On Jun 06, "Nick Hilliard (INEX)" <n...@inex.ie> wrote: > The first, and main one, is that this isn't current operational practice > across a lot of IXPs. It might happen one day that it'll be adopted widely > across IXPs, but as far as I'm aware, we're not at that point yet. When We are not at that point because our plan was to first publish a document with a timeline of future actions. If we have totally misunderstood the process of publishing a RIPE BCOP then we can just move on with the plan and come back in a couple of years to publish the document (if anybody will still care to do the work when ~everybody in Europe will already have adopted it).
> In the case of routing security, there are still difficulties for > organisations who have ASNs, as-sets and route lists which span different > RIRs, and for whom third party IRRDBs provide a reasonable and responsible > mechanism for expressing their intended routing policies. Cutting these I do not believe that this is a real issue: while it may be slightly more convenient for some networks to just dump all route objects in RADB instead of using the appropriate IRR which is authoritative for each prefix, I think that at this point it is a fact that filters are generated as the union of the results from multiple IRRs. So I do not believe that allowing this is worth the troubles which come from using non-authoritative IRRs. > organisations off is not going to help routing security overall - they'll > simply bypass route servers and then the industry will be back to unfiltered > bgp sessions again. The proposal does not specify any actions for non-RS BGP filters, so I am not sure that I understand your point. -- ciao, Marco
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
_______________________________________________ connect-wg mailing list connect-wg@ripe.net https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/connect-wg To unsubscribe from this mailing list, get a password reminder, or change your subscription options, please visit: https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/connect-wg
