At 11:16 AM 2/18/02, Howard wrote:
>UGGGGGGGGGG!
>
>What petition of Arthur Robinson?
>
>The petition is from SEPP, which has no connection with Arthur Robinson.
>Can't you get your facts straight?  SEPP is headed by Dr. Frederick Seitz,
>president emeritus of Rockefeller University and a past president of the
>U.S. National Academy of Sciences.  The petition was signed by 17,000
>scientists worldwide.  Do have any evidence that Arthur Robison even signed
>it?

 From the web site that I linked to in my earlier message:
http://www.prwatch.org/improp/oism.html
(you do know how to click on links don't you?)

The Oregon Petition, sponsored by the OISM,
               was circulated in April 1998 in a bulk mailing to
               tens of thousands of U.S. scientists. In addition to
               the petition, the mailing included what appeared to
               be a reprint of a scientific paper. Authored by
               OISM's Arthur B. Robinson and three other
               people, the paper was titled "Environmental
               Effects of Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide" and was
               printed in the same typeface and format as the
               official Proceedings of the National Academy of
               Sciences. A cover note from Frederick Seitz, who
               had served as president of the NAS in the 1960s,
               added to the impression that Robinson's paper
               was an official publication of the academy's
               peer-reviewed journal.

In reality, neither Robinson's paper nor OISM's
               petition drive had anything to do with the National
               Academy of Sciences, which first heard about the
               petition when its members began calling to ask if
               the NAS had taken a stand against the Kyoto
               treaty. Robinson was not even a climate scientist.
               He was a biochemist with no published research
               in the field of climatology, and his paper had never
               been subjected to peer review by anyone with
               training in the field. In fact, the paper had never
               been accepted for publication anywhere, let alone
               in the NAS Proceedings. It was self-published by
               Robinson, who did the typesetting himself on his
               own computer.
The NAS issued an unusually blunt formal
               response to the petition drive. "The NAS Council
               would like to make it clear that this petition has
               nothing to do with the National Academy of
               Sciences and that the manuscript was not
               published in the Proceedings of the National
               Academy of Sciences or in any other
               peer-reviewed journal," it stated in a news
               release. "The petition does not reflect the
               conclusions of expert reports of the Academy." In
               fact, it pointed out, its own prior published study
               had shown that "even given the considerable
               uncertainties in our knowledge of the relevant
               phenomena, greenhouse warming poses a
               potential threat sufficient to merit prompt
               responses. Investment in mitigation measures acts
               as insurance protection against the great
               uncertainties and the possibility of dramatic
               surprises."
______________________________________________________________________
Macromedia ColdFusion 5 Training from the Source
  Step by Step ColdFusion
  http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0201758474/houseoffusion

Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to