John Watkinson wrote:
We are definitely ready and willing to bring the code back in to the Jakarta Commons when the time is right. Our goal was to get it done so that developers (us included) could start using and improving it, but we hope that we can eventually contribute it all back to the Commons.
+1, This sounds like the right approach to me.

1) Should it be a separate project or a branch of Commons-Collections?

It is the case that Java 1.5 classes are NOT binary compatible with previous runtime environments (1.4 and earlier). So, the original Collections have a very long life ahead of them. Also, an enormous number of third-party libraries have the Commons-Collections as a dependency and it will not be possible to ensure binary compatibility between the generic-enabled Commons-Collections and the original library, even if the code is run on the 1.5 platform.
There are numerous good points here. [collections] got a bad name with the 3.0 release for breaking binary compatability. (In fact this was 99% FUD spread by Hani and TSS, because only a couple of constants were incompatible).

However, what it does serve to emphasise is that [collections] must not only be 'clean', but also be perceived to be clean. To me, this means that clever tools like Retroweaver would not be an option.

2) Is there enough support for the 1.5 Collections to warrant a new project?

I agree with the points raised earlier on this topic. Developers may not yet be clamoring for this, but as more of them adopt 1.5, they may begin doing so. Also, a high-profile project like the Commons-Collections could help attract developers to 1.5.
The main problem is keeping bug fixes in sync between the two codebases. However, a separate package structure is the only practical solution to achieve 1.5 collections. Whether it is a separate project is a moot point, and I don't have a strong view either way.

I would expect the package name for collections JDK1.5 to be
 org.apache.commons.collections15

3) What are the open-source credentials of Matt Hall and John Watkinson?

We are the authors of Streamsicle (http://www.streamsicle.com). I have also written SwarmCache (http://swarmcache.sourceforge.net) and MegaMap (http://megamap.sourceforge.net). We are the authors of Starfish, a project that we are in the process of opening (http://www.larvalabs.com/starfish).
Having previous OSS experience will be helpful.

Finally, any ideas from http://collections15.sourceforge.net should also be taken into account.

Stephen

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to