Hi,

No, I dont see problems in freeze interface, with an exception:
_ Java (Commons Math) is not a friendly with linear algebra. We are using vectors like one row (or column) matrix (it is a real pain to use vectors this way), and it is not uncommon multiplies arrays by Euclidean vectors. Moreover vectors are not only Euclidean Spaces (in fact, matrixes are generalization of Vectors) So, to reduce the contact surface and to treat most abstrac concepts, I�d like that Matrix interface inherences from a Vector interface. And using more abstract interface could be easier to freeze a interface.

[]�s
Rodrigo

Mark Diggory wrote:

Very cool Phil,

So, when (which version) would we make this methods available? I'm
concerned that this report suggests that adding methods to an interface
is breaking backward compatibility. When I think the opposite, in that
its breaking "forwards compatibility" of existing application. You tend
to need to break forwards compatibility to make progress on an API's
design.

In out case, adding these methods should only effect a small subset of
the user base (specifically those who may have extended either the
interface or the implementation on their own, effecting them because the
signatures may be incompatible). I'm not even sure if we have anyone in
our userbase actually doing this...

Stray Thoughts:

1.) Should versioning drive development or vis versa (maybe we're
already working on 2.0 if we're breaking compatibility with 1.0)?

2.) I've been dealing with versioning on another project lately, we
adopted the following standard versioning scheme

xx.yy.zz

where

xx: Major version number incremented when major backward incompatible
changes occur.
yy: Minor version number incremented when forwards incompatible changes
occur
zz: Patch version number, incremented when changes neither cause
forwards or backwards incompatibility,

3.) Maybe we should consider making the Interfaces "final"? This would
stop users from extending them and allow us more room to make
additions/removals to the interfaces without the above usecase I
initially referred to occurring above...

-Mark




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to