On Fri, 19 Nov 2021 05:07:23 GMT, Vicente Romero <vrom...@openjdk.org> wrote:
>> Please review this PR which aims to optimize the implementation of the >> `toString` method we provide for records. A benchmark comparing the >> implementation we are providing for records with lombok found out that >> lombok is much faster mainly because our implementation uses >> `String::format`. This fix is basically delegating on >> StringConcatFactory::makeConcatWithConstants which is faster. >> >> TIA >> >> This is the result of the benchmark comparing records to lombok with vanilla >> JDK: >> >> Benchmark Mode Cnt Score Error Units >> MyBenchmark.base avgt 4 0.849 ± 0.111 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.equals_record avgt 4 7.343 ± 2.740 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.equals_value avgt 4 6.644 ± 1.920 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.record_hash_code avgt 4 5.763 ± 3.882 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.record_to_string avgt 4 262.626 ± 12.574 ns/op >> <------ Before >> MyBenchmark.value_class_to_string avgt 4 30.325 ± 21.389 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.value_hash_code avgt 4 5.048 ± 3.936 ns/op >> >> >> after this patch: >> >> Benchmark Mode Cnt Score Error Units >> MyBenchmark.base avgt 4 0.680 ± 0.185 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.equals_record avgt 4 5.599 ± 1.348 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.equals_value avgt 4 5.718 ± 4.633 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.record_hash_code avgt 4 4.628 ± 4.368 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.record_to_string avgt 4 26.791 ± 1.817 ns/op >> <------- After >> MyBenchmark.value_class_to_string avgt 4 35.473 ± 2.626 ns/op >> MyBenchmark.value_hash_code avgt 4 6.152 ± 5.101 ns/op > > Vicente Romero has updated the pull request incrementally with one additional > commit since the last revision: > > adding the benchmark Regarding the slot limit in `StringConcatFactory`, it's not clear to me the limit of 200 is normative or is merely an implementation note. The limit of 200 slots seems to be arbitrary and shouldn't be baked into the spec. Perhaps this limit can be removed if the splitting logic is moved into `StringConcatFactory`. ------------- PR: https://git.openjdk.java.net/jdk/pull/6403