-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 2015-06-19 16:36, Matt Whitlock wrote: > On Friday, 19 June 2015, at 3:53 pm, justusranv...@riseup.net wrote: >> I'd also like to note that "prima facie" doesn't mean "always", it >> means >> that "the default assumption, unless proven otherwise." > > Why would you automatically assume fraud by default? Shouldn't the > null hypothesis be the default? Without any information one way or > another, you ought to make *no assumption* about the fraudulence or > non-fraudulence of any given double-spend.
If we have ECDSA proof that an entity intentionally made and publicly announced incompatible promises regarding the disposition of particular Bitcoins under their control, then why shouldn't that be assumed to be a fraud attempt unless shown otherwise? There are ways of achiving transaction fee adjustment after broadcast that do not present the appearance of, or opportunity for, fraud. If those options are available and the user chooses not to use them in favor of the option that does, that makes bad intentions even more probable. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2 iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJVhEasAAoJECpf2nDq2eYjcwIP/25yoRpNvZkkdFfYiBKaiL/g XRH8iFAyM5q3/75sA23vD/fzCNGIRRWYyp8PWk+23NF1gdsgVU6gFNNCUmDbjANv nWTt2Bd926St24jcU+OxMewSGlxpenDSFDNQVtxhNFKst6hoPatwK1Zfa0Eq7/Qw +r0H2Pse1ulrN4P1n5xnrYMq2w/GF3zinNZbrn2KOZCnsDa8lKlP8y9eNFHBJ//Z wDrOcfZ1WLhf5/5xlV1NiH0tdxzABilH0ITimm2LCKbj3JcSJayZlyu4n3NypE0E cVFeYpBaVZW9wuKUv/va5fzcyWDFPAo+OrR2B3siAb8nfY1jONXNhuV3yZ76pzMr j39lvuSpoTbLobnEWMCJQ5bI/ngbhatT57gqMfF92sO0YjMe/gi/iU6urR9fi5Gz 3Ov6QA78vxzy/YduFjkc/1FV2dNdbGJtq6b0stmz5TtM1uljeGUoj6JZ8kOJ0EXn 857KFAqEd3hG9eYtBdFQcYeV2ShndALBQE0k3cqQvV6XYdHwHuTY15i1nq+u91MZ VwsR1M69PrDX5Ps6qo1F6QYJA/fA4fyOZ9dwIvh+cgtu4wBptr/NOpL3XH0kE2+G b2FRGOwdb2KlejIXSL9p4mfJTX9lmk4twbZe2Spjiy4FinOUyzxEobNoUTMcFCU7 Zu2i5yjMlJzrDB8yXz/N =xtXD -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ _______________________________________________ Bitcoin-development mailing list Bitcoin-development@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bitcoin-development