all well and good Bill, but in 3 visits to BVARC FD I have been told twice that 
visitors were not welcome and I should leave.
last year I asked to be included in the planning meetings so I could help and 
was cut out of them
working with the scouts last year was fun and the fellow on GOTA last year was 
very nice and we have cooperated on a project since then.  the only contact I 
have had from BVARC this year was your request for a the contact information 
for the “scout guy”.  

You’re a good guy Bill.  You are one of 2-3 in the club who have been welcoming.

based on observation, BVARC is 100 % a contest club and needs to be honest 
about it.
that is ok, but I prefer more casual operations and several members have made 
it clear that I would not be welcome.
and they have used those very words

Oak Forest ARC members greet people as they come in and stopped FD set up to 
help a brand new ham understand the antennas.
THAT is what amateur radio is supposed to be.

see you on 10 meters.

KE5HDF
Ralph


From: Bill Stone 
Sent: Wednesday, July 02, 2014 02:28
To: [email protected] ; BRAZOS VALLEY AMATEUR RADIO CLUB ; 'Ralph (home)' 
Subject: Re: [BVARC] field day lessons



I would like to make a comment on this post keeping in mind that we have not 
had any after action review of Field Day yet and all the facts are not in. I 
have attended 3 different club Field Days and have attended and participated in 
9 BVARC Field Days and NEVER to my knowledge has anyone been told they could 
not attend. The problem that I suspect calls for me to take responsibility for 
the miss information, as I was the bonus points captain at Field Day. NO ONE 
was rejected from Field Day. What was rejected is an assumption that a stand 
alone non designated alpha radio station, separate from GOTA or the freebee 6&2 
meter station as decried in the ARRL Field Day rules to operate the club call 
in the contest from separate antenna and UN coordinated band changes. As it 
turns out in the past this station may have been put on the network grid when 
another station was put out of service with band coordination. Again this is 
not confirmed at this time. As the 2014 FD Bonus Points Captain the station 
equipment in question was to be used for the coordinated solar power bonus 
points effort and then become a stand by radio and antenna spare. As it turns 
out the radio gear was needed as no solar power points were made, GOTA shut 
down early due to a GOTA coach injury and one of the 8 alpha station radios 
went down close to the end of the contest. I make no excuse for not being able 
to stay on top of the problem as after Friday setup Norma was called in to work 
and did not get done till 11AM Saturday. I alone elected to stay home till she 
arrived so we both could attend Field Day. We arrived to the site about 11:40 
Saturday and by then the incident had happened. I will say that the person who 
felt rejected from FD was contacted by me prior to my arrival to Field Day, 
amends were made and an offer to pay for gas and even offered to give a ride to 
him to come back to the Field Day site. This deeply saddens me for my error as 
this person is a friend of mine and I may have been able to redefine the reason 
for the station gear that he brought to the site. Please know that we are 
working to learn from past mistakes made to make for a better 2015 Field Day

73 Bill WS5H



  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Scott Royall via BVARC 
  To: 'Ralph (home)' ; 'BRAZOS VALLEY AMATEUR RADIO CLUB' 
  Sent: Tuesday, July 01, 2014 5:31 PM
  Subject: Re: [BVARC] field day lessons

  I would be interested in more information.

   

  From: BVARC [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Ralph (home) via 
BVARC
  Sent: Tuesday, July 01, 2014 17:27
  To: [email protected]
  Subject: [BVARC] field day lessons

   

  I have refrained from commenting on the reflector for several months and was 
considering unsubscribing to the reflector, but some observations of this years 
FD deserve comment before I do so.

   

  It saddened me to see on this reflector a fellow who wanted to attend but was 
told "no".

   

  I have been to 3 BVARC field days and was summarily turned away at the first 
2.

  being new to radio at the time i had a lot of questions and just wanted to 
watch and learn

  the third time I was several years later and i was turned away from the 
planning sessions but was stubborn enough to stick with it and help with the 
scouts

   

  While going to FD with a different club this year, I heard a fellow who was 
very upset because he had been told he was not welcome at the BVARC FD site.  I 
admit I do not know all the details, but he made his feelings about the club 
very clear.

   

  It appears your tradition continues and is not isolated to just myself

  BVARC has the tendancy to not accept anyone new, searching to learn, or 
unable to devote 100% of their free time to radio.

  (one of your fellows actually worte to tell me that if i was not willing to 
give 110%, i should not bother joining BVARC)

  Some individuals in the club are very welcoming, but others are obnoxious and 
mean spirited.

   

  There are other clubs and other hamfests that are welcoming and OFFER to help 
and actually do so.

  They listen to ideas and and engage in a discussion rather than sneering at 
the newcomer.

  This was the 5th FD i have attended with a club.  It was the first I really 
enjoyed.

  I am supporting them.

   

   



------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  _______________________________________________
  BVARC mailing list
  [email protected]
  http://mail.bvarc.org/mailman/listinfo/bvarc_bvarc.org



------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  No virus found in this message.
  Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
  Version: 2014.0.4716 / Virus Database: 3986/7777 - Release Date: 07/01/14
_______________________________________________
BVARC mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.bvarc.org/mailman/listinfo/bvarc_bvarc.org

Reply via email to