GitHub user potiuk edited a comment on the discussion: What motivated the 
decision to make grid and graph view, mutually exclusive, on the bump to 
Airflow 3?

Sorry for being also a little harsh - but yeah - if you do want to help, thehn 
please by all means, but I think what helps there is to explain what you want 
to achieve.

Generally speaking "bring back old experience" is never a good idea. Usually it 
means that yes - you have some muscle memory and you would really want to get 
it the way it was, but this is like that with **any** change. You need to 
adapt. But if you have a good reason why you would like some change, then 
**ideally** do not put the burden on those who already spend time in the past 
explaining the decisions in the past PRs, disucussions and issues, to find 
those issues and PRs for you. Dig deeper and find it - or ideally explain what 
you really want to achieve and WHY you want it changed. What behaviour it 
enables? How current solution makes it difficult and what you think exactly 
(other than "bring old UI back") makes it easier.

Often when doing it, you will find that in-fact what you want to do is easier 
to do (that was one of the general design decisions of the new UI to make  a 
number of typical use cases easier, faster, and more "natural". Or when you 
explain what you really want we will find out that indeed, we could improve the 
flow. 

But almost neve "make it customizable in the way to bring the old behaviour" is 
a good solution. Usuallly it means that things get more complex, messy and you 
get less chance to learn new, better ways of doing things. 

So .... Please, by all means help us to improve the new UI. But please never, 
ever do it by "bring the new UI back" and "spend even more time explaining ME 
the UI decisions when all of that has been explained over and over again in 
past discussions.

If you want to help - spend your time on explaining what you want to do and how 
you think it can be improved - not by "going back" but by looking forward on 
how we can improve things without complicating things.

GitHub link: 
https://github.com/apache/airflow/discussions/50492#discussioncomment-13536085

----
This is an automatically sent email for [email protected].
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: [email protected]

Reply via email to