[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/NETBEANS-3161?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Timothy Miller updated NETBEANS-3161:
-------------------------------------
Description:
In earlier versions of Netbeans, building an Ant project would automatically
cause jar dependencies to be copied into a "lib" directory under "dist". In
11.1, I found that this no longer worked. I determined that this must be some
kind of incompatibility between NB11 and JDK11 that only manifests during
*project creation time*.
I tested this with the following scenarios:
* NBTest1 – NB8.2 with JDK8
* NBTest2 – NB11 with JDK8
* NBTest3 – NB11 with JDK11
Testing steps:
# Create empty project (Java with Ant > Java Application)
# Right click Libraries and add a dependency (I added a jar)
# Put something trivial in main, like System.out.println
# Click Clean & Build.
# Start a terminal and go to the dist directory.
Projects created in and run in NBTest1 and NBTest2 work just fine. In both
cases, the dependency is copied into the dist directory. A project created in
NBTest3 does not work correctly. The first really weird part is that a project
created in NBTest1 or NBTest2 ALSO works just fine. So the failure occurs only
for projects created in NBTest3.
Then I diff'd all the XML and project files to see what's different between
NBTest2 and NBTest3, and I can't find anything different. All I know is that
even with JDK11, both NBTest2 builds fine, while NBTest3 doesn't. I'm
attacking all three projects.
was:
In earlier versions of Netbeans, building an Ant project would automatically
cause jar dependencies to be copied into a "lib" directory under "dist". In
11.0+, this no longer happens. Projects created in older versions of Netbeans
(e.g. NB 8.x, while using JDK8) still copy their dependencies correctly, but
newly created projects (NB 11.1, while using JDK11) do not. There is an option
under Properties>Build>Packaging to "Copy Dependent Libraries." This is
enabled by default, but turning it off and back on again doesn't fix the
problem either.
Step by step instructions to reproduce:
# Create empty project (Java with Ant > Java Application)
# Right click Libraries and add a dependency (project, jar, or both)
# Add some code to main that references that dependency.
# Click the Run button. (It should run just fine)
# Click Clean & Build.
# Start a terminal and go to the dist directory. Notice that the project jar
file is there, but there's no lib directory.
I diffed some of the nbproject files, and there are some interesting changes.
For instance, build-impl.xml has an entirely new section <target
name="-pre-init-libraries"> that doesn't exist for the older (working) project.
I'm going to go ahead and attach all the nbproject files.
> "Copy Dependent Libraries" doesn't work in NB11.x+ with Oracle JDK 11
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: NETBEANS-3161
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/NETBEANS-3161
> Project: NetBeans
> Issue Type: Bug
> Affects Versions: 11.0, 11.1
> Environment: macOS 10.14.6 (18G95), Oracle JDK 11
> Reporter: Timothy Miller
> Priority: Major
> Attachments: NBTests.tgz
>
>
> In earlier versions of Netbeans, building an Ant project would automatically
> cause jar dependencies to be copied into a "lib" directory under "dist". In
> 11.1, I found that this no longer worked. I determined that this must be
> some kind of incompatibility between NB11 and JDK11 that only manifests
> during *project creation time*.
> I tested this with the following scenarios:
> * NBTest1 – NB8.2 with JDK8
> * NBTest2 – NB11 with JDK8
> * NBTest3 – NB11 with JDK11
> Testing steps:
> # Create empty project (Java with Ant > Java Application)
> # Right click Libraries and add a dependency (I added a jar)
> # Put something trivial in main, like System.out.println
> # Click Clean & Build.
> # Start a terminal and go to the dist directory.
> Projects created in and run in NBTest1 and NBTest2 work just fine. In both
> cases, the dependency is copied into the dist directory. A project created
> in NBTest3 does not work correctly. The first really weird part is that a
> project created in NBTest1 or NBTest2 ALSO works just fine. So the failure
> occurs only for projects created in NBTest3.
> Then I diff'd all the XML and project files to see what's different between
> NBTest2 and NBTest3, and I can't find anything different. All I know is that
> even with JDK11, both NBTest2 builds fine, while NBTest3 doesn't. I'm
> attacking all three projects.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
For further information about the NetBeans mailing lists, visit:
https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/NETBEANS/Mailing+lists
