Nick McClure wrote:
>Well first, he has invaded other countries in the past.
>
>He continues to seek offensive weapons of mass destruction.
>
>He continues to torture and persecute the people of Iraq, they continue
>to live in fear of his chemical weapons and tactics.
>
>The first reason is not reason enough alone, but you add that with the
>weapons he seeks, and you have a potentially dangerous belligerent.

Replace(justification,"Iraq","Pakistan","All")
Replace(justification,"Iraq","Libya","All")

So is the next war before or after Christmas?


>My question for you is, if the world agrees that Saddam and Iraq should
>not have the weapons, and allow ALL the people of Iraq to not live in
>fear, then why are so many against war?

I will try to give some answers, but you should really ask the people that 
are against the war.


> Simply because it is war?

For some left-wing people that is enough.


> Or because of President Bush?

Most definitely. He might have gained some support in the US for how he is 
handling this situation, but from a foreign affairs point of view he is a 
lost case.
I mean, for about 80 countries in the world the first 2 questions would be:
- what exactly is the policy of the US?
- how does that policy apply to my country?

Considering that the current administration is not able to answer the first
question, countries don't feel secure about the answer to the second 
question and will not support the US for fear that they are the next target
of the US policy. (One of the nicest examples is Russia, when the US went 
down on the Taliban they supported that (because they have the same problem
in Chechnya), but now that the US is using Human Rights as argument they 
don't (because they have a HR problem in Chechnya.)

Naturally, most of these countries are irrelevant, but this group includes 
countries with a questionable track record that happen to be relevant 
because they are neighbours of Iraq.
For many other countries the question is indeed what the US policy is. Why 
is Iraq singled out? What is the long term strategy of the US? The US has 
guided the rebuilding of Japan and Germany for more than 50 years after 
WWII. Is the US willing to keep investing in the builtup of Iraq for such a
long time, or is it just a whim of a president with a grudge and is the US 
going to retreat to their safe continent after the war? What are the 
intentions of the US with post-war Iraq? Why is it that none of the 
briefings about post-war Iraq include the words "democratic"? Does the US 
want to repeat the thing they did in Iran with the Sjah?

None of these questions gets a convincing answer, and that makes it easy to
believe there are other motives.

And then there is the group of people that believe the war is not 
necessary. Who has Saddam attacked lately? What are the chances that Saddam
can use his WMD? Isn't the war something that could have been avoided by 
trying diplomacy a bit harder?


> Remove mans laws from the picture, and talk about ethics, People ought
> to be free, they ought to have the right to life, liberty, and the
> pursuit of happiness. People with a government which does not try to
> remove these rights ought to do what they can to ensure that all people
> have these rights.

I very much agree. So to Ctrl-Z mans laws again, when does the military 
support for Saudi Arabia and Egypt stop? ;-)


> No government, even democratic, should be allowed to persecute and
> torture people based on any personal belief or idea.

I don't think that torture is ever allowed, regardless of the reason.


> Laws should not be
> permitted which prevent the people from learning the truth, or
> expressing their opinions or faiths. People should have fair trials,
> where the decision is not made by the government itself, but by an
> impartial jury.

Not necessarily a jury, judge has its advantages as well. *impartial* is 
the important word.


> Countries should not seek the means to kill innocent people. I know we
> have such weapons, and they are deployed, but they were built and
> deployed as a deterrent, for the protection of the US, while we have
> first strike capabilities, we never intended to use them.

Cuba crisis? Some hothead generals during the Korean War? Don't tell me 
they didn't plan for it.

Ethics apply universally.


> Americans may be quick to jump to war, but that is because we have seen
> a number of wars in our short history, and we know that when a fight is
> inevitable it is best to do it your own terms.

I think the answer to the question whether a fight is inevitable depends on
what the objective is. And that is something where the Bush administration 
is sending mixed signals at best.

Jochem

PS I will try to answer some more messages tomorrow, but with the current 
speed of the archives that is a mission impossible. And please cut 
everything you are not specifically responding to keep those archives usable.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|
Archives: http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/index.cfm?forumid=5
Subscription: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/index.cfm?method=subscribe&forumid=5
Signup for the Fusion Authority news alert and keep up with the latest news in 
ColdFusion and related topics. http://www.fusionauthority.com/signup.cfm

                                Unsubscribe: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/unsubscribe.cfm?user=89.70.5
                                

Reply via email to