http://www.greenleft.org.au/2008/742/38380


The Communist Manifesto: 160 years old and still causing trouble

Review by Barry Healy
29 February 2008


The Manifesto of the Communist Party 
Karl Marx & Frederick Engels (with a commentary by Leon Trotsky) 
Resistance Marxist Library, 1998 
74 pages, $8.50 
Available at <http://www.resistancebooks.com> 


Not many authors can publish a work before they reach 30 years of age and have 
it remain in publication continuously for the following 160 years. Yet, that is 
precisely the case with the Manifesto of the Communist Party (the Communist 
Manifesto), which emerged in the middle of the revolutionary upsurge of 
February 1848. 

Moreover, the Manifesto still rings through the years to today's world with its 
promise of human liberty and fulfilment. 

The democratic wave that swept Europe in 1848 was a consequence of the 
unfinished business of the Great French Revolution of 1789. In that heroic 
revolt the French capitalist class took control of society by winning the lower 
orders to their side by promising liberty, fraternity and equality. The 
reactionary European powers quelled the revolution, without destroying its 
promise. 

The expansion of capitalist production that followed enlarged the working class 
and, by the late 1840s, an economic crisis brought conflict. The unfulfilled 
promises of freedom from 1789 mingled with new urges for liberty from wage 
slavery and helped create the explosion. 

The spark of the rebellion came from Switzerland in November 1847. The struggle 
spread down the Italian peninsula and agitation was rife from one end of Europe 
to the other, with barricades being erected and epic street battles taking 
place in most European capitals. 

During this upsurge the newly formed Communist League bent every effort to 
drive the movement forward, with the secret police of every country hounding 
them and establishment newspapers slandering them. This why the Manifesto 
begins famously with: "A spectre is haunting Europe - the spectre of 
Communism." The Manifesto was the first public statement of the communists, 
newly surfaced from the shadows of underground organising. By the time it came 
off the printing press, Marx was embroiled in revolutionary Paris. 

Just who were these communists? The fact is, the movement had only recently 
united and had barely begun to establish its intellectual foundations when the 
flood of revolution overtook it. 

Marx and Engels were young German intellectuals, critical thinkers trained in 
the exacting method of G.W.F. Hegel, whose philosophical system of dialectics 
Marx developed and revolutionised. Exiled from Germany and having moved through 
radical European circles for several years, they joined the secretive League of 
the Just, a grouping of radical German artisans. 

Within this grouping Marx and Engels argued against what they called "crude 
communism" and other underdeveloped thinking. It was in late 1847, at a London 
congress of the League, that Marx and Engels' ideas won the day, including that 
of moving into the public domain with the Manifesto. 

The crude communists longed for a purified form of pre-capitalist society. Marx 
and Engels proposed a totally different vision. The Manifesto argued that the 
victory of the workers, leading all the downtrodden, would be built upon the 
economic foundations that have been constructed by the capitalists. 

More than this, Marx and Engels argued, the rise of the bourgeoisie (the French 
name for the capitalists) actually prepares the way for socialism. "The 
development of Modern Industry . cuts from under its feet the very foundations 
on which the bourgeoisie produces and appropriates products. What the 
bourgeoisie, therefore, produces, above all, are its own grave-diggers. Its 
fall and the victory of the proletariat are equally inevitable." 

The first section of the Manifesto (entitled "Bourgeois and Proletarians") 
summarises the sweep of the development of class society. It begins bluntly: 
"The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class 
struggles." It surveys the epic development of European capitalism, which 
"sprouted from the ruins of feudal society" and has established "new classes, 
new conditions of oppression, new forms of struggle in place of the old ones". 

More than that, they write: "Our epoch, the epoch of the bourgeoisie, possesses 
. this distinct feature: it has simplified the class antagonisms." Out of these 
sharp lines of class division will emerge the new society that will free 
humanity of all class distinction forever. 

How can such a promise be made? Because in capitalist society "capital is 
independent and has individuality, while the living person is dependent and has 
no individuality". For the capitalist "the labourer lives merely to increase 
capital, and is allowed to live only in so far as the interest of the ruling 
class requires it". 

Do such bold statements still apply? Yes. Even in advanced capitalist countries 
where many workers enjoy the fruits of consumer society, the scrap-heap of 
unemployment and destitution is just a recession away. As for the rest of the 
world, the bourgeoisie doesn't pretend to care if the bulk of humanity lives or 
dies. 

The Manifesto is a clarion call to revolution against bourgeois culture, which 
is, "for the enormous majority, a mere training to act as a machine". But what 
was the communists' promise about the new society that they proposed? 

For a richer sense of Marx and Engels' revolutionary ideas, it is valuable to 
look at some of their earlier writings. In 1845, in The Holy Family, they broke 
new philosophical ground by speaking of how human beings are formed by the 
manner in which we produce our means of subsistence. 

What humans are, they wrote, "coincides with their production, both with what 
they produce and with how they produce. The nature of individuals thus depends 
on the material conditions determining their production." As the mode of 
economic life has changed through history, so human nature has changed. 

Thus the Manifesto's declaration for a new society formed as "an association, 
in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development 
of all" is the promise of a new human nature replacing "the old bourgeois 
society, with its classes and class antagonisms". 

As capitalist economic relations grew so did the tendency for such things as 
the products of labour, money, social relations and even ideas to appear as 
something dominating, separate from human beings. Marx concentrated on the 
alienation of labour and its debilitating consequences on human beings. 

With the domination of the modern factory system, humans had ceased relating to 
themselves and their world except through a veil of capitalist property 
relations. This distortion colours our entire existence. 

For Marx, "Communism is the positive abolition of private property, of human 
self-alienation, and thus the real appropriation of human nature through and 
for man", he wrote in the Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844. 

With such a promise, of course the "ruling classes tremble at a communist 
revolution", as the Manifesto says. 

The capitalist class still has no answer to the problems of this planet. As 
Marx and Engels stirringly concluded the Manifesto 160 years ago: "The 
proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win." 

The Communist Manifesto remains a revolutionary call to action. 

Kirim email ke