nuttxpr commented on PR #14914: URL: https://github.com/apache/nuttx/pull/14914#issuecomment-2495548161
[**\[Experimental Bot, please feedback here\]**](https://github.com/search?q=repo%3Aapache%2Fnuttx+13552&type=issues) No, this PR does not fully meet the NuttX requirements as described. While it provides a summary of the changes, it lacks crucial details required for proper review and integration. Here's a breakdown of the missing information: **Summary:** * **Missing "Why":** The summary explains *what* is changed, but not *why*. Why is it necessary to make netstats work without socket import? What problem does it solve? Why is a 'netcheck' command needed? What benefits does it provide? * **Missing "How (details)":** The summary says *what* changes, but not *how* it's implemented. What code modifications were made to achieve these changes? This is essential for reviewers to understand the approach taken. * **Missing Links:** No related NuttX or NuttX Apps issues/PRs are linked, even if none exist. Explicitly stating "N/A" is preferable to omission. **Impact:** * **Too brief:** Simply stating "No impact" is insufficient. While the changes might not introduce user-facing behavioral alterations, there could be impacts on code size, memory usage, or performance. Each impact category (user, build, hardware, documentation, security, compatibility) should be addressed individually, even if the answer is "NO" with a brief justification (e.g., "Impact on build: NO - No changes to the build system or dependencies"). * **Missing consideration of potential impacts:** For example, does the `netcheck` command introduce any security risks (e.g., information leakage)? Does it depend on any specific hardware configurations? **Testing:** * **Insufficient Build Host Information:** "qemu" isn't descriptive enough. Specify the host OS, its version, the QEMU version used, and any relevant details about the QEMU configuration. * **Insufficient Target Information:** "same setup as #14913" requires reviewers to look up another PR. Provide the target architecture (e.g., `qemu-arm`), the NuttX configuration used (e.g., `nsh`), and any other relevant details. * **Meaningless Test Logs:** The provided logs don't demonstrate the functionality of the changes. Show the output of `netstats` before and after the change. Demonstrate the different checks performed by `netcheck` and their expected output for both passing and failing scenarios. Include tests with and without an active telnet connection. **In short:** The PR needs to be significantly more detailed to meet the NuttX requirements. Reviewers need enough information to understand the changes, their motivations, their potential impacts, and how they've been tested. Clear, concise, and complete information is essential for a smooth and efficient review process. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
