Thanks for the feedback Dave. Glenn may have more comments... Mine are below.
Joe Dave Miner wrote: > Glenn Lagasse wrote: >> All, >> >> I've posted the first rev of the design document for the Virtual Machine >> Constructor project at the following location: >> >> <http://www.opensolaris.org/os/project/caiman/VMC> >> >> Please provide any comments you may have by COB Friday, July 31st. If >> you need more time to review the document, please let me know. >> >> Thanks, >> > > General: section numbering would be helpful in providing review > references. > > VMC DC Manifest: Please consider making these new tags arguments to > the finalizer scripts instead. The DC manifest language seems > somewhat too application-specific when viewed in the context of the > unified engine work, and I'd like to see a moratorium on additional > tags until that's been sorted out some. If that's not practical for > some reason, consider at least introducing a new section specific to > this application of DC to group these tags within so that the clutter > is somewhat confined. I like the suggestion of having the tags be arguments to the finalizer scripts instead. It has the side effect of easing the development of them since I can test them without a manifest. > > Finalizer scripts: Please add notes on why ksh is chosen for these > vs. other possible choices (at least python). Well, I see later on > that you have notes about this in the phasing, but I'd expect it here > where the decision is noted, or at least a reference. Sure. A reference where the decisio is noted would make it clearer. > > Phasing: Since it appears that the bootable AI image work will be > integrated well before your anticipated integration, does it really > make sense to deliver phase 1 as specified here? Agreed. I didn't think we need to deliver Phase I. I had thought that we could check in the finalized scripts as Eric had pointed out checking code in would be a good way to show progress. Perhaps this is not necessary. ? > > Dave > > _______________________________________________ > caiman-discuss mailing list > caiman-discuss at opensolaris.org > http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/caiman-discuss
