided. If there shall be a Centrist way of thinking and a > Rightist way of thinking, there will also be some kind of Leftist way of > thinking as well. This seems to be as natural as it can be. > 2. Extending the same further, we can see that Left and Right both move > have a scope to tend to their respective infinities, just as we see in the > Number system. > 3. Hence, extreme Left (like the one seen all over the world on so many > occasions) and Extreme Right (example being that of Hitler and Mussolini) > are such phenomenons that always have a scope of popping up. > 4. The same can also be seen through the most popular of the Statistical > distribution tables, known as Normal distribution, which as we all know is > Bell-shaped. Here all situations ranging from minus infinity to plus > infinity are possible with varying probability. Thus, extrapolating this > concept to the various possible ideologies, we see that while Centrist ideas > and those closer to center (on both the Right and the Left) have a much > higher probability of existence, yet the presence of extreme ideologies can > not be ruled out. > 5. This must have been the reason for all kinds of ideologies existing > since the advent of human race- in different forms. > 6. Left and Extreme Left also have some kind of glamour and romanticism > attached to it. This must have been the reason for such extremely talented > people with bright future as Che Guevera, Fidel Castro, Lenin, Charu > Mazumdar et al to have given up everything to get attracted to this, with > varying degree of success. > 7. Again, whenever the Left or extreme Left has been able to acquire power > finally, it tends to have more and more of Centrist tendencies. It is akin > to water flowing from higher level to lower level naturally. > Thus, science and nature seem to point out that Ultra Left ideologies have > an inbuilt place in human existence. But, then since the prime role of State > is related to Peace and tranquility in the Society, hence no government > (acting on behalf of the State) can ever tolerate any such kind of > aberration and anomaly that questions its very existence. > Hence, such a struggle, time and again. > > Amitabh Thakur > IPS, > Currently at IIM Lucknow > # 94155-34526 > > > -- vikas dhankhar research engineer c-dot new delhi
