Croway opened a new issue, #133:
URL: https://github.com/apache/camel-upgrade-recipes/issues/133
`.github/workflows/comment-pr.yml` (triggered via `workflow_run` when
`receive-pr` completes,
to post the OpenRewrite patch as a PR comment) has failed with
`startup_failure` on every
single run since at least 2026-08-25, with zero jobs ever created:
```
$ gh run list --workflow=comment-pr.yml --limit 10
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 34974276122 0s
2026-09-15T13:19:36Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 34973597155 0s
2026-09-15T13:13:11Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 34967476361 0s
2026-09-15T12:11:59Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 34964978102 0s
2026-09-15T11:45:08Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 34598633934 0s
2026-09-11T12:23:04Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 32848753617 0s
2026-08-25T12:38:58Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 32844934883 0s
2026-08-25T11:56:51Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 32841737321 0s
2026-08-25T11:19:42Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 32839424480 0s
2026-08-25T10:52:44Z
completed startup_failure comment-pr main workflow_run 32836579991 0s
2026-08-25T10:18:51Z
```
`gh api repos/apache/camel-upgrade-recipes/actions/runs/34974276122/jobs`
returns
`{"total_count":0,"jobs":[]}` -- the run fails before any job is even
scheduled, which is the
usual signature of a workflow being rejected because it requests more
`GITHUB_TOKEN`
permission than the repository's default workflow permissions allow.
The `post-suggestions` job in `comment-pr.yml` declares:
```yaml
permissions:
pull-requests: write
```
If the repo/org's default `GITHUB_TOKEN` permissions are read-only (common
under ASF INFRA
policy) and this workflow isn't allow-listed for the elevated scope, every
run would fail
exactly like this. That's a hypothesis based on the symptom, not a confirmed
root cause --
someone with access to the repository's Settings → Actions → General →
"Workflow permissions"
page would need to check.
Net effect: PR review-comment automation (the OpenRewrite-suggested-diff
comment) has not
actually been posting to any PR for at least three weeks.
_Claude Code on behalf of croway_
--
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]
