Aman-Mittal commented on PR #5096: URL: https://github.com/apache/fineract/pull/5096#issuecomment-3407166348
Sharing AI code review for report based on ticket and code changes. **NOTE: These are for reference only so it can be dismissed** <html> <body> <!--StartFragment--><h2 data-start="200" data-end="258">⚠️ Code Review Summary: DTO and Request Inconsistencies</h2> <h3 data-start="260" data-end="323">1. Inconsistent Field Names Between Request and DTO Classes</h3> <p data-start="324" data-end="340"><strong data-start="324" data-end="340">Observation:</strong></p> <ul data-start="341" data-end="598"> <li data-start="341" data-end="598"> <p data-start="343" data-end="418">Request payloads use different field names than their corresponding DTOs.</p> <ul data-start="421" data-end="598"> <li data-start="421" data-end="519"> <p data-start="423" data-end="519"><strong data-start="423" data-end="457"><code data-start="425" data-end="455">bulkDisbursementTransactions</code></strong> includes: <code data-start="468" data-end="480">externalId</code>, <code data-start="482" data-end="497">receiptNumber</code>, <code data-start="499" data-end="511">bankNumber</code>, etc.</p> </li> <li data-start="522" data-end="598"> <p data-start="524" data-end="598"><strong data-start="524" data-end="556"><code data-start="526" data-end="554">bulkSavingsDueTransactions</code></strong> includes: <code data-start="567" data-end="578">savingsId</code>, <code data-start="580" data-end="592">externalId</code>, etc.</p> </li> </ul> </li> </ul> <p data-start="600" data-end="617"><strong data-start="600" data-end="617">Code Changes:</strong></p> <ul data-start="618" data-end="774"> <li data-start="618" data-end="774"> <p data-start="620" data-end="774"><code data-start="620" data-end="653">DisbursementTransactionsRequest</code> and <code data-start="658" data-end="687">SavingDueTransactionRequest</code> DTOs were updated with fields like <code data-start="723" data-end="731">loanId</code>, <code data-start="733" data-end="752">transactionAmount</code>, and <code data-start="758" data-end="773">paymentTypeId</code>.</p> </li> </ul> <p data-start="776" data-end="789"><strong data-start="776" data-end="789">Red Flag:</strong></p> <ul data-start="790" data-end="1071"> <li data-start="790" data-end="1071"> <p data-start="792" data-end="1071"><code data-start="792" data-end="820">bulkSavingsDueTransactions</code> request contains <code data-start="838" data-end="849">savingsId</code>, but the <code data-start="859" data-end="888">SavingDueTransactionRequest</code> DTO <strong data-start="893" data-end="905">does not</strong> define <code data-start="913" data-end="924">savingsId</code>.<br data-start="925" data-end="928"> → This will cause the <code data-start="952" data-end="963">savingsId</code> field to be <strong data-start="976" data-end="987">ignored</strong> during deserialization or trigger a <strong data-start="1024" data-end="1041">binding error</strong> if strict mapping is enabled.</p> </li> </ul> <hr data-start="1073" data-end="1076"> <h3 data-start="1078" data-end="1124">2. Missing Fields in DTOs Used by Requests</h3> <p data-start="1125" data-end="1141"><strong data-start="1125" data-end="1141">Observation:</strong></p> <ul data-start="1142" data-end="1215"> <li data-start="1142" data-end="1215"> <p data-start="1144" data-end="1215">Several request fields are not represented in their corresponding DTOs.</p> </li> </ul> <div class="_tableContainer_1rjym_1"><div tabindex="-1" class="group _tableWrapper_1rjym_13 flex w-fit flex-col-reverse"> Request Type | Missing Fields in DTO | DTO Name -- | -- | -- bulkRepaymentTransactions | externalId, receiptNumber, bankNumber | RepaymentTransactionRequest bulkSavingsDueTransactions | externalId, receiptNumber, bankNumber, savingsId | SavingDueTransactionRequest </div></div> <!--EndFragment--> </body> </html> -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
