Steve writes:

> As Tim has mentioned.  Sites with controversial content who wish not to
> be at the mercy of ISPs should consider hosting their content via a P2P
> system (e.g., Mojo Nation.)

> They need only provide an automated redirection Web page with no
> controversial content and a Mojo-style link and instructions for
> downloading the Mojo client to make the transition.

I took a quick look at the documentation and code for Mojo Nation.

A few questions...

It looks like the system works best hosting static content.  A
controversial web board can scroll everything off every 2-3 days, and the
index, which is huge, changes every time a message is posted.

I get the impression one would fill the block servers with tons of stuff
that ceases being relevant a few days later.  Is there a mechanism for
expiring this content?

How long does "publishing" take?  Would it be competative with what now
constitutes "posting?"

The client looks complex, and the requirement that users run services in
order to participate looks like a huge barrier to entry for the average
peon.  Could hackers do damage by running compromised clients?

Despite snide remarks about "boards catering to homosexual pedophiles,"  
the resources in question are widely read, and bandwidth is a major cost
of operation.  If a 140k index doesn't refresh in seconds when the person
hits "Reload," the service is going to be considered woefully inadequate.

The resources in question are heavily moderated, so that trolls do not
post inflammatory or illegal things in order to get them shut down.  
Publishing under Mojo Nation doesn't appear to be an easily reversible
process, and there seems to be no way of deleting bad content instantly,
and having all copies of it disappear.

I suppose it's theoretically possible to run a Web message board as a Peer
to Peer application.  But bear in mind that since the content is not
illegal, the server can't be seized.  The problem here is not one of
hosting banned material, it is one of finding a wire to plug the server
into, to connect it to the rest of the world.

The obvious solution is simply to pay a premium for bandwidth, from a
provider who agrees to take the heat, in return for the excess cash.

This becomes more complicated when that provider's upstream provider wants
to police content as well, or when people with big pipes decide to block
the IP.

-- 
Eric Michael Cordian 0+
O:.T:.O:. Mathematical Munitions Division
"Do What Thou Wilt Shall Be The Whole Of The Law"

Reply via email to