Hello Yoshiaki,

> I am sending my first bug report, and I hope I am following the
> correct procedure by sending it here first. Apologies if these four
> issues should have been separately reported, but given how some of
> the issues are interrelated, I decided to report them in this email
> thread.

thanks for your e-mail.  AFAIK, it hasn't been reported yet – I've
entered the search term 'clarinet' on

  https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/issues/

and nothing relevant came up.  The nearest one is issue #4477, but
this is something else.  So please open a new issue (or probably
multiple issues if you think it makes sense) and put your findings
there.

> It actualy took me a while to discover that LilyPond featured the
> fingering system for bass clarinet down to Low C, as the website's
> Selected Snippets --> Woodwind diagrams listing didn't cover it
> (though it was inconspicuously listed in the "Woodwind diagrams key
> lists" section. It may be worth including the low bass clarinet
> fingering chart in the future version release?

Certainly.  This looks like an oversight.

> Many thanks for your attention to these issues I discovered. Please
> feel free to reach out to me with any questions you might have. I am
> also active in the usual "lilypond-user" mailing list.

It seems that you are also a clarinet player (AFAIK, the main LilyPond
developers are not) and able to handle Scheme code, so you might help
with fixing the diagrams – perhaps this can be your first code and/or
documentation contribution :-)


    Werner

Reply via email to