NO The examples are inconsistent with regards to the use of the class numbers, both internally and in relation to other examples.
Secondly, the transformation should be physical -- the /use/ of a church as a stable is not /necessarily/ a physical transformation. A clearer example should be selected please. Rob On Tue, Oct 6, 2020 at 8:35 AM George Bruseker <george.bruse...@gmail.com> wrote: > Dear all, > > In 11/2018 a discussion was started to revise the scope note of E81 > Transformation and to change the ranges of its relative properties p123 and > p124. In brief, it was argued that the range of the class was too broad > (E77 Persistent Item) and that it should be limited to E18 Physical Thing. > This change was accepted. You can find the history here: > > > http://www.cidoc-crm.org/Issue/ID-404-modification-of-scope-notes-and-ranges-for-e81-p123-p124 > > To support the new definition of the class and its properties new examples > were sought after. The HW was assigned to ET and AK. They have come up with > the following examples for the classes and relations in question. > > The proposed examples are to be found in the text pasted below. > > Please vote if you accept the examples. You can vote yes, yes with caveat > or no with explanation. Please vote by October 16, 2020. > > E81 Transformation > > Subclass of: E63 Beginning of Existence > > E64 End of Existence > > > Scope note: > > This class comprises the events that result in the simultaneous > destruction of one or more than one E18 Physical Thing and the creation of > one or more than one E18 Physical Thing that preserves recognizable > substance and structure from the first one(s) but has fundamentally > different nature or identity. > > Although the old and the new instances of E18 Physical Thing are treated > as discrete entities having separate, unique identities, they are causally > connected through the E81 Transformation; the destruction of the old E18 > Physical Thing(s) directly causes the creation of the new one(s) using or > preserving some relevant substance and structure. Instances of E81 > Transformation are therefore distinct from re-classifications (documented > using E17 Type Assignment) or modifications (documented using E11 > Modification) of objects that do not fundamentally change their nature or > identity. Characteristic cases are reconstructions and repurposing of > historical buildings or ruins, fires leaving buildings in ruins, taxidermy > of specimen in natural history. > > Examples: > > - the death and mummification of Tut-Ankh-Amun (transformation of > Tut-Ankh-Amun from a living person to a mummy) (E69, E81, E7) > - The death and petrification of the people of Pompeii during the > eruption of Vesuvius in the first century B.C (E69, E81, E7) > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > from a church to a stable for the French cavalry in 1795 (following > Napoleon’s invasion) > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > building from printing house to a bookshop in 2006 > > > In First Order Logic: > E81(x) ⊃ E63(x) > E81(x) ⊃ E64(x) > > Properties: > P123 resulted in (resulted from): E18 Physical Thing > P124 transformed (was transformed by): E18 Physical Thing > > P123 resulted in (resulted from) > > Domain: E81 Transformation > Range: E18 Physical Thing > Subproperty of: E63 Beginning of Existence. P92 brought into existence > (was brought into existence by): E77 Persistent Item > Quantification: many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n) > > Scope note: This property identifies the E18 Physical Thing or things that > are the result of an E81 Transformation. New items replace the transformed > item or items, which cease to exist as units of documentation. The physical > continuity between the old and the new is expressed by the link to the > common Transformation. > > Examples: > > - the transformation of the Venetian Loggia in Heraklion into a city > hall (E81) resulted in the City Hall of Heraklion (E22) > - the death and mummification of Tut-Ankh-Amun (E81) resulted in the > Mummy of Tut-Ankh-Amun (E22 and E20) > - The death and the carbonization by the intense heat of a 300 °C gas > cloud (E69) of the people of Pompeii resulted in petrified and later > preserved in plaster bodies (E22). > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > into a stable (E81) resulted in Stable for the French Cavalry (E22) > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > into a bookstore (E21) resulted in the Selexyz Dominicanen bookstore (E22) > > In First Order Logic: > P123(x,y) ⊃ E81(x) > P123(x,y) ⊃ E18(y) > P123(x,y) ⊃ P92(x,y) > > P124 transformed (was transformed by) > > Domain: E81 Transformation > > Range: E18 Physical Thing > > Subproperty of: E64 End of Existence. P93 took out of existence (was taken > out of existence by): E77 Persistent Item > > Quantification: one to many, necessary (1,n:0,1) > > Scope note: This property identifies the E18 Physical Thing or things that > have ceased to exist due to a E81 Transformation. > > The item that has ceased to exist and was replaced by the result of the > Transformation. The continuity between both items, the new and the old, is > expressed by the link to the common Transformation. > > Examples: > > - the transformation of the Venetian Loggia in Heraklion into a city > hall (E81) transformed the Venetian Loggia in Heraklion (E22) > - the death and mummification of Tut-Ankh-Amun (E81) transformed the > ruling Pharao Tut-Ankh-Amun (E21) > - The death and the petrification of the people of Pompeii during the > eruption of Vesuvius transformed the people of Pompeii (E21) > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > into a stable for the French cavalry (E91) transformed the Dominicaner Kerk > building in Maastricht. > - The transformation of the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht > into a bookstore transformed the Dominicaner Kerk building in Maastricht. > > > > Very much obliged, > > George Bruseker > Vice Chair CIDOC CRM SIG > _______________________________________________ > Crm-sig mailing list > Crm-sig@ics.forth.gr > http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig > -- Rob Sanderson Director for Cultural Heritage Metadata Yale University
_______________________________________________ Crm-sig mailing list Crm-sig@ics.forth.gr http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig
