nuttxpr commented on PR #15590: URL: https://github.com/apache/nuttx/pull/15590#issuecomment-2597909605
[**\[Experimental Bot, please feedback here\]**](https://github.com/search?q=repo%3Aapache%2Fnuttx+13552&type=issues) No, this PR summary does not meet the NuttX requirements. It lacks critical details. Here's why and how to fix it: **Missing Information in Summary:** * **Insufficient Explanation of the "Why":** "No reason to keep asking for these over and over" isn't an explanation of the underlying problem. What is being asked repeatedly? Why is it unnecessary? What benefit does removing it bring? (e.g., reduces code size, improves performance, simplifies logic, etc.) * **Unclear Functional Change:** "MPFS bootloader only" is too vague. Which *part* of the MPFS bootloader is changed? Be specific (e.g., "The network initialization sequence of the MPFS bootloader...", "The CPU boot counter logic in the MPFS bootloader...", etc.) * **Missing "How":** How does the change fix the `g_cpus_booted` issue? What was the bug, and what's the corrected behavior? How does the change optimize performance? Explain the mechanism (e.g., "Removed redundant checks in the boot sequence," "Optimized a loop in the network initialization," etc.). * **Missing Issue References:** If this relates to any reported issues, link them. **Missing Information in Impact:** * **Specifics on Impact:** "performance optimization" and "fix issue with g_cpus_booted global variable" are too general. Quantify the performance improvement if possible (e.g., "Reduces boot time by X milliseconds," "Reduces code size by Y bytes," etc.). Explain the consequences of the `g_cpus_booted` bug and how the fix resolves them. * **YES/NO Answers:** Use the provided "NO/YES" format for each impact category and elaborate where needed. For example, since this affects performance, the impact on the user is potentially YES. Explain if this is a noticeable improvement or only measurable in specific scenarios. **Missing Information in Testing:** * **Insufficient Detail:** "MPFS" is not enough. Specify the build host (OS, CPU architecture, compiler), the target platform (architecture, board, configuration), and the exact steps to reproduce the tests. * **Missing Logs:** Include actual log output before and after the change to demonstrate the fix and performance improvement. Even if the logs are short, they provide valuable evidence. **Example of an Improved Summary:** ``` This PR optimizes the MPFS bootloader's network initialization sequence by removing redundant queries for the MAC address, which were previously performed on each CPU boot. This reduces boot time, especially in multi-core systems. It also fixes a bug where the `g_cpus_booted` global variable was not incremented correctly when SBI is enabled, leading to inaccurate CPU count reporting. This fixes [NuttX Issue #XXX] (if applicable). ``` By providing more context and specific details, you make it easier for reviewers to understand and evaluate your changes, leading to a smoother and faster review process. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
