http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/catholicism-should-lower-the-drawbridge-20080623-2vje.html?page=-1
Catholicism should lower the drawbridge
a.. Barney Zwartz
b.. June 24, 2008
Some changes to church doctrines would make it more appealing.
IN LESS than a month, Pope Benedict will celebrate Mass in Sydney before an
expected congregation of 500,000 - the high point of the week-long World Youth
Day celebration that the Catholic Church in Australia hopes will revitalise
church attendance and religious commitment.
Secular critics fear that - helped by an ever-rising injection of Government
funds, so far about $130 million - it may. Many Catholics are sceptical. Yes,
there will be a media-fuelled surge of interest. Devout young Catholics will
find their faith affirmed, and some less-committed will be reached. But many
young people will attend in the same spirit as a concert - an interesting
event, but not life-changing.
The church would be wrong to put all its eggs in the World Youth Day basket. As
it enters its third millennium, it needs another bout of self-examination of
the sort it has done sporadically through the centuries.
The issues today are as serious as any in the past: plummeting Mass attendance,
the dramatic decline in priests and religious orders, the advance of
secularism, the challenge of Islam, and especially the alienation of ordinary
Catholics from the institutional church. Disenchantment over such issues as
contraception, the place of women, authoritarianism and the sexual abuse crisis
have left millions still believing in Jesus but not the church.
Now it is time to try a touch of democracy. Some relatively simple reforms
would not affect the church's core teaching of hope and salvation, which are
non-negotiable. But how the church operates as an institution should always be
open to self-examination.
Three books in recent months by leading Australian Catholics - philosopher Max
Charlesworth, former priest and Catholic commentator Paul Collins and former
Sydney bishop Geoffrey Robinson - have suggested such reforms.
They want to curb papal power and the Curia - the Vatican bureaucracy that is
virtually all male, all clerical and unaccountable to the wider church - and to
re-examine certain doctrines, peripheral accretions over time, that could be
readily changed. These include allowing married priests, contraception and
greater involvement by laymen and women.
Charlesworth discusses the conflict between the values liberal democracies take
for granted and the almost totalitarian rule the Vatican seeks over its
adherents. It wasn't always so, he argues, and it needn't be now.
The way the Vatican's doctrinal watchdog, the Congregation for the Doctrine of
Faith, treats dissident theologians - its "Star Chamber methods" - are, he
says, completely at odds with elementary principles of justice. The insistence
that Catholics should obey their bishops before their consciences is another
conflict, since the basis of democratic society is the freedom of the
individual to make judgements of conscience.
Particularly revealing is the church's response to revelations of priestly
sexual abuse and the long institutional cover-up, finally exposed by an
American lay group, Voice of the Faithful, and the media. The fact that the
church still hasn't dealt with it well reflects the hierarchy's discomfort at
being challenged by laypeople.
Despite all this, there is a strong similarity (not coincidental) between
Christian and democratic values, such as equality, freedom, conscience and
human dignity. Politically, these values are protected by the constitution,
universal suffrage and an array of checks and balances. Why shouldn't the
church operate the same way? Why not let laypeople vote for the Pope? They did
for the first 1000 years. And it took centuries for today's authoritarian
structure to emerge out of a variety of local systems.
These suggestions horrify conservative Catholics, because the majority can
easily be wrong. The church's motto is semper eadem ("always the same") because
it is the repository and guardian of religious truth for all time and cannot be
subject to the tides of intellectual fashion.
In fact, of course, the church can and does change - both culturally and
theologically - around the edges while maintaining its central message. For
centuries, the church justified persecution and bad faith on the grounds that
"error has no rights".
But the reforming Vatican II council in the 1960s recognised that "in matters
of religion no one can be forced to act in a manner contrary to his beliefs" -
a massive U-turn that the church presented as a "development". It took 1000
years for celibacy to become a requirement for priests (even then for purely
practical reasons), while papal infallibility has been a formal doctrine for
only 138 years.
In all its "developments", the church has rightly been responding to its
environment. Today it has come to terms with its diminished role in a
pluralistic West, and explicitly accepts that other religions contain truth.
Given the often-justified criticism of the institutional church, it's easy to
forget that it has been an enormous force for good: tending people, promoting
justice, providing education, offering compassion, consolation and hope. It
will keep doing it - but how much more successfully if it can lower the last
drawbridges and emerge from behind the battlements.
Barney Zwartz is religion editor.
Larissa Dubecki is on leave. Her column will return later this year.