As someone with a thyroid condition, I have a personal interest in what
research says about potential goitrogenic effects of millets consumed as
food. This issue has only come up a couple of times on Collab,/1/2 and
generally is not a wide concern outside of particular thyroid conditions or
dietary insufficiency, but it is useful to be aware of our state of
knowledge on the subject. So, here are two very recent items, followed by a
few personal observations:

1.
"Millets for Thyroid: Safe Choices, What to Avoid (2026)"
https://www.orggu.com/blog/millets-for-thyroid

This is a "guide" to millets from the point of view of thyroid health,
produced by an Indian company, Orggu, which mentions as sources National
Institute of Nutrition (NIN,  Hyderabad,   India), Indian Council of
Medical Research (ICMR), and USDA FoodData Central. It meritsmention for
its treatment of millets individually and for distinguishing between the
two main and opposite types of thyroid conditions (over vs under production
of thyroid hormones). However, it does not mention fonio or teff (not to
surprising, given that Orggu operates only in India), nor does it mention
proso millet (which is surprising, given that it is grown and consumed in
India). Overall, its discussion is more detailed and nuanced than most
other similar webpages I have seen. This is not to recommend it
unconditionally, which I'm not qualified to do anyway. but if you're
unfamiliar with this issue, it seems like a useful starting point.

Millets covered: sorghum; pearl millet; finger millet; foxtail millet;
little millet; kodo millet; barnyard millet (species not indicated); and
browntop millet.

2.
Onipe, O. O., Udeh, H. O., & Gwata, E. T. (2026). "Goitrogens in millets:
occurrence, impact on product development and mitigation strategies."
International Journal of Food Properties, 29(1).
https://doi.org/10.1080/10942912.2026.2629050

This review article covers:  sorghum; pearl millet; finger millet; foxtail
millet; proso millet; little millet; kodo millet; barnyard millet
(Echinochloa crus-galli and E. colona are mentioned, rather than E.
esculenta and E. frumentaea); and fonio.

ABSTRACT: "Goiter is a health disorder characterized by an enlarged thyroid
gland, and it has been associated with iodine deficiency, which can be
exacerbated by the ingestion of substances that impair iodine uptake
(goitrogens). Millets have been associated with thyroid dysfunctions due to
presence of goitrogens. Pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum), finger millet
(Eleusine coracana), and fonio (Digitaria exilis Stapf) contain appreciable
amounts of goitrogens, thiocyanates and flavonoids, that can obstruct
iodine metabolism in the thyroid. The concentration of thiocyanate and
C-glycosyl flavones in finger millet ranged from 31 to 43 mg/kg, and from
15 to 541 and up to 350 mg/kg in pearl millet and fonio contain,
respectively. This review consolidates growing knowledge about the
occurrence, metabolic pathways, and dietary consequences of goitrogens in
millets. The biochemical routes through which goitrogens inhibit the
thyroid hormone peroxidase are discussed. The interplay of environmental
and varietal and agricultural methods on the goitrogenic profile of minor
millets is also clarified. The influence of processing on the breakdown of
goitrogens is also discussed. The review findings indicate that employing a
dual approach, heat and mechanical processing, reduces goitrogenicity in
millets; nevertheless, in certain instances, such as fermentation and
sprouting were found to have variable effect, with several studies
indicating either stable or increased goitrogen levels. The study shows
that cooking or boiling and decortication are the most effective methods to
reduce goitrogens in millets."

I found it a useful discussion that touched on many points. If you first
looked at the webpage linked above (#1), this article gives more depth and
explanation. If I were to make one editorial suggestion, it would be to be
clearer on the set of milllets discussed at various points. For example the
abstract mentions fonio but not sorghum, but a later list has the latter
but not the former, even though similar issues were raised for both. And
there was one discussion under "Boiling" of red and brown millet varieties,
but it wasn't clear whether one millet or a common feature of several were
described. Also, the brief discussion of the effect of soaking, which
appears under the subheading of "Germination" might have its own
subheading, or alternatively the subheading could include both words, to
facilitate findng, since soaking is a separate practice used for many
grains. Altogether, it is worth reading if you want more background on this
topic.

Some comments:
* In general, it seems that the major millets - sorghum, pearl millet, and
sometimes finger millet/3 - have higher content of goitrogenic compounds
* The minor or small millets - those with hard husks or shells - seem to
have less goitrogenic compounds.
* Fonio, however, seems to have higher levels
* Proso is not given any attention in #1, and is mentioned only once
without discussion of its goitrogenic content in #2. One other site
compares it to other minor millets in this regard:
https://milletmatters.com/blogs/blogs/which-millet-is-good-for-thyroid-a-complete-guide-to-choosing-the-right-millets-for-better-thyroid-health
* Teff, as indicated above, and for that matter adlay on the other end of
the size spectrum
* Goitrogens are present in a range of foods, including some vegetables
commonly sold and consumed in North America
* Goitrogens are part of a larger category of what are called
antinutrients, which also includes phytates (phytic acid), which are a
different compoud found in whole grains (this woud be a separate discussion)
* It might be helpful to have a NAMA explainer on this topic for a broad
audience that improves on those discussed above (for instance bringing
proso into it) - unless there's already one that we could point to
* None of this is intended to raise unwarrented concerns about consumption
of millets, which overall have many health and nutritional advantages.
Fwiw, I consume a range of millets as part of a diverse diet, but have not
experienced any adverse issues despite my thyroid issue..


Don Osborn, PhD
(East Lansing, MI, US)
North American Millets Alliance

Notes:
1. "Supposed downsides of millets as food" 29 May 2023
https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/message/7XZDL3TDCYTBDLKBGBHOWVVQGGBLOXNP/
2. "Goitrogen issue again - pearl millet & fonio," 30 Aug 2024
https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/message/7IZSMZ7DQPLDDKSQ7HBMWHLAMFVBFVA2/
3. The topic of the major/minor (small) millets and the place of finger
millet is one for another time.


-- 
Collab mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to