votes for removing cli 1.0: +1's (binding) Yoav Shapira Henri Yandell Stefan Bodewig Martin Cooper
Stephen Colebourne Brett Porter Dion Gillard Phil Steitz +1's (non binding) Torsten Curdt +0's (binding) Glen Stampoultzis votes for replacing with official cli 1.0: +1's (binding) Yoav Shapira Henri Yandell Stefan Bodewig Brett Porter Dion Gillard Phil Steitz +1's (non binding) Torsten Curdt +0's (binding) Glen Stampoultzis, Martin Cooper if i've made any mistakes, my apologies and please correct them. by my tally, both votes passed. i hope to execute them tomorrow. - robert On Tue, 2005-07-26 at 23:37 +0100, robert burrell donkin wrote: > i have included two separate votes in one email since they are closely > related. > > the commons-cli-1.0 jar in the java repository > http://www.apache.org/dist/java-repository/commons-cli/jars/ is not the > official apache commons-cli 1.0 release. this is a clear apache policy > violation and should be addressed. IMO the only way to address this > issue is to remove the jar from the repository. i will preserve the jar > so that it can made available later. > > however, users are also going to be effected by this change. this has > been discussed at length in numerous threads. this jar could be replaced > (in the java repository) by the officially release jar. this will ensure > that future maven builds will be accurate but may break other builds. > this action is policy neutral. > > i will execute any required actions. > > i propose to tally the votes no earlier than 2400 hours GMT Thursday > 27th July. > > i'm +1 to both proposals > > - robert > > --8<--------------------------------------------------------------------- > [ ] +1 Comply with ASF policy and remove the bogus jar > [ ] +0 Sounds right but too busy to investigate > [ ] -0 Sounds list a bad idea but we should comply with ASF policy > [ ] -1 Leave the jar ever though this breaks the ASF policy > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > --8<--------------------------------------------------------------------- > [ ] +1 Upload the official commons-cli 1.0 release jar > [ ] +0 Sounds ok... > [ ] -0 Sounds bad... > [ ] -1 Do not upload the official commons-cli 1.0 release jar > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > >
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part