commits  

Messages by Date

• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] Activate unit test [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1665] Override verboseStringWithOperatorId in NativeFileSourceScanBase [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 [I] Publish nightly base docker images [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.3.1 deleted (was b8b3f709) github-bot
• 2025/11/27 (auron) branch master updated: Bump bytesize from 2.3.0 to 2.3.1 (#1669) csy
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.3.0 to 2.3.1 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1639] Avoid ByteBuddyAgent inject when class not found [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [I] Build datafusion-ext-commons failed: `#![feature]` may not be used on the stable release channel [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [I] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats (#1657) richox
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert BroadcastExchange to native does not take effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert ShuffleExchange to native does not take effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/27 Re: [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [PR] [AURON #1668] Remove the usage of BASH associative array [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [I] Build datafusion-ext-commons failed: `#![feature]` may not be used on the stable release channel [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Build hangs on updating git repository: arrow-rs.git [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Build hangs on updating git repository: arrow-rs.git [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [I] Build hangs on updating git repository: arrow-rs.git [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.3.1 created (now b8b3f709) github-bot
• 2025/11/26 [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.3.0 to 2.3.1 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Build failed on macOS: spark.version: syntax error: invalid arithmetic operator [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [I] Build failed on macOS: spark.version: syntax error: invalid arithmetic operator [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Support Iceberg [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert ShuffleExchange to native does not take effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [PR] [AURON #1665] Override verboseStringWithOperatorId in NativeFilterBase [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [PR] [AURON #1665] Override verboseStringWithOperatorId in NativeProjectBase [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Align NativeFileSourceScan plan explain output with vanilla spark [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Align NativeFileSourceScan plan explain output with vanilla spark [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 [I] Improve verbose string output for all Native*Exec operators to match Spark explain format [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [I] Remove ubuntu-22.04-arm runner [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 Re: [PR] [AURON #1659] Remove ubuntu-22.04-arm runner [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/26 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1659] Remove ubuntu-22.04-arm runner (#1660) csy
• 2025/11/25 Re: [PR] [AURON #1642] Align NativeFileSourceScanBase.verboseStringWithOperatorId with vanilla Spark [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/25 Re: [PR] [AURON #1637] Enforce Clippy lint and Eliminate unwrap [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1637] Enforce Clippy lint and replace unwrap with expect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1663] Fix: NativeEmptyExec should fallback on unsupported types (#1664) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] NativeEmptyExec should fallback on unsupported types [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1663] Fix: NativeEmptyExec should fallback on unsupported types [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1636] Bump orc-rust 0.7.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] ORC Out of spec, message: over/underflow when decoding patched base integer [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: bump orc-rust 0.7.0 (#1661) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Incorrect conversion of FileScanConfig in from_proto.rs [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: Fix incorrect FileScanConfig.projection conversion (#1591) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1537] Fix incorrect FileScanConfig.projection conversion [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1644] Fix build-native.sh ensure native lib cache takes effect (#1645) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Native lib cache never takes effect by default [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1644] Fix build-native.sh ensure native lib cache takes effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1654] Add AuronQueryTest base class for SQL testing (#1655) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1654] Add AuronQueryTest base class for SQL testing [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Add AuronQueryTest: compare results with vanilla Spark and check native operators [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1637] Enforce Clippy lint and replace unwrap with expect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1652] Fix: add Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1652] Fix: add Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions (#1653) richox
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Missing Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1654] Add AuronQueryTest base class for SQL testing [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 [PR] [AURON #1663] Fix: NativeEmptyExec should fallback on unsupported types [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 [I] NativeEmptyExec should fallback on unsupported types [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Adding Auron to ClickBench [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [I] Adding Auron to ClickBench [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 Re: [PR] [AURON #1595] Enforce skiptest=false to not miss failing UT [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/24 [PR] Add tpch suite [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [PR] [AURON #1636] Bump orc-rust 0.7.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1639] Avoid ByteBuddyAgent inject when class not found [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1639] Avoid ByteBuddyAgent inject when class not found [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [PR] [AURON #1659] Remove ubuntu-22.04-arm runner [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [I] Remove ubuntu-22.04-arm runner [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [I] Add TPC-H test suite [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [I] Add AuronQueryTest: compare results with vanilla Spark and check native operators [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 Re: [PR] [AURON #1652] Fix: add Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [PR] [AURON #1656] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [I] Support to disable the scan timestamp for Parquet and ORC formats [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [PR] [AURON #1654] Add AuronQueryTest base class for SQL testing [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/23 [I] Add AuronQueryTest: compare results with vanilla Spark and check native operators [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 [PR] [AURON #1652] Fix: add Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 [I] Missing Spark_ prefix for Hashing Functions in Auron ext functions [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] UT cannot be skipped in auron-core module when build [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] Enable the parquet_page_filtering_enabled but slow down the TPC-DS queries [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] Support BatchScanExec to native [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] Enable the parquet_page_filtering_enabled but slow down the TPC-DS queries [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] Support BatchScanExec to native [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/smallvec-2.0.0-alpha.12 updated (a800a4fc -> 813d12ce) github-bot
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] `NativeConvertersSuite` cast string trim-disable tests failed [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] [AURON #1617] Fix NativeConvertersSuite cast trim-disable test failures [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1617] Fix NativeConvertersSuite cast trim-disable test failures (#1618) richox
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] Bump smallvec from 2.0.0-alpha.11 to 2.0.0-alpha.12 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1579] Fix and strengthen nvl2 unit test (previous test was fundamentally wrong) (#1635) richox
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] [AURON #1579] Fix and enhance nvl2 unit test [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/lz4_flex-0.12.0 deleted (was c360e2bc) github-bot
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] Bump lz4_flex from 0.11.5 to 0.12.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch master updated: Bump lz4_flex from 0.11.5 to 0.12.0 (#1623) richox
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.3.0 deleted (was 24218ae6) github-bot
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.2.0 to 2.3.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch master updated: Bump bytesize from 2.2.0 to 2.3.0 (#1648) richox
• 2025/11/22 Re: [I] Fix Node Name Difference in NativeEmptyExec for JDK 8 and JDK 21 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/22 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1650] Override nodeName for NativeEmptyExec (#1651) richox
• 2025/11/22 Re: [PR] [AURON #1650] Override nodeName for NativeEmptyExec [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [I] When there are more than one filter conditions, triggering bloomFilter will cause the task to fail [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [I] Support HiveTableScanExec to native [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [I] Support HiveTableScanExec to native [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [PR] [AURON #1595] Enforce skiptest=false to not miss failing UT [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [PR] [AURON #1595] Enforce skiptest=false to not miss failing UT [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 [PR] [AURON #1650] Override nodeName for NativeEmptyExec [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 [I] Fix Node Name Difference in NativeEmptyExec for JDK 8 and JDK 21 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 [PR] [AURON #1637] Enforce Clippy lint and replace unwrap with expect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [PR] [AURON #1637] Enforce Clippy lint and replace unwrap with expect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/21 Re: [I] Introduce #![deny(clippy::unwrap_used)] [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.3.0 created (now 24218ae6) github-bot
• 2025/11/20 [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.2.0 to 2.3.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 Re: [I] Module spark-extension-shims-spark3 included comile scope test-jar dependencies [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [PR] [AURON #1646] isNaN currently uses math::isnan which propagates nulls and can mismatch Spark semantics [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 Re: [PR] [AURON #1595] Enforce skiptest=false to not miss failing UT [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [I] isNaN currently uses math::isnan which propagates nulls and can mismatch Spark semantics [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [PR] [AURON #1644] Fix build-native.sh ensure native lib cache takes effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [I] Native lib cache never takes effect by default [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 Re: [PR] [AURON #1579] Fix and enhance nvl2 unit test [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [PR] [AURON #1642] Align NativeFileSourceScanBase.verboseStringWithOperatorId with vanilla Spark [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [I] Align NativeFileSourceScan plan explain output with vanilla spark [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 Re: [I] Make tpcds-validator fail CI when query result checks fail [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/20 [I] Make tpcds-validator fail CI when query result checks fail [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 [PR] [AURON #1639] Avoid ByteBuddyAgent inject when class not found [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 [I] Avoid ByteBuddyAgent inject when class not found [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 [I] ORC Overflow while decoding timestamp (seconds=-62135798400, nanoseconds=0) to Nanosecond [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 Re: [I] Support for Spark 4.0.1 Compatibility in Auron [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 Re: [I] Support for Spark 4.0.1 Compatibility in Auron [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 Re: [I] Safely clean target-docker build directories without deleting cache [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 [I] Introduce #![deny(clippy::unwrap_used)] [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 [I] ORC Out of spec, message: over/underflow when decoding patched base integer [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/19 Re: [I] NullPointerException in ArrowFFIExporter.<init> – Likely Caused by Apache Arrow Version Conflict [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 [PR] [AURON #1579] Fix and enhance nvl2 unit test [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/lz4_flex-0.12.0 updated (cd807a3e -> c360e2bc) github-bot
• 2025/11/18 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider (#1620) richox
• 2025/11/18 Re: [I] NoClassDefFoundError: Could not initialize class org.apache.spark.sql.auron.NativeConverters$ during NativeShuffleExchange in Spark task [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 Re: [PR] [AURON #1631] Updates the labeler workflow to cover the newly added modules in the Auron project [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1631] Updates the labeler workflow to cover the newly added modules in the Auron project (#1632) richox
• 2025/11/18 Re: [I] Updates the labeler workflow to cover the newly added modules in the Auron project [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 Re: [PR] Bump lz4_flex from 0.11.5 to 0.12.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/18 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytes-1.11.0 deleted (was d49cd223) github-bot
• 2025/11/18 (auron) branch master updated: Bump bytes from 1.10.1 to 1.11.0 (#1634) richox
• 2025/11/18 Re: [PR] Bump bytes from 1.10.1 to 1.11.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/17 [PR] Bump bytes from 1.10.1 to 1.11.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/17 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytes-1.11.0 created (now d49cd223) github-bot
• 2025/11/17 [PR] Bump smallvec from 2.0.0-alpha.11 to 2.0.0-alpha.12 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/17 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/smallvec-2.0.0-alpha.12 created (now a800a4fc) github-bot
• 2025/11/17 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 [PR] [AURON #1631] Updates the labeler workflow to cover the newly added modules in the Auron project [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 [I] Updates the labeler workflow to cover the newly added modules in the Auron project [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 Re: [PR] [AURON #1629] Fix out-of-date module name in labeler.yml [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 Re: [PR] [AURON #1629] Fix out-of-date module name in labeler.yml [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1629] Fix out-of-date module name in labeler.yml #1629 maruilei
• 2025/11/16 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1612] Filter out empty build-info values to improve Spark UI display (#1615) maruilei
• 2025/11/16 Re: [PR] [AURON #1612] Filter out empty build-info values to improve Spark UI display [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/16 [I] Tokio thread spawn failure in auron native path: “OS can't spawn worker thread: Resource temporarily unavailable (os error 11)” [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/15 [PR] Fix out-of-date module name in labeler.yml [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 Re: [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert ShuffleExchange to native does not take effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert ShuffleExchange to native does not tabke effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 [PR] [AURON #1625] Fix disable convert BroadcastExchange does not tabke effect [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 Re: [I] Bug with Two-Phase Agggregate using vanilla spark sort shuffle manager [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 (auron) branch master updated: make MD5 output back to utf8 (#1605) richox
• 2025/11/13 Re: [I] MD5 function with utf8view output is not supported as a hash input [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 Re: [PR] [AURON #1604] Make MD5 output back to utf8 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 (auron) branch master updated: Bump bytesize from 2.1.0 to 2.2.0 (#1619) richox
• 2025/11/13 Re: [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.1.0 to 2.2.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/13 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.2.0 deleted (was b423f5db) github-bot
• 2025/11/13 Re: [I] Bug with Two-Phase Agggregate using vanilla spark sort shuffle manager [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 (auron) branch master updated: [AURON #1621] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption (#1622) richox
• 2025/11/12 Re: [PR] [AURON #1621] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 Re: [I] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 Re: [I] Proposal: split auron-core module [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 Re: [I] Proposal: split auron-core module [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 Re: [I] Auron Spark UI casing does not match the rest of the UI [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 Re: [I] Auron Spark UI casing does not match the rest of the UI [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 [I] Bug with Two-Phase Agggregate using spark vanilla sort shuffle manager [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/12 [I] Failed Unit Tests: AuronCheckConvertShuffleExchangeSuite & AuronCheckConvertBroadcastExchangeSuite [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 [I] Support ORC RowSelection [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1621] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1621] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/lz4_flex-0.12.0 created (now cd807a3e) github-bot
• 2025/11/11 [PR] Bump lz4_flex from 0.11.5 to 0.12.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 [PR] [AURON #1621] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1604] Make MD5 output back to utf8 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 [I] Introduces dynamic default value for ConfigOption [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/11 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 Re: [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 [PR] [AURON #1602] Implement AuronAdaptor SPI discovery with Spark provider [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 (auron) branch dependabot/cargo/master/bytesize-2.2.0 created (now b423f5db) github-bot
• 2025/11/10 [PR] Bump bytesize from 2.1.0 to 2.2.0 [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 Re: [I] NoClassDefFoundError: Could not initialize class org.apache.spark.sql.auron.NativeConverters$ during NativeShuffleExchange in Spark task [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 [PR] [AURON #1617] Fix NativeConvertersSuite cast trim-disable test failures [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 [I] `NativeConvertersSuite` cast string trim-disable tests failed [auron] via GitHub
• 2025/11/10 (auron) branch CalvinKirs-patch-1 deleted (was 9a08a185) kirs

• Earlier messages
• Later messages