Yeah. Of cpunx relevance, hypothetically:
* Laws in Uganda ban anonymous remailers. German operator runs one,
used to libel Ugandans, Ugandan sues and gets default judgement.
Under at least one interpretation of Hague convention, German operator
must pay. The U.S. State Department has already drafted a sample for
to use for collecting Hague judgements:
http://www.cptech.org/ecom/jurisdiction/Sample_Form.pdf
* Currently DMCA does not apply to Europe, allowing those naughty
scandanavians to craft DeCSSware. Now it does. Movie industry sues.
Perhaps the programmers are judgement-proof, but the Internet providers
hosting the material aren't. DeCSS begins to vanish. Freenet to the
rescue, perhaps.
* Botaslavia enacts strict libel law. U.S. resident claims under
Botaslavian law he has been libeled by cypherpunk message posted by
Australian. U.S. resident sues Australian in Botaslavia, gets
judgement.
This is admittedly probably a worst-case analysis. But the fact that
such possibilities are even conceivable should give anyone pause.
-Declan
On Wed, May 16, 2001 at 08:31:05AM -0700, Bill Stewart wrote:
> Looks like lots of potential for ugliness :-)
>
> COPYRIGHT HOLDERS, TELECOMS DEBATE GLOBAL COMMERCE REGULATION
> [The Washington Post, E4.] Hollywood studios and major record companies are
> squaring off against Internet service providers and other communication
> companies over a proposed international treaty aimed at resolving questions
> of legal jurisdiction in the global economy. The proposal, called the Hague
> Convention on Jurisdiction and Foreign Judgments, would require signatory
> countries to recognize and enforce each other's legal judgments in most
> business disputes. It would cover all forms of commercial litigation,
> including libel, defamation, patents almost any issue between two private
> parties suing each other. The first formal negotiations over the treaty's
> terms begin next month in The Hague. The draft treaty comes as nations
> wrestle with how to regulate commerce in an age when more and more companies
> are doing business over the Internet, which knows no geographic boundaries.
> At a conference on the proposal yesterday, representatives of the studios
> and record companies said they hoped the treaty would help them in a global
> game of Whack-a-Mole, where copyright violators are shut down in one
> country, only to pop up in another. But major telecommunications companies,
> including AT&T, Verizon and Cable & Wireless, want to drop the treaty's
> copyright provisions because they fear they could be sued by copyright
> owners who claim their material is being illegally distributed over the
> networks. Marilyn S. Cade, director of Internet and e-commerce law and
> government affairs for AT&T, argues the proposal would allow copyright
> owners to shop around the world for friendly courts and then seek
> enforcement in the U.S. or other countries that have a different approach to
> the same laws. "We are very concerned about forum shopping," she said.