We thought of two other differences between this zone and the others:
1. this zone has NS records with servers that are in the zone itself, and
2. our global "also-notify" option contain IP addresses that resolve to host
names in this zone.
Could the problem be the result of the servers notifying each other?
On 2 Mar 2012, at 5:13 PM, David Kreindler wrote:
> When BIND 9.9.0 was released, we started converting our DNSSEC-signed zones
> to inline signing.
>
> Everything went smoothly with all but one of our zones ("pesky.zone", below).
> With that zone, after named signed it and completed an AXFR-style IXFR to
> each of four slaves, it proceeded to start repeatedly incrementing the SOA
> serial and retransferring. By the time we stopped it, named had incremented
> the serial almost 200 times, with corresponding IXFRs.
>
> There is nothing different about this zone from any of our others, except
> that it contains somewhat more RRs. (There are no dynamic updates permitted,
> no DS records for delegated subdomains, nothing else that we could think of
> to explain the behavior.)
>
> Why would named go crazy when we configure inline signing for this one zone,
> when all of our other zones are working fine with inline signing?
>
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: received control channel command
> 'reconfig'
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: loading configuration from
> '/etc/named.conf'
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: reading built-in trusted keys from
> file '/etc/bind.keys'
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: using default UDP/IPv4 port range:
> [1024, 65535]
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: using default UDP/IPv6 port range:
> [1024, 65535]
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: prefix length for ::1 is unknown
> (assume 128)
> Mar 2 14:33:14 ns0 named[806928]: sizing zone task pool based on 207
> zones
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN: (master) removed
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: prefix length for ::1 is unknown
> (assume 128)
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: reloading configuration succeeded
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN (unsigned):
> loaded serial 2012030200
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: any newly configured zones are now
> loaded
> ...
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN (signed): loaded
> serial 2012030200
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 daemon:err|error named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN
> (signed): receive_secure_serial: unchanged
> Mar 2 14:33:15 ns0 named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN (signed):
> reconfiguring zone keys
> Mar 2 14:33:16 ns0 named[806928]: zone pesky.zone/IN (signed): next
> key event: 02-Mar-2012 15:33:15.740
> Mar 2 14:33:16 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42941/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR started: TSIG
> ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:17 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48695/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR started: TSIG
> ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:17 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52228/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR started: TSIG
> ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:17 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42941/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:17 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51606/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR started: TSIG
> ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:18 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48695/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:18 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52228/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:18 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51606/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': AXFR-style IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:21 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42944/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:21 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42944/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:21 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52229/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:21 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48700/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:21 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51607/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:22 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52229/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:22 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48700/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:22 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51607/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:26 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42945/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:26 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42945/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:26 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52230/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:26 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48702/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:26 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51608/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:27 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48702/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:27 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52230/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:27 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51608/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:31 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42947/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:31 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42947/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:31 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51609/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:31 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48703/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:31 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52231/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:32 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48703/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:32 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51609/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:32 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52231/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:36 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42952/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:36 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42952/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52232/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48706/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51610/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52232/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48706/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:37 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51610/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:41 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42954/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42954/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48709/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52233/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51611/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48709/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52233/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:42 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51611/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:46 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42957/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42957/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51612/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52234/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48710/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51612/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48710/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:47 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52234/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42960/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42960/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51613/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48713/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52235/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48713/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51613/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:52 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52235/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:57 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42962/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:33:57 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42962/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:57 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51614/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:33:57 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48715/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:33:57 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52236/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:33:58 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48715/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:58 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51614/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:33:58 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52236/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:34:02 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42963/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns3
> Mar 2 14:34:02 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns3]#42963/key ns0-ns3
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:34:02 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48718/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns4
> Mar 2 14:34:02 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52237/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns2
> Mar 2 14:34:02 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51615/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR started: TSIG ns0-ns1
> Mar 2 14:34:03 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns4]#48718/key ns0-ns4
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:34:03 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns2]#52237/key ns0-ns2
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> Mar 2 14:34:03 ns0 named[806928]: client [ns1]#51615/key ns0-ns1
> (pesky.zone): transfer of 'pesky.zone/IN': IXFR ended
> ....
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Please visit https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users to unsubscribe
> from this list
>
> bind-users mailing list
> bind-users@lists.isc.org
> https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users
_______________________________________________
Please visit https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users to unsubscribe
from this list
bind-users mailing list
bind-users@lists.isc.org
https://lists.isc.org/mailman/listinfo/bind-users
