RodrigoDLopez commented on pull request #4140: URL: https://github.com/apache/cloudstack/pull/4140#issuecomment-643358376
@davidjumani I tested this enhancement with Cloudmonkey and used JQ to parse the output. My Environment have 2 Zones and some fake templates named T<int> copied into both zones * Test 01 ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List all my templates without duplicate entries. **Result:** the output brought all templates duplicates too ``` name: T1 id: 422b3235-ad7f-49fa-93ec-2c2df9140569 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T2 id: 6d224f3a-057e-4be3-bf27-ea911a77b87d zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T6 id: 07994afd-ec0d-4098-ba86-c5ae1a4198df zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T7 id: 09face5a-f496-47cf-a367-1e872bb1c659 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T8 id: f6e92bc2-5dbd-4c9a-bba6-1ec4f1402667 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T9 id: c79b03a0-c9c8-431a-a4a4-a11164ea2f09 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T10 id: c3c8e05c-f8b9-44f7-91c8-b9679de95b30 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T11 id: bd552d64-7354-4e51-9c57-b7991f5d3a95 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T12 id: b21ffae9-cf69-4c3e-b204-3ea9202a662a zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T6 id: 07994afd-ec0d-4098-ba86-c5ae1a4198df zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T7 id: 09face5a-f496-47cf-a367-1e872bb1c659 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T8 id: f6e92bc2-5dbd-4c9a-bba6-1ec4f1402667 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T9 id: c79b03a0-c9c8-431a-a4a4-a11164ea2f09 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T10 id: c3c8e05c-f8b9-44f7-91c8-b9679de95b30 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T11 id: bd552d64-7354-4e51-9c57-b7991f5d3a95 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T12 id: b21ffae9-cf69-4c3e-b204-3ea9202a662a zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a ``` * Test 02 ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ pagesize=5 \ page=1 \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List only 5 templates **Result:** All good, as expected ``` name: T1 id: 422b3235-ad7f-49fa-93ec-2c2df9140569 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T2 id: 6d224f3a-057e-4be3-bf27-ea911a77b87d zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a ``` * Test 03 ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ pagesize=7 \ page=1 \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List only 7 templates **Result:** All good, as expected ``` name: T1 id: 422b3235-ad7f-49fa-93ec-2c2df9140569 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T2 id: 6d224f3a-057e-4be3-bf27-ea911a77b87d zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T6 id: 07994afd-ec0d-4098-ba86-c5ae1a4198df zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T7 id: 09face5a-f496-47cf-a367-1e872bb1c659 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a ``` * Test 04 ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ pagesize=9 \ page=1 \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List only 9 templates **Result:** the output brought 16 templates and some duplicate entries ``` name: T1 id: 422b3235-ad7f-49fa-93ec-2c2df9140569 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T2 id: 6d224f3a-057e-4be3-bf27-ea911a77b87d zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T6 id: 07994afd-ec0d-4098-ba86-c5ae1a4198df zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T7 id: 09face5a-f496-47cf-a367-1e872bb1c659 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T8 id: f6e92bc2-5dbd-4c9a-bba6-1ec4f1402667 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T9 id: c79b03a0-c9c8-431a-a4a4-a11164ea2f09 zoneid: bfa05e73-7948-419f-a47d-29b498bf3ef9 name: T3 id: f302a9f9-50e6-4990-a746-3185be9fa6fb zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T4 id: a10d6bb8-dea5-45a9-8e45-4fec5456c885 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T5 id: 584317d2-009e-46eb-a5b0-ef005231bd14 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T6 id: 07994afd-ec0d-4098-ba86-c5ae1a4198df zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T7 id: 09face5a-f496-47cf-a367-1e872bb1c659 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T8 id: f6e92bc2-5dbd-4c9a-bba6-1ec4f1402667 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T9 id: c79b03a0-c9c8-431a-a4a4-a11164ea2f09 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a ``` Whithout `showunique` parameter, I receive duplicate entries as well, but the `pagesize` was respected * Test 05 ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ pagesize=10 \ page=1 \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List only 10 templates **Result:** As the test 04, I received duplicate entries, and the `pagesize` was not respected. But the second page seems to be okay. ``` cloudmonkey -p acs listtemplates \ templatefilter=self \ pagesize=10 \ page=2 \ showunique=true \ | jq -r '.template[] | "name:\t\(.name)\tid: \(.id)\tzoneid: \(.zoneid)"' ``` **Expected result:** List the remaining templates, without duplicates. **Result:** all good, bring the remaining templates, without duplicate entries ``` name: T11 id: bd552d64-7354-4e51-9c57-b7991f5d3a95 zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a name: T12 id: b21ffae9-cf69-4c3e-b204-3ea9202a662a zoneid: 8e4d0af1-fd82-4a25-bf90-e0adfb0a4e8a ``` ---------------------------------------------------------------- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: us...@infra.apache.org
