This is an automated email from the ASF dual-hosted git repository. imbajin pushed a commit to branch goal-test in repository https://gitbox.apache.org/repos/asf/hugegraph-ai.git
commit 77917906ffe19d0bc8395cb458d54602cfdb3681 Author: imbajin <[email protected]> AuthorDate: Sun May 31 02:25:19 2026 +0800 docs(quality): finalize quality program report - document deferred refactors and production change evidence - summarize test matrix, coverage ratchets, and remaining risks - provide maintainer-ready final quality report --- .../checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md | 48 +++++++++ .workflow/quality-program/quality-state.json | 18 +++- .../quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md | 64 ++++++++++++ .../reports/final-quality-report.md | 112 +++++++++++++++++++++ .../quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md | 12 +-- .../2026-05-31-hugegraph-ai-quality-program.md | 38 +++---- 6 files changed, 262 insertions(+), 30 deletions(-) diff --git a/.workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md b/.workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..66ba5f91 --- /dev/null +++ b/.workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +# G7 Deferred Refactors and Final Report Checkpoint + +## Status + +Complete. + +## Deferred Boundaries + +Recorded deferred queues for: + +- async/streaming API full-chain refactor +- YAML config migration +- demo UI decomposition +- flow/node/operator boundary redesign +- vector DB backend abstraction cleanup +- broader dependency and config cleanup +- optional MCP/tool-surface integration + +## Production Change Ledger + +Final ledger contains production changes only for G2-G4: + +- client response validation error-surface preservation +- LLM HugeGraph commit endpoint mapping and explicit failure handling +- RAG API LLM config field mapping + +No production code was changed in G5-G7. + +## Final Report + +Created `.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md` with: + +- layer test matrix +- coverage baseline and ratchet summary +- exact final verification commands +- production change evidence +- known risks and skips +- deferred refactor queue +- maintainer review notes + +## Verification + +Final G7 sanity checks: + +- placeholder scan over `.workflow/quality-program` and `docs/quality`: no unresolved placeholder content after removing self-matches from this report +- `git status --short`: only G7 report, state, and plan files pending before commit +- `uv run ruff format --check .`: 342 files already formatted +- `uv run ruff check .`: all checks passed diff --git a/.workflow/quality-program/quality-state.json b/.workflow/quality-program/quality-state.json index e4bf12cb..55b15b35 100644 --- a/.workflow/quality-program/quality-state.json +++ b/.workflow/quality-program/quality-state.json @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ { - "current_goal": "G7", + "current_goal": "complete", "repo_sha_start": "d048bc9fa07042833549dd1def5ff3222c47be70", "base_branch": "main", "open_pr_snapshot_time": "2026-05-30T17:18:30Z", @@ -11,7 +11,8 @@ "G3", "G4", "G5", - "G6" + "G6", + "G7" ], "files_touched": [ ".workflow/quality-program/README.md", @@ -88,7 +89,10 @@ "hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration/test_core_text2gremlin_smoke.py", "docs/quality/coverage-ratchet.md", ".workflow/quality-program/coverage/combined-baseline.json", - ".workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/07-coverage-ratchet.md" + ".workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/07-coverage-ratchet.md", + ".workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md", + ".workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md", + ".workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md" ], "production_changes": [ { @@ -204,7 +208,11 @@ "uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m \"unit or contract\" -q", "HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests -m \"integration and hugegraph\" -v --tb=short", "HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m \"integration and hugegraph\" -v --tb=short", - "uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration -m \"smoke\" -v --tb=short" + "uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration -m \"smoke\" -v --tb=short", + "placeholder scan over .workflow/quality-program docs/quality", + "git status --short", + "uv run ruff format --check .", + "uv run ruff check ." ], "known_failures": [], "deferred_items": [ @@ -214,5 +222,5 @@ "Avoid #240 vector/property embedding abstraction surface.", "Quarantine client/test fixes overlapping #323/#329/#342 until exact changed files are inspected." ], - "next_recommended_action": "Start G7 deferred refactor queue and final report" + "next_recommended_action": "Quality program complete; review final report and CI workflow split" } diff --git a/.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..63247d32 --- /dev/null +++ b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md @@ -0,0 +1,64 @@ +# Deferred Refactors + +## Async/Streaming API Full-Chain Refactor + +- blocked_by: `#179` or successor PR status +- affected modules: `hugegraph-llm/src/hugegraph_llm/api/`, flows, nodes, streaming response paths +- why deferred: broad async contract collision and explicitly outside the quality-program scope +- prerequisite tests: parser/API contract tests, core smoke tests, selected streaming boundary tests +- trigger condition: upstream async/streaming PR merged, closed, or superseded with a stable API contract +- suggested future goal: async/streaming boundary and smoke gate + +## YAML Config Migration + +- blocked_by: `#350`, `#277`, or successor config migration work +- affected modules: config loading, generated config defaults, API config endpoints, tests that assume current config layout +- why deferred: migration would replace configuration contracts instead of testing current behavior +- prerequisite tests: current config unit contracts, API config endpoint tests, compatibility tests for old and new config shapes +- trigger condition: maintainers choose the migration direction and settle replacement/deprecation behavior +- suggested future goal: config compatibility ratchet and migration smoke gate + +## Demo UI Decomposition + +- blocked_by: UI ownership and decomposition scope not part of Layer A-C quality gates +- affected modules: demo UI, generated/static assets, browser-facing flows +- why deferred: would require UI-specific review and assets beyond deterministic backend quality gates +- prerequisite tests: API contracts for UI calls, focused browser smoke tests with deterministic backend fixtures +- trigger condition: UI decomposition work is accepted as a separate feature or maintenance goal +- suggested future goal: UI contract smoke and static asset verification + +## Flow/Node/Operator Boundary Redesign + +- blocked_by: `#315` or successor flow integration redesign +- affected modules: `hugegraph-llm/src/hugegraph_llm/flows/`, nodes, operators, operator return contracts +- why deferred: redesigning execution architecture is beyond test hardening and risks invalidating current smoke evidence +- prerequisite tests: current operator contracts, flow smoke tests, graph-boundary integration tests +- trigger condition: a concrete redesign spec is approved and its compatibility requirements are known +- suggested future goal: flow/node/operator contract migration plan + +## Vector DB Backend Abstraction Cleanup + +- blocked_by: `#240` or successor vector/property embedding abstraction work +- affected modules: vector index, embedding provider adapters, retrievers, rerank paths +- why deferred: broad backend abstraction cleanup could require live service credentials and provider-specific semantics +- prerequisite tests: deterministic vector index contracts, provider wrapper error-surface tests, optional Layer D live backend checks +- trigger condition: target backend abstraction and supported providers are explicitly chosen +- suggested future goal: vector backend compatibility matrix and Layer D provider workflow + +## Broader Dependency and Config Cleanup + +- blocked_by: dependency replacement decisions and config migration direction +- affected modules: root `pyproject.toml`, module `pyproject.toml` files, lockfile, CI install paths +- why deferred: dependency/config replacement can alter the whole workspace and is not necessary for this quality gate +- prerequisite tests: full unit/contract matrix, selected HugeGraph integration, import/collection checks +- trigger condition: dependency replacement is tied to a concrete failing test or accepted maintenance issue +- suggested future goal: dependency update branch with import and runtime compatibility checks + +## Optional MCP and Tool-Surface Integration + +- blocked_by: unclear public contract and likely external service requirements +- affected modules: MCP/tool server surfaces, agent-facing integration points +- why deferred: external tool-surface behavior belongs outside default PR gates until a stable contract exists +- prerequisite tests: deterministic command/tool contract tests, fake transport tests, optional live integration workflow +- trigger condition: maintainers define supported MCP/tool APIs and credentials model +- suggested future goal: MCP/tool contract test suite and opt-in live smoke diff --git a/.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..25e5313a --- /dev/null +++ b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md @@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ +# Final Quality Report + +## Summary + +The HugeGraph AI Quality Program v2 completed P0-G7 on branch `goal-test`. + +The program changed the quality gates from broad, mixed test execution into explicit layers: + +```text +Layer A unit/contract no Docker, no live providers +Layer B HugeGraph HugeGraph 1.7.0, fail when selected service is unavailable +Layer C core smoke deterministic fake LLMs plus production operators/flows +Layer D external opt-in only, not default PR gates +``` + +## Test Matrix + +| Layer | Module | Command | Final result | +|---|---|---|---| +| Layer A | `hugegraph-python-client` | `uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests -m "unit or contract" -q` | 17 passed, 59 deselected | +| Layer A | `hugegraph-llm` | `uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m "unit or contract" -q` | 168 passed, 2 skipped, 134 deselected | +| Layer B | `hugegraph-python-client` | `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests -m "integration and hugegraph" -v --tb=short` | 59 passed, 17 deselected | +| Layer B | `hugegraph-llm` | `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m "integration and hugegraph" -v --tb=short` | 5 passed, 299 deselected | +| Layer C | `hugegraph-llm` | `uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration -m "smoke" -v --tb=short` | 4 passed, 15 deselected | +| Formatting | workspace | `uv run ruff format --check .` | 342 files already formatted | +| Lint | workspace | `uv run ruff check .` | all checks passed | + +## Coverage Baseline and Ratchets + +Baseline artifacts: + +| Artifact | Scope | Coverage | +|---|---|---:| +| `.workflow/quality-program/coverage/client-baseline.json` | initial `pyhugegraph` Layer A | 45% | +| `.workflow/quality-program/coverage/llm-baseline.json` | initial `hugegraph_llm` Layer A | 34% | +| `.workflow/quality-program/coverage/combined-baseline.json` | final combined unit/contract baseline | 39% | + +The combined baseline required `--import-mode=importlib` because both workspace packages expose `tests.conftest` during cross-package collection. + +Initial ratchet areas are documented in `docs/quality/coverage-ratchet.md`: + +- `pyhugegraph` +- `hugegraph_llm.operators.hugegraph_op` +- `hugegraph_llm.operators.llm_op` +- `hugegraph_llm.api` +- `hugegraph_llm.api.models` + +## Commands Run + +Final G6 verification: + +```bash +uv run python -c "import yaml, pathlib; [yaml.safe_load(pathlib.Path(p).read_text()) for p in ['.github/workflows/hugegraph-llm.yml','.github/workflows/hugegraph-python-client.yml']]" +uv run ruff format --check . +uv run ruff check . +uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests -m "unit or contract" -q +uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m "unit or contract" -q +HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests -m "integration and hugegraph" -v --tb=short +HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests -m "integration and hugegraph" -v --tb=short +uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration -m "smoke" -v --tb=short +``` + +Final G7 sanity checks: + +- placeholder scan over `.workflow/quality-program` and `docs/quality`: no unresolved placeholder content after removing self-matches from this report +- `git status --short`: only G7 report, state, and plan files pending before commit +- `uv run ruff format --check .`: 342 files already formatted +- `uv run ruff check .`: all checks passed + +## Production Changes + +| Goal | File | Change | Proving test | +|---|---|---|---| +| G2 | `hugegraph-python-client/src/pyhugegraph/utils/util.py` | Preserve backend error envelope details for non-404 HTTP errors and prefer server `message` over `exception`. | `uv run pytest hugegraph-python-client/src/tests/api/test_response_validation.py -q` | +| G3 | `hugegraph-llm/src/hugegraph_llm/operators/hugegraph_op/commit_to_hugegraph.py` | Map primary-key `label:value` edge endpoints to server-created VIDs and raise explicit vertex creation errors. | `uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/operators/hugegraph_op/test_commit_to_hugegraph.py::TestCommit2Graph::test_load_into_graph_raises_explicit_error_when_vertex_creation_fails -q`; `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/integration/test_hugegraph_boundary.py -v - [...] +| G4 | `hugegraph-llm/src/hugegraph_llm/api/rag_api.py` | Map `/config/llm` to `llm_settings.chat_llm_type`. | `uv run pytest hugegraph-llm/src/tests/api -m "unit or contract" -v --tb=short` | + +No production code changed in G5-G7. + +## Failures, Skips, and Known Risks + +- The original combined coverage command failed with pytest import-path mismatch because both packages define `tests.conftest`; rerun with `--import-mode=importlib` passed. +- Two LLM model tests remain skipped inside the Layer A selection; they are explicit pytest skips, not service-bound silent skips. +- Layer B commands used local HugeGraph `hugegraph/hugegraph:1.7.0` and `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true`. +- GraphRAG smoke emits known NLTK BLEU zero-overlap warnings for short deterministic strings; assertions do not depend on BLEU score value. +- Legacy mock-only integration tests remain documented as future cleanup. New authoritative smoke tests import production code. + +## Deferred Refactors + +Deferred items are documented in `.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md`: + +- async/streaming API full-chain refactor +- YAML config migration +- demo UI decomposition +- flow/node/operator boundary redesign +- vector DB backend abstraction cleanup +- broader dependency/config cleanup +- optional MCP/tool-surface integration + +## Maintainer Review Notes + +- CI now separates default PR gates by layer and keeps external-provider tests out of default execution. +- HugeGraph integration jobs use `hugegraph/hugegraph:1.7.0` and selected integration tests fail when the required service is unavailable. +- Smoke tests are deterministic and exercise production code at KG, GraphRAG, and Text2Gremlin boundaries. +- Coverage ratchets start from local areas instead of imposing a full-repository threshold. + +## Recommended Next Actions + +1. Review CI runtime after the workflow split and adjust matrix breadth if runtime is too high. +2. Decide whether legacy mock-only integration tests should be converted, demoted, or removed. +3. Add targeted ratchet thresholds for the initial areas once maintainers agree on acceptable floors. +4. Re-check open PR collisions before starting any deferred refactor. diff --git a/.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md index 4e1f62cf..5f831617 100644 --- a/.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md +++ b/.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md @@ -2,10 +2,10 @@ | Test or area | Risk | Current mitigation | Future action | |---|---|---|---| -| LLM CI HugeGraph readiness | `sleep 10` can hide slow startup or race with tests | P0 records current issue only | G1 should replace with HugeGraph `1.7.0` service health check | -| LLM external skip control | Global `SKIP_EXTERNAL_SERVICES=true` prevents selected real HugeGraph boundary tests from opting in | P0 records current issue only | G0/G1 should switch to default-only skip semantics and explicit Layer B fixture behavior | -| Client integration selection | Full client suite currently mixes service-bound and local tests | P0 records current issue only | G0/G1 should add markers and fixture-driven selection | -| Open PR collisions | Parallel PRs touch config, vertex IDs, Gremlin examples, flow tests, vector/property embedding, and async API | Quarantine list in `00-preflight.md` | Inspect exact files before goals touching those surfaces | -| Local HugeGraph service for G2 | Local Docker/OrbStack availability can block selected Layer B tests | G2 resumed after starting `hugegraph/hugegraph:1.7.0`; full client integration suite passed with `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true` | Keep using explicit readiness checks and fail selected tests when required service is unavailable | -| Legacy mock-only integration tests | `test_kg_construction.py` and `test_graph_rag_pipeline.py` define local replacement pipeline classes | G5 added production-code smoke tests for KG, GraphRAG, and Text2Gremlin as the authoritative smoke gate | Convert or demote legacy mock-only files after quality program scope | +| Docker HugeGraph readiness | Service startup can be slow or locally unavailable, which can mask whether a selected Layer B test is actually running | CI jobs use `hugegraph/hugegraph:1.7.0` service health checks; local selected integration commands set `HUGEGRAPH_REQUIRED=true` so unavailable service fails instead of silently skipping | Keep health-check retries explicit and record service version in failure reports | +| HugeGraph cleanup | Shared `hugegraph` graph state can leak labels, vertices, edges, variables, or tasks between tests | Layer B fixtures use unique prefixes and cleanup helpers; integration tests were run serially against local `hugegraph/hugegraph:1.7.0` | Add graph/database isolation if HugeGraph supports it consistently for this client version | +| External provider exclusion | Real LLM, embedding, reranker, vector DB, or UI credentials can make default PR tests flaky and secret-dependent | Default gates select unit/contract, HugeGraph integration, and deterministic smoke only; provider live paths remain Layer D | Add opt-in scheduled Layer D workflows with explicit secrets and failure classification | +| Smoke fixture determinism | Smoke tests can become brittle if they depend on live model output or replacement pipelines | G5 smoke tests use deterministic fake LLM output and import production pipeline operators/flows | Keep fixture data small and versioned; reject smoke tests that reimplement production behavior locally | +| Legacy mock-only integration tests | `test_kg_construction.py` and `test_graph_rag_pipeline.py` define local replacement pipeline classes | G5 added production-code smoke tests for KG, GraphRAG, and Text2Gremlin as the authoritative smoke gate | Convert, demote, or remove legacy mock-only tests after maintainers review compatibility needs | | GraphRAG smoke BLEU warnings | Short deterministic strings trigger NLTK BLEU zero-overlap warnings | Assertions check structured non-empty output, not BLEU score value | Consider smoothing or a deterministic scorer if warnings become noisy in CI | +| Open PR collisions | Parallel PRs touch config, vertex IDs, Gremlin examples, flow tests, vector/property embedding, and async API | P0 collision quarantine constrained this program to tests, narrow proven bug fixes, CI gates, and docs | Re-check open PRs before starting any deferred refactor | diff --git a/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-31-hugegraph-ai-quality-program.md b/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-31-hugegraph-ai-quality-program.md index 071fbc38..b1713622 100644 --- a/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-31-hugegraph-ai-quality-program.md +++ b/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-31-hugegraph-ai-quality-program.md @@ -1482,7 +1482,7 @@ git commit -m "ci(quality): split test gates and add coverage ratchet" -m "- sep - Create/Update: `.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md` - Create/Update: `.workflow/quality-program/checkpoints/08-deferred-refactors.md` -- [ ] **Step G7.1: Create deferred refactor report** +- [x] **Step G7.1: Create deferred refactor report** Create `.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md` with one section per item: @@ -1501,7 +1501,7 @@ Create `.workflow/quality-program/reports/deferred-refactors.md` with one sectio Add matching sections for YAML config, demo UI decomposition, flow/node/operator boundary redesign, vector DB backend abstraction cleanup, broader dependency/config cleanup, and optional MCP/tool-surface integration. -- [ ] **Step G7.2: Finalize production change ledger** +- [x] **Step G7.2: Finalize production change ledger** Ensure `.workflow/quality-program/reports/production-change-ledger.md` contains: @@ -1514,7 +1514,7 @@ Ensure `.workflow/quality-program/reports/production-change-ledger.md` contains: Every production file edit from G2-G6 must have a row. -- [ ] **Step G7.3: Finalize flaky risk ledger** +- [x] **Step G7.3: Finalize flaky risk ledger** Ensure `.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md` contains: @@ -1527,7 +1527,7 @@ Ensure `.workflow/quality-program/reports/flaky-risk-ledger.md` contains: Include Docker readiness, HugeGraph cleanup, external provider exclusion, and smoke fixture determinism. -- [ ] **Step G7.4: Write final quality report** +- [x] **Step G7.4: Write final quality report** Create `.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md` with: @@ -1555,7 +1555,7 @@ Create `.workflow/quality-program/reports/final-quality-report.md` with: Include exact commands and final status for each layer. -- [ ] **Step G7.5: Run final sanity checks** +- [x] **Step G7.5: Run final sanity checks** Run: @@ -1568,7 +1568,7 @@ uv run ruff check . Expected: no placeholder text. Ruff checks pass or failures are recorded with exact reason. -- [ ] **Step G7.6: Commit final reports** +- [x] **Step G7.6: Commit final reports** Run: @@ -1581,16 +1581,16 @@ git commit -m "docs(quality): finalize quality program report" -m "- document de ## Plan Self-Review Checklist -- [ ] Spec coverage: P0 maps to preflight/collision gate and state ledger. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G0 maps to strict marker definitions and coverage baseline. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G1 maps to deterministic HugeGraph 1.7.0 service fixtures and CI readiness. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G2 maps to pyhugegraph contract hardening. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G3 maps to `hugegraph-llm` HugeGraph boundary hardening. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G4 maps to parser/API/operator deterministic contract coverage. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G5 maps to production-code core smoke gates and anti mock-only integration rules. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G6 maps to coverage ratchet and CI split. -- [ ] Spec coverage: G7 maps to deferred refactor queue and final report. -- [ ] No task requires real LLM, embedding, reranker, vector DB, or UI credentials in default gates. -- [ ] No task performs async/streaming, YAML config, demo UI, flow/node/operator architecture, dependency-system, or vector DB abstraction refactors. -- [ ] Every production-code change task requires a proving test and ledger entry. -- [ ] Every goal ends with a checkpoint and commit. +- [x] Spec coverage: P0 maps to preflight/collision gate and state ledger. +- [x] Spec coverage: G0 maps to strict marker definitions and coverage baseline. +- [x] Spec coverage: G1 maps to deterministic HugeGraph 1.7.0 service fixtures and CI readiness. +- [x] Spec coverage: G2 maps to pyhugegraph contract hardening. +- [x] Spec coverage: G3 maps to `hugegraph-llm` HugeGraph boundary hardening. +- [x] Spec coverage: G4 maps to parser/API/operator deterministic contract coverage. +- [x] Spec coverage: G5 maps to production-code core smoke gates and anti mock-only integration rules. +- [x] Spec coverage: G6 maps to coverage ratchet and CI split. +- [x] Spec coverage: G7 maps to deferred refactor queue and final report. +- [x] No task requires real LLM, embedding, reranker, vector DB, or UI credentials in default gates. +- [x] No task performs async/streaming, YAML config, demo UI, flow/node/operator architecture, dependency-system, or vector DB abstraction refactors. +- [x] Every production-code change task requires a proving test and ledger entry. +- [x] Every goal ends with a checkpoint and commit.
