http://www.feedmag.com/templates/default.php3?a_id=1697

Crypto Sees the Light
Christine Kenneally on the breakthrough in quantum cryptography

THE BEST WAY to communicate in secret is to do it in the most public place possible. 
If your message is in code and the code is unbreakable, you can shout it from your 
window, you can put it on a billboard, you can even broadcast it on Oprah if you like. 
Spies around the world can watch the show, but if they don't have the key to your code 
they'll understand nothing, just like everyone else. The problem, however, is that at 
some point you have to give the key to your code to the intended recipient of your 
message. You can't put the key into code. That's just deferring the problem because 
you'll have to give the recipient the key for that as well. You can't do it in public 
because someone might be listening. If a spy gets the key, they crack the code. If 
they crack the code, they get the message, and if they get the message your secret is 
out.
Quantum cryptography is the only way to ensure the absolute safety of a key. This is 
because the key will be protected by the laws of physics. The implementation of 
quantum communication, of which quantum cryptography is one type, is in its infancy. 
Until now, it has been experimentally demonstrated only over very small distances 
(tens of kilometers). Yet in today's issue of Nature, Professor Anton Zeilinger and 
colleagues at the Institute for Experimental Physics in Vienna propose a method that 
could increase the distance of quantum communication tenfold.
The idea of interacting via the quantum realm is as appealing as it is strange. 
Essentially, it involves communication by pure energy. Photons -- light particles -- 
can take on one of four polarizations or states. Such relatively simple changes of 
state can be exploited to convey one of four pieces of information (e.g., one state 
signifies "1," another "0," etc.). If you string a bunch of photons together, a 
relatively complicated message, like the key to a code, can be conveyed.
What makes quantum communication perfect for cryptography is Heisenberg's Uncertainty 
Principle. The principle states that the observation of a quantum system necessarily 
changes that system. It is an extremely odd, but nevertheless fundamental property of 
photons that when unobserved they exist in a state of undecidedness. When they are 
observed, however, the very act of observation forces them to assume a well-defined 
state, which in this case could be a specific polarization. This means that the 
spied-upon photons will carry an indelible record of any third-party observation. By 
comparing a small sample of the received information with the sender, the intended 
recipient of the key can determine if the state of the photons has been significantly 
altered. They may also find that the structure of the message has been changed, 
because it's not possible for an eavesdropper to intercept a quantum transmission 
channel without absorbing some of the photons.
In fact, the mark left by an eavesdropper is proportional to the amount they have 
eavesdropped. So, even though quantum cryptography can't ensure that someone won't try 
to spy on you, it does mean that the recipient of your key can always tell how much a 
third party has been listening in. And once you know someone has been eavesdropping 
enough to determine what the key is, you can pick another key and try again.
How to isolate photons for a message from the abundance of light is one of the 
problems of quantum information systems. "A rough estimate of the amount of light 
particles in a well lit room at any point," says Zeilinger, "is 1015 [one thousand 
million million], that's how small these buggers are." But for quantum cryptography 
you need just a handful. How to transmit that handful once you have them is another 
challenge. Photons can be transmitted through air using lasers or via fiber-optic 
channels. But they are extremely fickle. This means that their state may change over 
distance or they may be absorbed in the transmission channel. While a vast majority of 
the photons pass through air or the glass of a fiber-optic tube successfully, minor 
impurities contained in the glass or air can absorb them. The longer the distance 
between sender and receiver, the greater the number of impurities, and the more likely 
it is that the photons will be lost or altered.
There are a few types of quantum communication. The type that Zeilinger and colleagues 
propose to use exploits the entanglement of photons, which Zeilinger calls "the most 
curious quantum phenomenon there is." Entanglement means that two (or more) photons 
mimic each other's state. For example, if one becomes polarized in a particular 
direction, the other will be, too. What's curious about this relationship is that it's 
non-local. Photons in an entangled pair could theoretically be miles apart, but if you 
treat one, the other reacts correspondingly. So you might have one photon of an 
entangled pair in New York and the person you want to communicate with has the other 
in L.A., and by effecting a change in the New York photon you simultaneously effect a 
change in the L.A. photon. In this way, it's possible to communicate at that instant 
without transmitting a thing.
There are various ways to produce entangled photons, and at this stage, says 
Zeilinger, "it's a fairly random process." Because entanglement degrades over time, 
it's necessary for long-distance communication that a pair be as perfectly entangled 
as possible to begin with. Zeilinger's proposed mechanism, a polarized beam splitter 
(PBS), is a little cube of gas that generates highly entangled states in photons that 
are only weakly entangled, making them robust for long-distance communication. While 
there are no specific plans to build the PBS yet, Zeilinger's team is currently 
bidding on a number of industrial models of quantum communication devices being built 
in Europe; if they win the bid, the models will presumably incorporate some kind of 
PBS device. The PBS would replace an earlier proposed device known as a CNOT gate. It 
would achieve only 50 percent of the predicted results of the CNOT gate, but the PBS 
is still a distinct improvement: According to Zeilinger, it's "wel!
l within the reach of current technology." As is the way with theoretical physics, the 
CNOT gate is a device that doesn't exist, and no one knows how to build it.

Christine Kenneally is an Australian writer who lives in New York.




Reply via email to