Date: Fri, 18 May 2001 00:01:15 +0300 (EET DST)
From: Jei <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: Matthew Gaylor <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: No more privacy

http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/5/19003.html

    Eurocops want seven-year retention of all phone, Net traffic

    [6]By: [7]Andrew Orlowski in San Francisco
    Posted: 16/05/2001 at 20:30 GMT

    The official EU body that represents the member governments will
    recommend the long-term retention of personal data at a meeting with
    the European Commission later this month, according to documents
    leaked to London-based civil liberties journal Statewatch.
    The Council of the European Union, which represents the 15 member
    governments, will discuss implementing a policy originally designed
    with the FBI six years ago. It calls for the retention of "every phone
    call, every mobile phone call, every fax, every e-mail, every
    website's contents, all internet usage, from anywhere, by everyone, to
    be recorded, archived and be accessible for at least seven years,"
    notes the journal.

    The proposal gives law enforcement agencies powers far beyond
    authorised, approved interceptions. Existing provisions permit data to
    be retained for the length of the billing period, up to 90 days.
    The proposals are being rushed in front of the European Commission
    before the European Parliament can agree on a common privacy position
    in June. The Parliament is already working on personal privacy
    legislation, and bouncing the other two European institutions now is
    the Eurocops' best chance of putting their draconian provisions into
    place.

    Anonymity is bad for business

    Last November, the Council's Working Party on Police Co-operation put
    its case succinctly:- "It is impossible for investigation services to
    know in advance which traffic data will prove useful in a criminal
    investigation. The only effective national legislative measure would
    therefore be to prohibit the erasure or anonymity of traffic data."
    The European Commission's Justice and Home Affairs Council will debate
    the proposal on May 28.

    The law enforcement agencies, argues the proposal, must have access to
    "user addresses, equipment identities, user name/passwords, port
    identities, mail addresses etc" The agencies are also to be provided
    with "the full name of the person (company), the residential address
    and credit card details."

    The Council's proposal takes its cue from UK law enforcement body NCIS
    (National Criminal Intelligence Service), which last year [8]proposed
    that telcos and ISPs store data for one year for 'real-time
    monitoring' purposes, after which the data would be archived for seven
    more years in a gigantic new data warehouse.

    This paragraph in the NCIS document justifies the demands:-
    "The Police Service is now in its third major era ... and is now a
    directed patrolling, proactive and reactive investigation service,"
    notes the document. "The Crime and Disorder Act empowers ... the
    national law enforcement bodies in appropriate intrusive data
    collection in their central role. The lack of appropriate legislation
    on communications data retention does not sit happily with this
    strategic direction." [our emphasis]

    A gallery of baddies, ranging from organised crime to the authors of
    the Melissa and I Love You viruses, are evoked to justify the
    draconian new approach to Lauren Order.
    In the looking-glass world of law enforcement, the cops and spooks
    argue that long-term data retention actually boosts the public's faith
    in e-commerce:-

    "The obligation for operators to erase and make traffic data
    anonymous, besides obstructing seriously crime investigations, also
    can lead to a decreasing confidence in, particularly, the electronic
    commerce..." according to the leaked document.

    The EU's own privacy watchdogs - regularly criticised for the opt-outs
    provided to law enforcement agencies - have condemned the move. The
    International Working Group on Data Protection in Telecommunications
    deems the storing of data on all telecommunications and Internet
    traffic for extended periods "disproportionate and therefore
    unacceptable." Even the Council's own documents accept that the cops'
    demands "would probably not be considered proportionate."

    Statewatch editor Tony Bunyan was officially refused the documents on
    the grounds that public oversight would "impede the efficiency of the
    ongoing deliberations".

    Statewatch has launched a new website [9]SOS Europe with Privacy
    International to highlight the proposal. It contains full texts of the
    leaked deliberations [10]here.

    8. http://cryptome.org/ncis-carnivore.htm
    9. http://www.statewatch.org/soseurope.htm
   10. http://www.statewatch.org/news/2001/may/03Cenfopol.htm

**************************************************************************
Subscribe to Freematt's Alerts: Pro-Individual Rights Issues
Send a blank message to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] with the words subscribe FA
on the subject line. List is private and moderated (7-30 messages per week)
Matthew Gaylor, (614) 313-5722  ICQ: 106212065   Archived at 
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/fa/
**************************************************************************

Reply via email to