On 31/Aug/11 05:09, Sam Varshavchik wrote: > Alessandro Vesely writes: > >> [http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ordogh-spam-reporting-using-imap] > > Looking over this, it doesn't really do a lot that cannot be > accomplished in IMAP already. All this is, is just an alias for a > COPY+DELETE+EXPUNGE, or just a fancy way of STOREing a custom keyword, > with, perhaps, the server defining what the keyword is.
Yes, more or less, and bind the command to that configurable action on the server, as you say. Two other ways to accomplish it with IMAP are http://wiki.asrg.sp.am/wiki/Adding_a_junk_button_to_MUAs#Via_IMAP > Reading between the lines, what this is struggling to accomplish is > the ability on the client side to make a generic proclamation: "this > is spam"; and then have this result in some configurable action on the > server. The client does not need to bother to specify what that action > is, presumably the server already knows what it should do with spam. > The server might STORE a keyword for this message. Or move it to some > predetermined folder in the mailbox. Or feed it into some heuristical > spam filter. The server can also decide whether to report spam to the relevant abuse team. This is complicated by considerations on the trustworthiness of the sender, feedback loops, amount of redaction, recipients privacy issues, and the like. Some clients run their own filtering and auto-detect spam. Reporting these messages as well, hopefully with different keywords, may result in better coordination of spam management between server and client. > Only the last action seems to actually add something new – a somewhat > formalized way to have an IMAP client report spam to the server. > There's also a bit that reports only some MIME part of a message as > spam – presumably this is a means of reporting a single message in a > multipart/digest as spam, rather than the digest itself. > > But then there's all the other stuff in there that just useless > duplication of existing functionality, like the option to set a > keyword, or move the message somewhere. I just don't see the point to > all of that. It's getting tiresome to have 2-3 different ways of > accomplishing the same results, in IMAP. All it does is result in > interoperability problems between clients and servers, with different > clients picking different options, and different servers implementing > one of the alternatives more efficiently than other alternatives. Good point. I understood it as a way to quickly stick together a bunch of directives related to the spam at hand. Both client addons and a server scripts may be more easier to code if all parameters are passed within the same operation. However, it is true that they could be used for just setting a keyword, with dubious redundancy. > I always get suspicious when I see something like this. You can't > help but get an impression that there might be dubious, ulterior > motives at play, and somebody is hiding something. I see that this > is being pushed by RIM, aka. blackberry. The conspiracy theorist in > me wants to believe that RIM wants to just put a "Report spam" > button on the Blackberry, without really doing much work > themselves, and burden the server to implement all the > functionality. And when the button is absent, because the server > does not advertise this IMAP extension, it would be the server's > fault of course, rather than the client's lack of an fallback > implementation for an optional IMAP feature. Agreed. Not to talk about all the proprietary spam-aggregation features which ought to be outside the standardization of the command. Thank you for reviewing that draft. -- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Special Offer -- Download ArcSight Logger for FREE! Finally, a world-class log management solution at an even better price-free! And you'll get a free "Love Thy Logs" t-shirt when you download Logger. Secure your free ArcSight Logger TODAY! http://p.sf.net/sfu/arcsisghtdev2dev _______________________________________________ courier-users mailing list [email protected] Unsubscribe: https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/courier-users
