Ron Stordahl <[email protected]> wrote: > I have done as you requested, providing for each failing burn an analysis of > the debug logs with my comments > about things that don't seem right.
Please try to stay below 40 kB in future, then the mail will not be blocked... > There is a bit of guessing involved, as I don't completely understand the > details of the reports generated by cdrecord -v with the many reporting > options. > > I tried to pick out the anomalies by comparing a run with CD-R to an > otherwise identical run with CD-RW. All 9 drives tested successfully burn > the E-CD when using CD-RW. I think this is the best I can do in comparing > failing vs successful > burns. I used a diff line program WinMerge to make the comparisions. > > The files which contain all the debug data are contained in > http://204.221.76.52/cd/Edited_Debug_Logs.7z > They are edited to make the timestamps all 00:00.00: to facilitate > comparison. The unedited debug logs are > in the full test set http://204.221.76.52/cd/E-CD_Test.7z in the > appropriately named folders. > > This an overwhelming amout of test data, however I felt it would be best to > provide it all at once. > > I am sure you are a very busy person, so please review this when time allows. > I am in no hurry. > > Since all the tested drives will successfully burn the large E-CD with > CD-RW's, a work-around is to use CD-RW > and if needed to image the multisession CD-RW onto a CD-R. A program, > ImgBurn, will do that successfully in a single step, even to those drives > which fail to create the E-CD in my testing. Correct, using CD-RW helps to save money for testing. > The 5 failing drives are (Short ID - Long ID): > > LG_E60N = "LG HL-DT-ST DVD-RAM GSA-E60N Rev 1r00" > Phillips = "Phillips PLDS DVE+-RW DH-16AAS Rev JD12" > > Plextor = "Plextor PX-891SAF Rev 1rT2" > Samsung = "Samsung TSSTcorp CDDVDW SE-218GNRSBD Rev TS00 USB 2015" > Sony = "Sony DVD RW DRU-830A_SS22" > > The numbers starting at column 1 are line numbers in the associated files. > Lines without line numbers are comments. > > The 'diff' program used is WinMerge. Use CTRL+Shift+C to copy with line > numbers. > > In the file names: > LRF indicates Large E-CD on CD-R Failed > LRWS indicates Large E-CD on CD-RW Successful > > Test drive: ASUS > =================== > > Comparison of ASUS_LRS (Large, CD-R, Successful) vs ASUS_LRWS (Large, CD-RW, > Successful): > ********** > > There are no significant differences other than things directly related to R > vs RW. Addresses nearly identical. The E-CD was created successfully in both > cases > > ********** > > Test drive: LG_E60N > ==================== > > Comparison of LG_E60N_LRF (Failed using a CD-R disc) vs LG_E60N_LRWS > (Succeeded using a CD-RW disc): > ********** > > File: LG_E60N_LRF.txt (Failed): > > 539: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 540: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 616: 00:00.00: > Sending CUE sheet... > 617: 00:00.00: > cdrecord: CUE sheet not accepted. Retrying with minimum > pregapsize = 1. > 618: 00:00.00: > cdrecord: Input/output error. write_g1: scsi sendcmd: no > error > 619: 00:00.00: > CDB: 2A 00 FF FF D1 B7 00 02 9F 00 > > cdrtfe message: cdrecord: Could not write Lead-In. Could not proceed. If "cdrfe" is creating a cue sheet that is not accepted by the drive, then this is either caused by a bug in the firmware of the drive or by a non-standard created by "cdrfe". > ---------- > > File: LG_E60N_LRWS.txt (Successful): > > 534: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 535: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 621: 00:00.00: > Sending CUE sheet... > 622: 00:00.00: > cdrecord: CUE sheet not accepted. Retrying with minimum > pregapsize = 1. > 623: 00:00.00: > SAO startsec: -11077 > 624: 00:00.00: > Writing lead-in... > 625: 00:00.00: > Lead-in write time: 19.609s (00:00:19.609) > 626: 00:00.00: > Writing pregap for track 1 at -150 > > Comment: Writing continues with the E-CD being successfully written. This seems to verify that the CUE sheet is not 100% correct as is is accepted by the drive after it was slightly modified by cdrecord. So you need to to send a bugreport against cderfe. BTW: where is the cue sheet file? > ********** > > Test drive Phillips > ==================== > > Comparison of Phillips_LRF.txt (Failed using a CD-R disc) vs > Phillips_LRWS.txt (Succeeded using a CD-RW disc): > ********** > > File: Phillips_LRF.txt (Failed): > > 549: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 550: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 speed=10 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 876: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -minfo -v > > 936: 00:00.00: > disk status: incomplete/appendable > 937: 00:00.00: > session status: incomplete/appendable > > Comment: Line 937 seems to indicate a problem. > > 949: 00:00.00: > Track Sess Type Start Addr End Addr Size > 950: 00:00.00: > ============================================== > 951: 00:00.00: > 1 1 Audio 0 22663 22664 -1 > 952: 00:00.00: > 2 1 Audio 22664 47263 24600 0 > 953: 00:00.00: > 3 1 Audio 47264 73500 26237 22664 > 954: 00:00.00: > 4 1 Audio 73501 109724 36224 47264 > 955: 00:00.00: > 5 1 Audio 109725 157049 47325 73501 > 956: 00:00.00: > 6 1 Audio 157050 199425 42376 109725 > 957: 00:00.00: > 7 1 Audio 199426 217727 18302 157050 > 958: 00:00.00: > 8 1 Audio 217728 251763 34036 199426 > 959: 00:00.00: > 9 2 Audio 263164 1166727 903564 229128 > 960: 00:00.00: > > 961: 00:00.00: > Last session start address: 263164 > 962: 00:00.00: > Last session leadout start address: 1166728 > 963: 00:00.00: > > 964: 00:00.00: > Execution completed. > > Comment: Line 959 seems to indicate a problem. > > Message: Not enough space on this disc. MiByte available (without > indicating any number before MiByte) If cdrfe creates orders that result in images that cannot fit on the CD, you need to make a bug report against cdrfe. > Comment: Could not proceed to write CD-ROM session. > ---------- > > File Phillips_LRWS.txt (Successful): > > 540: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 541: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 speed=10 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Large/Large.cue > > 911: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -minfo -v > > 982: 00:00.00: > disk status: incomplete/appendable > 983: 00:00.00: > session status: empty > > 995: 00:00.00: > Track Sess Type Start Addr End Addr Size > > 996: 00:00.00: > ============================================== > 997: 00:00.00: > 1 1 Audio 0 22663 22664 -1 > 998: 00:00.00: > 2 1 Audio 22664 47263 24600 0 > 999: 00:00.00: > 3 1 Audio 47264 73500 26237 22664 > 1000: 00:00.00: > 4 1 Audio 73501 109724 36224 47264 > 1001: 00:00.00: > 5 1 Audio 109725 157049 47325 73501 > 1002: 00:00.00: > 6 1 Audio 157050 199425 42376 109725 > 1003: 00:00.00: > 7 1 Audio 199426 217727 18302 157050 > 1004: 00:00.00: > 8 1 Audio 217728 251763 34036 199426 > 1005: 00:00.00: > 9 2 Blank 263164 359846 96683 229128 > 1006: 00:00.00: > > 1007: 00:00.00: > Last session start address: 0 > 1008: 00:00.00: > Last session leadout start address: 251764 > 1009: 00:00.00: > Next writable address: 263164 > 1010: 00:00.00: > Remaining writable size: 96683 > 1011: 00:00.00: > > 1012: 00:00.00: > Execution completed. > > Comment: Program proceeded to write the CD-ROM session successfully. Why is the size less than before? > Comment: Program proceeded to write the CD-ROM session successfully. > > ********** > > Test drive: Samsung > ==================== > > Comparison of Samsung_LRF.txt (Failed using a CD-R disc) vs Samsung_LRWS.txt > (Succeeded using a CD-RW disc): > ********** > > File Samsung_LRF.txt (Failed): > > 569: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 570: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 900: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -minfo -v > > 961: 00:00.00: > disk status: incomplete/appendable > 962: 00:00.00: > session status: empty > > 1508: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -xa -v -tao > /cygdrive/C/Users/RON_ST~1/AppData/Local/Temp/image.iso > > 1568: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 1569: 00:00.00: > 359847 2048 0x00 Formatted Media > 1570: 00:00.00: > Blocks total: 359847 Blocks current: 96683 Blocks > remaining: 7465 > 1571: 00:00.00: > Starting to write CD/DVD/BD at speed 24 in real TAO mode > for single session. > > 1592: 00:00.00: > Reading TOC of Disc. Please wait ... > 1593: 00:00.00: > Comparing 28 files with the source files ... > 1594: 00:00.00: > > 1595: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\AUTORUN.INF > 1596: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy01.fil > 1597: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy02.fil > 1598: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy03.fil > 1599: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy04.fil > 1600: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy05.fil > 1601: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy06.fil > 1602: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy07.fil > 1603: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy08.fil > 1604: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy09.fil > 1605: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy10.fil > 1606: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy11.fil > 1607: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy12.fil > 1608: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy13.fil > 1609: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy14.fil > 1610: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy15.fil > 1611: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy16.fil > 1612: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy17.fil > 1613: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy18.fil > 1614: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy19.fil > 1615: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy20.fil > 1616: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy21.fil > 1617: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy22.fil > 1618: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy23.fil > 1619: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy24.fil > 1620: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy25.fil > 1621: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : > d:\E-CD_Test_Test_Procedure.pdf > 1622: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\ShellRun.exe > 1623: 00:00.00: > > 1624: 00:00.00: > 28 error(s) found. > > Comment: Windows does not see the CD-ROM session it appears. > > 1637: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -toc -v > > 1692: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 1693: 00:00.00: > 352382 2048 0x00 Formatted Media > 1694: 00:00.00: > first: 1 last 9 > 1695: 00:00.00: > track: 1 lba: 0 ( 0) 00:02:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1696: 00:00.00: > track: 2 lba: 22664 ( 90656) 05:04:14 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1697: 00:00.00: > track: 3 lba: 47264 ( 189056) 10:32:14 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1698: 00:00.00: > track: 4 lba: 73501 ( 294004) 16:22:01 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1699: 00:00.00: > track: 5 lba: 109725 ( 438900) 24:25:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1700: 00:00.00: > track: 6 lba: 157050 ( 628200) 34:56:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1701: 00:00.00: > track: 7 lba: 199426 ( 797704) 44:21:01 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1702: 00:00.00: > track: 8 lba: 217728 ( 870912) 48:25:03 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1703: 00:00.00: > track: 9 lba: 263164 ( 1052656) 58:30:64 adr: 1 > control: 4 mode: -1 > 1704: 00:00.00: > track:lout lba: 352382 ( 1409528) 78:20:32 adr: 1 > control: 4 mode: -1 > 1705: 00:00.00: > > 1706: 00:00.00: > Execution completed. > > Comment: Line 1703 shows "4 mode: -1", whereas for successful burn CD-RW > shows "4 mode: 2" (see below) > > Comment: Beyond this point things look normal to me. > > Comment: The burn is unsuccessful. Windows does not see the CD-ROM session. > > ---------- > > File Samsung_LRWS.txt (Successful): > > 555: 00:00.00: > Start: Disc Image > 556: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 925: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -minfo -v > > 996: 00:00.00: > disk status: incomplete/appendable > 997: 00:00.00: > session status: empty > > 1538: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -xa -v -tao > /cygdrive/C/Users/RON_ST~1/AppData/Local/Temp/image.iso > > 1606: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 1607: 00:00.00: > 359849 2048 0x00 Formatted Media > 1608: 00:00.00: > 359849 2048 0x00 Reserved (0) > 1609: 00:00.00: > 295264 32 0x10 Reserved (0) > 1610: 00:00.00: > Blocks total: 359849 Blocks current: 96685 Blocks > remaining: 7467 > 1611: 00:00.00: > Starting to write CD/DVD/BD at speed 10 in real TAO mode > for single session. > > > 1632: 00:00.00: > Reading TOC of Disc. Please wait ... > 1633: 00:00.00: > Comparing 28 files with the source files ... > 1634: 00:00.00: > > 1635: 00:00.00: > 0 error(s) found. > > Comment: Successful verify of files in CD-ROM session with source files. > > 1648: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -toc -v > > 1711: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 1712: 00:00.00: > 352382 2048 0x00 Formatted Media > 1713: 00:00.00: > 352382 2048 0x00 Reserved (0) > 1714: 00:00.00: > 295264 32 0x10 Reserved (0) > 1715: 00:00.00: > first: 1 last 9 > 1716: 00:00.00: > track: 1 lba: 0 ( 0) 00:02:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1717: 00:00.00: > track: 2 lba: 22664 ( 90656) 05:04:14 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1718: 00:00.00: > track: 3 lba: 47264 ( 189056) 10:32:14 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1719: 00:00.00: > track: 4 lba: 73501 ( 294004) 16:22:01 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1720: 00:00.00: > track: 5 lba: 109725 ( 438900) 24:25:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1721: 00:00.00: > track: 6 lba: 157050 ( 628200) 34:56:00 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1722: 00:00.00: > track: 7 lba: 199426 ( 797704) 44:21:01 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1723: 00:00.00: > track: 8 lba: 217728 ( 870912) 48:25:03 adr: 1 > control: 0 mode: -1 > 1724: 00:00.00: > track: 9 lba: 263164 ( 1052656) 58:30:64 adr: 1 > control: 4 mode: 2 > 1725: 00:00.00: > track:lout lba: 352382 ( 1409528) 78:20:32 adr: 1 > control: 4 mode: -1 > 1726: 00:00.00: > > 1727: 00:00.00: > Execution completed. > > Comment: Line 17243 shows "4 mode: 2", whereas for unsuccessful burn CD-R > shows "4 mode: -1" > > Comment: The burn successfully created the Large E-CD. > > ********** > > Test drive: Sony > ==================== > > Comparison of Sony_LRF.txt (Failed using a CD-R disc) vs Sony_LRWS.txt > (Succeeded using a CD-RW disc): > ********** > > File Sony_LRF.txt (Failed): > > 167: "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -prcap > > 181: Write Performance: > 182: START LBA: 0 > 183: End LBA: 359834 > > 467: "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -minfo -silent -v > > 521: ATIP start of lead in: -11849 (97:24/01) > > Comment: For successful burn, Sony_LRWS.txt, above line is -11077 > > 522: ATIP start of lead out: 359847 (79:59/72) > > 527: Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 528: 16763814 2048 0x00 No Media Present > or Unknown Capacity > > 542: last start of lead in: -11849 > 543: last start of lead out: 359847 > > 562: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -v -multi -pad -text -dao > cuefile=/cygdrive/C/Users/Ron_Stordahl/Documents/E-CD_Test_Test/Test_Files/Large/Large.cue > > 630: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 631: 00:00.00: > 16763814 2048 0x00 No Media Present > or Unknown Capacity > 632: 00:00.00: > Blocks total: 359847 Blocks current: 359847 Blocks > remaining: 108083 > 633: 00:00.00: > Starting to write CD/DVD/BD at speed 40 in real SAO mode for > multi session. > > 640: 00:00.00: > SAO startsec: -11849 > > Comment: For the successful burn with CD-RW this was -11077 > > 1030: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > dev=0,0,0 -prcap -v > > 1040: 00:00.00: > Write Performance: > 1041: 00:00.00: > START LBA: 0 > 1042: 00:00.00: > End LBA: 359834 > > Comment: For the successful burn with CD-RW this was 166 > > 1492: 00:00.00: > "C:\Program Files (x86)\cdrtfe\tools\cdrtools\cdrecord" > gracetime=5 dev=0,0,0 driveropts=burnfree -xa -v -tao > /cygdrive/C/Users/RON_ST~1/AppData/Local/Temp/image.iso > > 1552: 00:00.00: > Capacity Blklen/Sparesz. Format-type Type > 1553: 00:00.00: > 251764 2048 0x00 Formatted Media > 1554: 00:00.00: > Blocks total: 359847 Blocks current: 96683 Blocks > remaining: 7465 > 1555: 00:00.00: > Starting to write CD/DVD/BD at speed 40 in real TAO mode > for single session. > > 1576: 00:00.00: > Reading TOC of Disc. Please wait ... > 1577: 00:00.00: > Comparing 28 files with the source files ... > 1578: 00:00.00: > > 1579: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\AUTORUN.INF > 1580: 00:00.00: > Error! File not found : d:\Dummy01.fil The result depends on whether you created a correct ISO image first and whether the image did fit on the CD. Jörg -- EMail:[email protected] (home) Jörg Schilling D-13353 Berlin [email protected] (work) Blog: http://schily.blogspot.com/ URL: http://cdrecord.org/private/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/schilytools/files/' ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Site24x7 APM Insight: Get Deep Visibility into Application Performance APM + Mobile APM + RUM: Monitor 3 App instances at just $35/Month Monitor end-to-end web transactions and take corrective actions now Troubleshoot faster and improve end-user experience. Signup Now! http://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/clk?id=272487151&iu=/4140 _______________________________________________ Cdrtools-support mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/cdrtools-support
