All:

In discussions at the Bay Area cypherpunks meeting last Saturday, I was 
repeatedly asked to forward an announcement.  I will be giving the Stanford 
EE380 colloquium talk this Wednesday, May 16, 2001.  The course URL is thus:
        http://www.stanford.edu/class/ee380/

The title of the talk is "Design for Commercial Reliance".  The theme is a 
particular reason why innovation in commercial transaction systems is 
difficult.  With the recent sale of the remaining assets of Cybercash to 
First Data Merchant Services and VeriSign, the initial wave of digital cash 
businesses is now fully over.  The score was 0/3 (Cybercash, First Virtual, 
DigiCash).

I believe it is instructive to see that the predominant payment system used 
over the internet (internet payment order initiation) is the credit card 
system for consumer and the ACH (checks) system for businesses.  The 
internet has been applied to the delivery channel, but the underlying 
financial mechanisms remain identical.  These internet use of these systems 
has been deeply conservative.  Even the only even moderately-successful 
"alternate" system, Paypal, still uses no new transfer mechanism.

New payment systems are an awful business.  They're low margin (they have 
to be, to meet the competition), so they have to be high volume to 
succeed.  Getting to high volume has lousy financial properties.  The 
"bathtub curve" is long and deeper than you'd like.  You have to finance 
not only the NRE (non-recoverable engineering) costs, including data center 
build-out, but also a few years of operating costs before you hit 
volume.  Let's just assume you've got the financing in place and also 
realistically patient financiers who are not dupes.  You have five years to 
break-even from launch, say.

Now you have to do everything possible to ensure that your system has rapid 
uptake.  It has been proven by demonstration at this point (see scoreboard 
above) that press coverage and cheerleading are insufficient.  It doesn't 
matter how much "RAH! RAH! Go Team!" there is.  Wishing doesn't make it so.

Certainly you need brand.  Without being able to quickly communicate what 
the service is about, you won't get rapid uptake, even in the business 
market.  So let's assume your financiers have stumped up for advertising 
and other brand-building activities.  You'll also need differentiation, 
because otherwise why not just use a check or credit card?  Let's assume 
that, too.  (The first wave of internet companies had adequate brand and 
differentiation.)

My claim is that you're still not done.  I'll be talking about a basic 
design failure that would kill uptake or slow it sufficiently that any new 
venture would still fail, even having done most everything else right.

Eric




Reply via email to