USDA publications on crops and other plants are standard references in the
US and also used internationally.Here's a brief consideration of the USDA
profile of our millet of the month in September, browntop or brown top
millet:
Sheahan, C.M. 2014. "Plant guide for browntop millet (Urochloa ramosa)."
USDA-Natural Resources Conservation Service, Cape May Plant Materials
Center, Cape May, NJ.
https://plants.sc.egov.usda.gov/DocumentLibrary/plantguide/pdf/pg_urra.pdf

Three years ago, I included a link to it in a Collab post about browntop
millet (and its cousin, Guinea millet)./1 Here I'd like to look at a few
details that might merit review for updating. I should hasten to add, that
by focusing on details, this is not meant to lessen the overall utility of
the plant guide - just to offer items for attention in any revision.

* Two different panicle forms: Under Description > General, this plant
guide does not mention that browntop has two panicle forms - one open, and
the other compact. See, for instance, Nandini, et al 2026 (which includes a
side-by-side image) cited in my recent post on Collab./2 See also an
article mentioning Karnataka, India farmers' observation that the
open-panicle or "branched" variety has less insect problems, and the
compact-panicle or "ball" variety has higher seed/grain production./3 The
panicle form would seem to be of particular interest for developing
varieties for food. My impression is that in general, browntop varieties in
the US are open-panicle varieties. (Panicle forms may vary in any millet,
but is this a distinct varietal difference in browntop? Cf. in sorghum,
Guinea type [open, often drooping] and Cautatum type [semi-compact and
upright].)

* Introduction to the US: Under Description > Distribution, the document
cites a 1990 source stating that it was introduced to the US in 1915.
Without suggesting that this is incorrect, I would note that I tried
without success to find a primary source confirming the date. Separate
searches turned up three mentions in newspapers in the US Southeast in
1918-1920 that did not give any background. One later source (1956) quotes
a crop specialist as saying that it was already being grown in Georgia in
1916. The 1915 date seems realistic, if one accepts the possibility of
quick dissemination. I'm still working on compiling the sparse information
on this and hope to share it later.

* Shade tolerance?: Under Description > Habitat, it is stated that browntp
grows best "... under full sun." This is unsurprising, being a common
characteristic of millets. However, there is evidence that it can also be
grown in association with trees (agroforestry) and might be shade
tolerant./4 The article mentions growing browntop under tamarind trees,
which from personal observation have a somewhat diffuse shade./5 How well
this association of browntop and trees actually works for grain or forage
production would be an interesting research topic.

* Waterlogging: Under Adaptation, it might state browntop's preference with
regard to too much water. Most descriptions not that it doesn't like wet
feet (unlike sorghum or the barnyard millets) but at least one source
suggests the opposite./4

* Use for food: The document mentions use of browntop as food not under
Uses but only under Ethnobotany. An update should mention that it is now a
minor commercial crop, packaged for sale in India and also exported.

* One final item: In mentioning several other millets under Adaptation,
this document equates "Japanese millet" with Echinochloa frumentacea, while
other sources prefer E. esculenta./6 This is a separate and longer
discussion, but noting here just that most sources discuss E. esculenta and
E. frumentatia - the "barnyard millets" - as two separate species with
origins likely in Japan and India, respectively.


Don Osborn, PhD
(East Lansing, MI, US)
North American Millets Alliance

Notes:
1. "September millet(s)-of-the-month: Browntop & Guinea," 30 Sept. 2023
https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/message/OGA6KKNUV2LJ5XHXXZ6QEFFV6TWT4KXB/
2. "3 recent review articles on browntop millet," 21 Sept. 2026
https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/thread/DYQUXTAH2T22AGV4KLXNMCWHF4SJBIKB/
3. Sujata B, Prabhu C G, Nandini C, Prabhakar, Thippeswamy V. "Browntop
Millet- A Review". Agricultural Research & Technology: Open Access Journal.
2018; 14(5): 555937. DOI: 10.19080/ARTOAJ.2018.14.555937
https://juniperpublishers.com/artoaj/pdf/ARTOAJ.MS.ID.555937.pdf
4. "Return of the forgotten crop – Brown top millet," by Anitha Reddy and
Krishna Prasad G, Leis India, n.d. (earliest capture on Archive.org, 3 Dec.
2020)
https://www.leisaindia.org/return-of-the-forgotten-crop-brown-top-millet/ .
I previously shared this link on Collab 2 years ago:
https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/message/EKBZIVNXFAHCBKINKXQGL2T7Q6F4M2E3/
5. Tamarind trees are common in the Sahel, where I have worked. I did some
limited propagation of this species from seed in Mali.
6. For example: Sheahan, C.M. 2014. "Plant guide for Japanese millet
(Echinochloa esculenta)." USDA-Natural Resources Conservation Service, Cape
May Plant Materials Center, Cape May, NJ.


-- 
Collab mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to