Harmon,
Your original statement was:
> > [judgments] aren't even enforceable
> > from state to state within the US --
> > unless done in fed court, that is.
I said that judgments were enforceable between states (i.e., via a judgment
on a judgment) and that one did not have to go to federal court. (And
contrary to your assertion, it's done all the time.) I stand by my version
of the law. If you wish to argue economics, fine, but get the law right
first.
S a n d y
> -----Original Message-----
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On
> Behalf Of Harmon Seaver
> Sent: 16 May, 2001 14:27
> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject: Re: Proposed international treaty on legal judgements in
> businessdisputes.
>
>
> Sandy Sandfort wrote:
>
> > Harmon Seaver wrote:
> >
> > > It's hard to see how they think they
> > > could enforce judgements internationally
> > > when they aren't even enforceable from
> > > state to state within the US -- unless
> > > done in fed court, that is.
> >
> > That's incorrect. Judgments from one state may be executed in another
> > without going to federal court. "Full faith and credit" is the
> term of art.
> > My recollection is that you have to go to state court to get a
> judgment on
> > your judgment, but it's pretty standard operating procedure.
> >
>
> That's not the same thing -- the original judgement is not
> enforceable in
> another state. Yes, they can go to a state court in the second
> state and *try*
> to obtain another judgement, but it's almost never done except in
> exceptional
> cases where a lot of money is involved *and* the there's actually
> a chance to
> collect from the defendant.
> It's a matter of economics, primarily, rather than law -- if
> you get a
> judgement against someone, they leave the state, you find them,
> then you have
> to either hire another attorney in that state or go there
> yourself, either of
> which is expensive, and might just end up with the defendant moving again.
> Lawyers have an extremely poor record of collecting anything
> after the
> judgement in most cases -- take a walk down to your local
> courhouse and ask to
> look thru the judgements. I used to get paid to do that when I
> was in school --
> pretty amazing how few get collected, unless you're talking about
> the big ones
> against a company instead of an individual, and even then ---
>
> --
> Harmon Seaver, MLIS
> CyberShamanix
> Work 920-203-9633 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Home 920-233-5820 [EMAIL PROTECTED]