All, I thought this would be a simple task, but for the life of me I
can't see how to do it!  All I want to do is convert an MTZ file to
Shel-X format for refinement.  I thought it would take me 2 secs, but
it's taken me at least 5 attempts, and it's still not right!


First I tried mtz2various with this command line:

echo 'labi FP=F SIGFP=SIGF FREE=FreeR_flag\noutp shelx' | mtz2various
hklin 16294 hklout 16294.hkl

with 'HKLF 3' in my .ins file.  This works fine, but then shelxl
complains with:

  11112222333344444444555555556666
 >> -48   0  27   37.49   19.74  -1<< ??

 ** REFLECTION      30  HAS WRONG FORMAT **


OK fair enough I should have read the Shel-X manual first, because it
appears that 'HKLF 3' doesn't accept free R flags, it has to be 'HKLF 4'
(i.e. I's not F's).  So when all else fails read the mtz2various
documentation (at least read it more thoroughly):

* If  only FP SIGFP or IP SIGIP are assigned on LABIN, then h k l FP
SIGFP or h k l IP SIGIP is output.
 

Great, precisely what I want!  So for my second try let's go with:

echo 'labi IP=IMEAN SIGIP=SIGIMEAN FREE=FreeR_flag\noutp shelx' |
mtz2various hklin 16294 hklout 16294.hkl

but no:

 Data line--- labi IP=IMEAN SIGIP=SIGIMEAN FREE=FreeR_flag
MtzParseLabin: neither label recognised: IP IMEAN
 MTZ2VARIOUS:  Error in label assignments in LABIN

Yet the output also says:

 LABIN <program label>=<file label> ...
 Valid program labels are: FP, SIGFP
 and optionally FPH, SIGFPH, IP, SIGIP, FC, PHIC, W, FPART, PHIPART,
PHIB, FOM, HLA HLB HLC HLD FREE


My first thought was "I've got the IMEAN/SIGIMEAN label wrong", but no,
mtzdump says:

 Col Sort    Min    Max    Num      %     Mean     Mean   Resolution
Type Column
 num order               Missing complete          abs.   Low    High
label

   1 ASC    -49      43      0  100.00     -8.7     18.6  48.75   1.33
H  H
   2 NONE     0      32      0  100.00     12.0     12.0  48.75   1.33
H  K
   3 NONE     0      41      0  100.00     15.7     15.7  48.75   1.33
H  L
   4 NONE    4.2   854.8   314   99.01    82.26    82.26  34.92   1.33
F  F
   5 NONE    0.7   241.2   314   99.01     3.38     3.38  34.92   1.33
Q  SIGF
   6 NONE  -58.6  8600.6   314   99.01   146.23   146.25  34.92   1.33
J  IMEAN
   7 NONE    0.5  5370.6   314   99.01     5.88     5.88  34.92   1.33
Q  SIGIMEAN
   8 NONE    0.0    19.0     0  100.00     9.48     9.48  48.75   1.33
I  FreeR_flag


Then I look further down in mtz2various.doc:

   Input labels accepted are:

   H, K, L Indices
   FP, SIGFP F and Sigma for native
   FPH, SIGFPH F and Sigma for derivative
   FC, PHIC F and Phase from model
   FPART, PHIPART F and Phase from partial structure
   DP, SIGDP Anomalous difference and Sigma
   I, SIGI I and Sigma
 

So OK, fair enough IP, SIGIP was a typo (happens all the time in CCP4
documentation!), so problem solved, for my third go let's try:

echo 'labi I=IMEAN SIGI=SIGIMEAN FREE=FreeR_flag\noutp shelx' |
mtz2various hklin 16294 hklout 16294.hkl

Yes it worked!!! or did it???  I see that the output file has "HKLF 3"
in the header, and when I read the log file I see: ****NB Amplitude
Output , flagged with HKLF 3 ***.  No good, Shel-X won't take free R
flags with HKLF 3 - and I thought mtz2various.doc said that if I/SIGI
are assigned then I/SIGI are output? (which would make a lot of sense!).

Then I read in mtz2various.doc:

  FSQUARED

   If  this flag is set, the program expects F and SIGF and will output
I
   and  SIGI: I = F*F, SIGI = 2*SIGF*F + SIGF*SIGF. These intensities
are
   not  necessarily  the same as the measured intensities
(pre-TRUNCATE);
   it is better to use the measured values if you have them.

I completely agree with the last sentence! - but how to make it read I's
and write I's?


So in desperation to get something working, my fourth go is with:

echo 'labi FP=F SIGFP=SIGF FREE=FreeR_flag\nfsqu\noutp shelx' |
mtz2various hklin 16294 hklout 16294.hkl

This works: a file in HKLF 4 format containing apparently I & SIGI is
produced, but again Shel-X complains:

  11112222333344444444555555556666
 >> -48   0  27   37.49   19.74  -1<< ??

 ** REFLECTION      30  HAS WRONG FORMAT **

Aaaargh - back to step 1!


So next I seek advice from a Shel-X user who says they've never seen the
"FREE" text at the end of the test reflection lines, e.g.:

 -48   0  27  114.07  151.73  -1  FREE

and I say something along the lines of "don't be silly there's no way
the program would write it out like that if Shel-X didn't accept it" -
and just to prove to them how dumb their suggestion is I do a global
edit of the file, and of course it turns out they're quite right, and
technically it works - except of course that I is not the same as F^2 if
F has come from truncate (good thing I read the documentation!).

I see that mtz2various.doc says "You may still have trouble getting
exactly the output you want.".  Maybe that's the answer I've been
seeking! - or I've missed something very obvious.  I could of course
have knocked up a jiffy Fortran program in 5 mins to read h, k ,l, I,
SIGI, Rflag in one format and write out h, k, l, I, SIGI, Rflag in
another format (and I'll probably end up doing just that!), but pity
those users who are not programmers!

So what have I missed - any ideas?

-- Ian

Disclaimer

This communication is confidential and may contain privileged information 
intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed 
except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended 
recipient you must not review, use, disclose, copy, distribute or take any 
action in reliance upon it. If you have received this communication in error, 
please notify Astex Therapeutics Ltd by emailing [EMAIL PROTECTED] and destroy 
all copies of the message and any attached documents. 



Astex Therapeutics Ltd monitors, controls and protects all its messaging 
traffic in compliance with its corporate email policy. The Company accepts no 
liability or responsibility for any onward transmission or use of emails and 
attachments having left the Astex Therapeutics domain.  Unless expressly 
stated, opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of 
Astex Therapeutics Ltd. The recipient should check this email and any 
attachments for the presence of computer viruses. Astex Therapeutics Ltd 
accepts no liability for damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. 
E-mail is susceptible to data corruption, interception, unauthorized amendment, 
and tampering, Astex Therapeutics Ltd only send and receive e-mails on the 
basis that the Company is not liable for any such alteration or any 
consequences thereof.

Reply via email to