I just finished the audio book AmerIndian 2192 by J. Scott Garibay while 
commuting to work.  Garibay is a new author and I have to say I’m very 
impressed.
The story is easy to follow with the exception of the flashbacks to 20 years 
prior (during the White Earth massacre segments).  There wasn’t a clear 
transition between the present and the flashback.  I assume there was in the 
printed book.  Perhaps a 5 second delay in the audio or similar could be 
performed in future audiobooks.
I had trouble with dialog of the Admiral Lye character.  He appears
to be a cross between Captain Ahab, General Custer and Darth Vader.  I
believe that the point of view of such a butcher is alien to the
author… making it difficult for the dialog to be largely believable. 
Fortunately, the dialog of Admiral Lye is short.  I’m hoping Garibay is
able to revisit Admiral Lye in future novels…  the character has a
great deal of potential (how did Lye become what he did?).
The AmerIndian Confederacy (AC) was created by the AmerIndian
tribals to regain their homeland.  The problem, albeit a minor problem,
is that we’re not given any real incite on how they became a power in
the universe - it was created twenty odd years prior and now is able to
take on Earth?  The AC is a utopian society, a highly successful
business, a mercenary group, and a terrorist group.
The premise:
AmerIndian 2192 is a science-fiction novel that
explores the intriguing possibilities of Native Americans in mankind’s
star flung future. AmerIndian 2192 presents the story of two brothers,
Wovoka and Keokuk, restoring the Native American people to a Homeland
where their vibrant culture can thrive. Lodge ships, Cybershaman
rituals and Tsimshian high technology are all elements in this
action-oriented tale of interstellar politics and personal struggles. 
— Podiobooks.com
I would put it differently:
AmerIndian 2192 is the story of the rebirth of
pre-Columbian Native American culture and a homeland in a far flung
galaxy.  The price required by the Grand Fathers nearly destroys the
homeland after the Ghost Dance ritual is performed.
The narrator, LeighAnn Garibay, performed quite well but it is
obvious she isn’t a professional narrator.  She doesn’t have to be for
this novel.  Kudos to her!
The audiobook on Podiobooks.com easily leaves room for a sequel (please let 
there be one!).  What
happens to the UDA, the clones, and the Admiral Lye (sp)?  Does Wovoka
ever find peace?  How many of the tribals fail transition to the new
life even though they try?  The author has the opportunity to make a
“Garibay” universe here.
I would love to see short stories related to AmerIndian 2192 by Garibay and 
other authors (fan fiction).
I definitely recommend this audiobook! 

http://froebe.net/blog/2008/06/27/audiobook-review-amerindian-2192-by-j-scott-garibay/

 Jason L. Froebe


WebBlog http://jfroebe.livejournal.com
Tech log http://www.froebe.net/blog
Froebe Fibers http://www.froebe-fibers.com


The opinions expressed within are the sole rantings of a raving lunatic and in 
no way reflect the rantings, fits, tantrums, errors, corrections, allocutions, 
or aimless thoughts of Sybase or its employees or of TeamSybase or ISUG. Any 
resemblence to reasonable thought, or any official or published opinion of 
Sybase, TeamSybase or ISUG is merely coincidental, and should be totally 
ignored.

------------------------------------

Have you told a friend today? http://bookcrossing.com/tellafriend

Archives and email list settings:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/BookCrossing



Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/BookCrossing/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/BookCrossing/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to